DeSantis signs bill to defund DEI programs at Floridaโs public colleges
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a bill into law that would bar the stateโs colleges and universities from spending money on diversity, equity and inclusion programs, and limit how race can be discussed in some courses.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis speaks on a book tour in Des Moines on March 10, 2023. (Rachel Mummey for The Washington Post)
ย
Listen
2 min
Comment2412
ย
Giftย Article
ย
Share
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) signed a bill into law Monday barring the stateโs colleges and universities from spending money on diversity, equity and inclusion programs, and limiting how race can be discussed in many courses.
ย
The move comes amid a larger conservative attack on higher education DEI programs, which DeSantis and others say reinforce racial divisions and promote liberal orthodoxy. Supporters of the programs say they are critical to serving the nationโs increasingly diverse student populations.
ย
โIf you look at the way this has actually been implemented across the country, DEI is better viewed as standing for discrimination, exclusion and indoctrination,โ DeSantis said at a news conference at New College of Florida in Sarasota. โAnd that has no place in our public institutions. This bill says the whole experiment with DEI is coming to an end in the state of Florida.โ
ย
ย
Floridaโsย new lawย prohibits public colleges from spending state or federal money on DEI efforts. These programs often assist colleges in increasing student and faculty diversity, which can apply to race and ethnicity, as well as sexual orientation, religion and socioeconomic status.
The law also forbids public colleges from offering general education courses โ those that are part of a required curriculum for all college students โ that โdistort significant historical events,โ teach โidentity politics,โ or are โbased on theories that systemic racism, sexism, oppression, or privilege are inherent in the institutions of the United States and were created to maintain social, political, or economic inequities.โ
The Florida legislation has beenย met with backlashย at both the state and national level, where higher education experts and First Amendment advocates say the state is trampling on academic freedom. โItโs basically state-mandated censorship, which has no place in a democracy,โ Irene Mulvey, president of the American Association of University Professors, said in a recent interview with The Washington Post.
ย
ย
DeSantis said students who want to study โniche subjects,โ such as critical race theory, ought to look elsewhere. โFloridaโs getting out of that game,โ he said. โIf you want to do things like gender ideology, go to Berkeley. Go to some of these other places.โ
The governor held the signing on the campus of New College of Florida, a public liberal arts college in Sarasota, where the governor recently appointed a crop of conservative trustees. Eliminating New Collegeโs DEI office was among the newly constituted boardโs first orders of business.
The event drew protests, whose chants could be heard inside the bill-signing ceremony.
Along with their parents and two health care providers, two trans teens are suing the state of Montana for its recent ban on gender-affirming care for trans youth.
Theย plaintiffs argueย that the law, S.B. 99, violates the state constitution, which guarantees the right to equal protection, the right of parents to direct the upbringing of their children, the right to dignity, and the right to seek healthcare.
Her lawsuit to be allowed back in failed right as the legislative session ended. Some of her colleagues were happy to see her.
The lawsuit, which was filed on behalf of the plaintiffs by the ACLU of Montana and Lambda Legal, also argues the unjust nature of the law because it bans gender-affirming care for trans youth but allows cisgender youth access to the same medical care for other reasons.
โThe Act is so damaging to the health and well-being of transgender adolescents that some of these adolescentsโ families with the resources to do so have taken steps to uproot their entire lives to move out of Montana in light of the Act,โ the lawsuit states.
โFor many more, however, that devastating option is not available, so these families and youth will have no choice but to remain and endure the harms that the Act inflicts.โ
The litigants include 16-year-old trans girl Scarlet, along with her parents Jessica and Ewout van Garderen; 15-year-old trans boy Phoebe, along with his parents Molly and Paul Cross; Dr. Katy Mistretta of Bozeman Creek Family Health; and Dr. Juanita Hodax of Community Medical Center.
โI will never understand why my representatives are working to strip me of my rights and the rights of other transgender kids,โ saidย Phoebe Crossย in a statement.ย โJust living as a trans teenager is difficult enough, the last thing me and my peers need is to have our rights taken away. There were many things I hoped my elected officials would achieve, this regression in human rights is not one of those things. The blatant disrespect for my humanity and existence is deeply unsettling.โ
Jessica van Garderen added, โIt is mentally and physically painful to feel like you are trapped in the wrong body. Going through puberty for the wrong sex is like having your body betray you on a daily basis. The only treatment we have found to be effective and give our daughter hope again is hormone therapy. The difference we have experienced is night and day and there is no going back. Taking away this crucial medical care is inhumane and a violation of our rights. We will fight this law for our daughter and every other family whose rights are being trampled.โ
The legislation was signed in April by Republican Gov. Greg Gianforte and will go into effect on October 1. The state became the center of national discourse after the anti-trans Republicans banned trans Montana state Rep. Zooey Zephyr (D) from the state house floor for speaking out against the bill.
Zephyr accused Republicans of having โblood on your handsโ for supporting the bill. They then voted to prevent her from entering the chamber after she raised an inactive microphone toward protestors in the state house galleryย who chanted, โLet her speak!โย The protestors were later arrested.
Zephyr was forced to vote remotely on bills while sitting on a bench outside the chamber in the state Capitol building. She also filed a lawsuit, but the judge declined to grant her relief from the Republicansโ censure order.
She would remain barred from the state house floor until the legislative session was adjourned. It has since ended, and sheย made a triumphant return.
This is done by Christian Nationalists, not Christians.ย ย I want to be as clear as I can that I no longer think of these religious zealots as Christians.ย They are not religious for the moral teachings, they are not interested in living by a personal code to do the right thing towards others.ย They are not interested in the truth or history of their religion.ย ย No instead they simply want to gain power and then to use that power to force others to do as their church doctrines demand.ย It is not about them living as their religion tells them to, it is about making others, the nonbelievers in their views, forcing those others to live as the Christian Nationalists believe / demand they must.ย I want to be clear that I don’t blame people who use their religious faith as a guide to their own life for the acts of these US Taliban or wannabe moral police.ย This is the same thing the Muslim Taliban did the first time they controlled Afghanistan when they destroyed very valuable old statues claiming they were offensive to their god.ย The Christian Nationalist railed constantly against the Muslim countries ruled by their religious zealots / church leaders, yet they are trying to do the very same thing here in the US demanding their god / religion be in charge of the government and laws be enacted to make everyone live according to their church doctrines / rules.ย ย ย Hugs
Porter Sculpture Park, listed by TIME Magazine as one of the top 50 American Roadside attractions in 2010, was vandalized Wednesday, May 10. It will now take up to several years to repair the damage, said the creator and operator of the park Wayne Porter.
His sister Audrey Porter said that when she got a call from her brother that Wednesday around noon, she immediately realized that something was wrong as usually it was her who was calling her brother and not the other way around.
โI call him, he doesnโt call me, he might text me about things, but he doesnโt [call],โ said Porter.
That Wednesday morning, Porter went to check on his sculpture park, for the annual opening of the new season planned for May 15.
Porter was in the far northwest corner of the 18-acre park west of Sioux Falls when he noticed that someone had apparently visited the place before him this year. His sculpture group of the bull and its four guardians was vandalized.
ย
The guardians, which look like human-sized skeletons with protruding ribs and goat-like faces and horns stationed around the bull, were beheaded, and the heads were gone. The bullโs base was spray-painted with the messages โSatan is defeated,โ and โJesus is King.โ
A few other sculptures, including the Irish monks and a sculpture depicting the artistโs brother, have also been vandalized. Porter said that it will take him more than a yearโs worth of work to replace the pieces that were stolen if they cannot be recovered.
His sister noted that the worst part of it is that it all came up just before their opening for the new season. It usually takes them a few days and several adults to get the place running at the best circumstances, she said.
โThere will be four strong adults working on it under the best of circumstances, and itโs a big job.”
Her brother said that in the past there had already been a few instances of vandalism in the park, but they were usually limited to minor issues, including spray-painting, but that did not bother him a lot because he could repaint pieces if needed.
โI donโt care about paint, I will just paint over,โ said Porter. โIt does happen occasionally.โ
His sister said that from time to time they were getting a comment on their social media that referred to the bull sculpture as Moloch. Moloch is a deity mentioned in some religious texts as a deity whose worship was marked by the sacrifice of children by their own parents.
ย
Both Porter and his sister said they never heard the term before. Porter noted that when it first came about, he looked it up, and discovered that the deity had arms and legs, while his sculpture was clearly a bull.
His sister noted that she remembered that some of the visitors would come up to her and mention that they felt Satanic influence associated with the park sculptures, while at the same time they would also get visitors that would come up to her and say that her brother must be the worldโs best Christian.
Porter said that while neither of that was true, she could assert that her brother was the kindest human being on the planet. It was the essence of art, Porter noted, to reveal what the spectators already carry around with them.
โArt is whatever people bring with them, and whatever they want to see โ they see,โ she said.
The sculptor himself said that his bull had a neo-Egyptian art influence about it. Porter, a graduate of South Dakota State University with a degree in political science and history, said he was fascinated with the ancient Egyptian empire.ย
After graduating from the university, Porter used to run a sheep farm. Although not a professionally trained artist, Porter has been making sculptures since he was a child helping in his fatherโs blacksmith shop.
Both his historical background, as well as his rural experiences are now evident in his sculptures although they are so varied in styles that people think it might be several artists working on them. He said he is an outsider artist, who doesnโt know art words.
โI am all over the place,โ said Porter.
During his time at the sheep farm, he continued to make sculptures whenever he had some spare time, and over the years he accumulated dozens of them.
โThe sculptures added up over a long period of time,โ said Porter.
Eventually, people started to want to come and see them, and when they did, they wanted to pay for what they saw even though Porter initially declined, and that was how the sculpture park gradually got going.
Potter said that his urge to make a bull sculpture came from his experiences of growing up in St. Lawrence, Hand County, with a population of less than 200 people. The surrounding area, he said, has always been known as a cattle region and home to famous rodeo riders, such as the Etbauer brothers.
ย
The Porters noted that although the majority of their social media followers were supportive of them after the incident, they still got a few comments stating that โthe vandalism was justified in the name of God.โ But the family said they had no assumptions on who committed the act of violence.
โMost people are good people, but you have a slim sliver of crazies,โ said Porter. โThey are clearly violent.โ
In addition to simply being art pieces, Porterโs sculptures are also part of his personality. He said that he himself pounded every square inch of them with a hammer. His sister said that her brother puts his whole life in his sculptures, and the recent attack hit hard on him.
โHe puts his whole life into his sculptures,โ said Porter. โHe canโt even sell them, they become a part of who he is, and he keeps them.โ
The Porters family asked anyone who might have tips on the whereabouts of the guardiansโ heads to contact the McCook County Sheriffโs Office at 605-425-2761. The family announced a $1,000 reward for the return of the stolen heads.
I would not have known that this had happened except for JMG posting it. But, believe me, if the reverse had happened and Satanists had vandalized a cross or some other Christian symbol this would be a major news story, especially on right–wing media. Hannity would talk about it for days! Every right-winger would be ranting about “Christian persecution in this country.” Tolerance is certainly not a Christian virtue.
Remember when a 10 Commandments monument in Oklahoma City was destroyed when a guy drove his car into it? They absolutely flipped out and were working on getting it replaced that day.
(Of course, the replacement was later removed because of that pesky rule about not singling out a religion for promotion by the gov’t, and they weren’t going to let anyone else put up a monument for their religion or lack thereof…)
It never was. They claim to follow Christ, but they have no idea what Christ was all about. They should read the Sermon on the Mount. It pretty much spells it out for them.
Fucking tax the churches. Christianity is the most destructive political and genocidal motivator of the past two thousand years. They can at least pay.
This is an important article and I hope everyone takes a minute to read it.ย ย Then think about what happened.ย ย A teacher had permission slips to show Disney catalog of movies to her students, and every parent said yes they were OK with their children seeing the Disney movies.ย ย Then this movie Strange World was show and one parent freaked out and filed a complaint against the teacher.ย ย Think of it, again one maga right winger maybe highly religious parent gets to derail the public education of all students to push their rabid right wing agenda.ย ย
So what was in the movie that could be that offensive, you ask?ย I did ask that, so Ron and I bought the movie for 20 dollars off Amazon Prime.ย ย Almost from the start, I saw what these MAGA right-winger republican types would hate.ย ย The parents were a loving couple who loved to smooch and kiss as they made breakfast, all very clean and not sexual / porn, just mom and dad quick cute kisses.ย So what is offensive about that to the maga?ย ย Well if you have seen the trailer you know that the mom is black and the dad is white.ย ย Which leads to the next maga issue.ย ย
The son, Ethan Clade, is a mixed race drawn with darker skin tone openly gay boy who is accepted by his family and his friends.ย ย In the opening get to meet the characters part of the movie, Ethan’s friends show up with some kind of game cards.ย With them is a boy Ethan has a crush on and the movie plays out letting us know in a funny sweet way of Ethan being shy around the boy.ย But the movie also makes it clear that the boy Ethan has a crush on likes Ethan as well along with all the friends being OK / happy with the boys being gay and liking each other.ย ย That is when the dad interrupts them and does the dad meeting his son’s boyfriend stating to Ethan how he likes the boy, saying something like he can see why Ethan likes him.ย ย I thought the movie was cute at this part, as most teenagers are embarrassed of their parents around their friends and to meet the one they have a crush on.ย ย
Which leads us to the the last part I think the maga people get angry at.ย Remember I have only gotten about a 1/4 of the way into the movie but in the movie the mother, who is black remember, is the outgoing adventurous one who manages to swoop in and save the flying ship.ย ย Imagine the maga people going crazy that a black woman acts to save everyone while the white people cling to the ship trying to hang on.ย ย Oh and also the women in the movie so far are more the adventurers and seeming more capable than the main white man character so far.ย Another thing I guess makes maga right-winger upset, the movie destroys their gender role stereotypes.ย ย
In all I like the movie so far.ย It is inclusive in a way that real life is.ย It is drawn and colored in bright vivid colors.ย The dialog and action is fun to watch.ย I have not watched a lot of movies in the last few years and I have not watched any animated ones.ย ย But I am really enjoying this one.ย ย But I can see why the republican right winger maga want to destroy Disney and take over what kinds of shows / movies they produce.ย ย This movie is a very far place from the stereotypical gender role models and public social standards of the 1950s that the maga are desperate to return the country to.ย ย Hugs
ย
ย
Purported investigation after screening of Disney animated movie comes amid governor Ron DeSantisโs attacks on educators
DeSantis has claimed, without evidence, that there is โindoctrination in our schoolsโ.ย Photograph: Daniel A Varela/AP
Florida education officials allegedly told a school teacher that she was under a misconduct investigation after, her friend claimed, she showed students the Disney animated film Strange World.
The purported investigation following this alleged showing of Strange World comes amid rightwing Republican governor Ron DeSantisโs attacks on educators that includeย book censorshipย and limitations on discussions of race and sex as he jockeys for his partyโs presidential nomination with โanti-wokeโ talking points.
———————————————————————————
ย
ย
โThe point is intimidationโ: Florida teachers besieged by draconian laws
โMy friend showed Disneyโs Strange World in a Florida classroom and one student reported it to their parents. Now sheโs under investigation by the state,โ Carl Zeeย tweetedย on 11 May. โFlorida is not safe for teachers, DO NOT MOVE HERE.โ
The film involves a group of explorers who try saving a โmysterious land from losing its vital energy sourceโ,ย per Variety. It also has aย prominent gay characterย โ a rarity in childrenโs animation.
Zee included a photo of a letter from the Florida department of education, stating that โfollowing receipt of a receipt of a complaint, this office has determined an investigation is warranted into allegations that you engaged in inappropriate conductโ.
โIf you have evidentiary witnesses or documents pertinent to the case, send them to this office no later than two weeks from receipt of this letter,โ the alleged missive continues. CBR.comย first reportedย on Zeeโs Tweet.
The alleged letter does not state specific allegations against this teacher. The Florida department of education did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
In response to a Twitter user who said that teachers who break the law find themselves under investigation, Zee wrote: โShe has signed permission from every parent in the classroom to show Disney & Dreamworks movies in class, even offering lines to specify specific movies parents didnโt want shown. Not one exception was written down, so no she didnโt break the law. Try again, doofus.โ
News of the alleged investigation is in keeping with Florida teachersโ concerns that they are being stymied and intimidated by new legislation championed by DeSantis. He has claimed, without evidence, that there is โindoctrination in our schoolsโ and allowed his press secretary to claim that teachers are โgroomingโ pupils.
A new Florida law has effectively resulted in book bans, with classrooms and libraries removing books over concerns they contain โinappropriateโ content.
One high school English teacher in Palm Bay, Florida,ย told the Guardianย that a librarian took away a third of the books in his classroom โ among them a collection of Emily Dickinsonโs poems, which was not on her list of green-lighted books.
DeSantis has also assailed Disney as a company after the entertainment titan pushed back against his โdonโt say gayโ legislation. He hit back at Disney by signing a bill that took away Disneyโs status as a self-governing special district near Orlando.
Disneyย fought backย against DeSantis, filing a federal lawsuit contending that he retaliated against the company for expressing its first amendment right to free speech. In the suit, Disney is asking to stop the governorโs attempted takeover of the special district.
My friend showed Disneyโs Strange World in a Florida classroom and one student reported it to their parents. Now sheโs under investigation by the state.
Tell the teacher to show the kidsย Song Of The Southย and all will be forgiven. It’s hard to find since Disney threw it in the vault and ate the key, but the DeSantis crowd will love him/her for it.
I’ll bet that teachers and medical professionals will also be leaving, as well as high school graduates who want a real college education. It’s a crime what republicans are doing.
Yep, my daughter’s teacher friend from Florida already packed it in and moved away to a blue state where she gets paid a LOT more and has more freedom to teach. She is urging her fellow teachers stuck in that hell hole to get the fuck out now.
They’ve already got a plan in place to hire less-than-honorably-discharged ex-military and rogue cops to teach the kids. They will be armed at all times so the kids will be totally safe.
So, there literally is a war against one of the most popular companies in the world right there in Florida. Evangelicals can literally destroy anything.
Investigating a teacher for showing a Disney film? Migrant workers are leaving your state in droves, which will affect construction projects, the gathering of crops, the hotel and hospitality sector of tourism, and God knows what else, and you’re still trying to stomp on Disney by going after a teacher for showing a film? Lord love a duck, just how stupid are you, Ron?
Don’t forget that the SEAWEED MONSTER has come to destroy their beaches and recreational tourism, but let’s focus on a fricken kids animated movie that might have a gay cartoon character in it.
One parent complained. ONE. So nobody gets to watch it. That sure sounds like cancel culture to me. I’ll bet the parent who complained didn’t even have any children in the school.
I live in Michigan, so I am allowed to make this statement:ย The Lions have demonstrated an ability to consistently disappoint their fans to a level only surpassed, maybe, by the Cleveland Browns.ย And yet, my uncle was not only a great fan of the Lions team but wouldnโt miss a game on tv.ย That, my friends, is the mark of a true fan:ย it isnโt the fact that the product is the best in quality, best in performance, best in taste, itโs the fact that a fan is a fan for no better reason than he has chosen to be a fan.ย Thereby lives a love of heartbreak, ridicule, and a test of loyalty sufficient to scar any soul forever.ย ย I of course come from much better stock:ย I am a fan of the Chicago Bears.ย Da Bears!ย ย If youโve not solved this puzzle by now, this is not about the Lions.ย Donโt get me wrong, they will forever disappoint โ Sorry Uncle Bob โ butย this post regards how a beer company has received backlash for sending beer to someone who is an internet influencer.ย Now, there are few things in this world that I purposely choose not to pay attention to, and among those are the Lions and things that republicans and rednecks have chosen to cancel in their anti-cancel-culture rants. ย Yes, thatโs confusing.ย It makes more sense if you drink a lot of low-quality beer and believe what Tucker Calson tells you.
Loyalty trumps Competence, as the saying goes.ย And, while there are those who believe Bud Light cheated on them, I expect to find all of those who have made a lifetime commitment with their Bud Light beer that has weathered two marriages, four kids, eight teeth and 29-stories that start with โdude, hold my beerโฆโ will be drinking again like nothing happened. ย ย In time they will forget why they were mad at a beer โ because letโs face it, who gets mad at beer?ย And, those of us watching from the sidelines, even as reluctantly as I, will remember that this was never about the beer, never about the internet influencer, but was ultimately about the homo- and the trans-phobic prejudice and hate that was so easily stirred to cause the easily led to put down their favorite beer.
I, for one, am going to continue to buy Bud Light.ย Mainly because itโs very drinkable โ as the joke goes itโs much like sex in a canoe.ย ย ย What I would like to hear them ask these detractors is why they are so against someone being who they are? Who are they to not only disparage the character of that person, but to speak as if a beer company deserves to be shot for treating a person as a living and worthwhile person?ย Each of us in America is born with the freedom to voice our opinion.ย It bothers me that so many have chosen to use this freedom to be so manipulated as to only be able to speak hate and so weak as to give up a beer they appear to love for the affront of giving another citizen simple respect.ย What are they truly angry or afraid of?
— Tony Michaels ๐ (@thetonymichaels) May 13, 2023
I love Randy’s writing.ย ย He has a way of getting his heartfelt ideas across with words that few can manage.ย I am glad he has offered to add his voice here.ย When Randy was talking with me on this post, he mentioned it might help people understand how stupid this unwarranted hate response was if people could see the video that these bigots are responding to.ย ย Also remember that these cans of beer with Dylan Mulvaney’s picture on them were not mass-produced, were never for sale to the public.ย ย These few cans were just a promotional gimmick and were not intended for putting in stores.ย ย This was not a national commercial but only on social media.ย ย If the bigots and haters had ignored it, then very few would even have known of the entire thing.ย ย But the haters managed to gin this up using a fake outrage over something not happening and getting people who drink a mediocre mass-produced beer to question their own manhood.ย That was what this was about, men fearing a beer that had let a trans woman promote it made them less than a man if they drank it, made them less masculine, maybe others would question the size of their penis by the beer they drank because a few cans had a trans woman on them.ย ย That is what this is really about, look at how the men reacted in destroying the cans of beer, with displays of macho destruction while yelling about how manly they are.ย ย In fact most hate of trans people is about fear of measuring up to some mythical stereotypical standards for what is masculine or feminine.ย ย ย Below is the social media promotion by Dylan Mulvaney.ย ย Hugs
*** it was hard to find just the video with no commentary added.ย The comments are the YouTube page constantly cisgender Dylan as he and calling her a gay man.ย Dylan Mulvaney identifies as a trans woman, and she is proud to be a woman.ย ย Hugs
A remarkable student comes forward at a school board meeting and shares the importance of lgbtq+ rights and transgender rights. The students shares the struggles the trans community faces in states like Missouri, North Carolina and Florida. The transgender community needs support now more than ever, especially in the young people like this student here.
Damn amazing!ย ย ย I think this boy will go far in life, and it gives me hope for the future.ย ย We need more young people like him.ย Sadly the school board won’t listen to him or his supporters.ย ย They have their idea that adults know so much more than kids do about their own body.ย ย Why because their god tells them this in a book written 2,500 years ago amended and incorrectly translated over centuries, that this boy can not exist.ย ย Their personal view of 1950s gender ideology and their political desires make this boy’s testimony something they scoff at and won’t hear.ย ย Yet in a few years this boy and his friends will vote these people out of office if we still have a democracy.ย ย And that terrifies these religious conservative bigots enough that they want to do way with democracy and allowing people to vote.ย ย ย Hugs
This post is for those that mistakenly thought these anti-drag bills were about protecting kids from sexualized burlesque type shows.ย ย The law is written very clearly to stop men from dressing like women and women from dressing like men in public.ย ย That was the intent from the beginning of this anti-drag queens stuff, the republicans just had to frame it as protecting kids from sex to get the public to accept it.ย Hugs
ย Itโs aimed at banning minors from โsexually oriented performance,โ which the bill initially defined as a โmale performer exhibiting as a female, or a female performer exhibiting as a male.โ If the bill becomes law, drag performers could face a criminal misdemeanor charge if they perform in front of children or on public property, and venues that host drag performances could face penalties up to $10,000.
ย
โThis legislature has spent more time targeting queer people than gun violence.โ
A Texas drag performer was escorted out of a public hearing on one of the stateโs anti-drag bills.
Asย NBC affiliate KXAN reports, the Texas House of Representatives State Affairs committee held a public hearing on Wednesday to discuss S.B. 12, which was passed by the state senate last month. Itโs aimed at banning minors from โsexually oriented performance,โ which the bill initially defined as a โmale performer exhibiting as a female, or a female performer exhibiting as a male.โ If the bill becomes law, drag performers could face a criminal misdemeanor charge if they perform in front of children or on public property, and venues that host drag performances could face penalties up to $10,000.
RELATEDย STORIES
ย
Texas House votes unanimously to expel โanti-groomingโ Republican after he groomed a teenager
He used to rail against drag queens performing in front of kids. Now one of his colleagues said heโs the โtype of man who steals innocence.โ
At Wednesdayโs hearing, the committee was considering removing any mention of drag from S.B. 12.
Get the Daily Brief
The news you care about, reported on by the people who care about you.
Austin drag performer Brigitte Bandit was one of nearly 400 people who signed up to testify, the overwhelming majority of them opposing the bill, according to KXAN. Bandit appeared before the committee in a dress bearing the names of the victims of the Uvalde and Allen mass shootings to argue that the real danger facing the stateโs children is gun violence, not drag queens.
โThis legislature has spent more time targeting queer people than gun violence, even following yet another mass shooting in our state,โ sheย tweeted on Wednesday.
After reportedly speaking 15 seconds over her allotted time, Bandit was escorted out of the hearing by security.
while wearing the names of the victims of the Uvalde and Allen shootings and after waiting 13 hours to speak, I was escorted out by police for testifying seconds over my allotted time to address the real harm that threatens TX kids: gun violence, not drag queens. pic.twitter.com/nyQiEg20n9
— Brigitte Bandit๐ (@BrigitteBandit) May 11, 2023
โIt is mentally and physically painful to feel like you are trapped in the wrong body. Going through puberty for the wrong sex is like having your body betray you on a daily basis. The only treatment we have found to be effective and give our daughter hope again is hormone therapy. The difference we have experienced is night and day and there is no going back. Taking away this crucial medical care is inhumane and a violation of our rights. We will fight this law for our daughter and every other family whose rights are being trampled.โ
ย
While the wave of anti-trans legislation has been hard to witness, we are seeing the beginning of the fight back in the courts. Gender affirming care bans are challenged in 9 states now.
States where gender affirming care bans are being challenged in court. ———————————————————————————— Please support my independent reporting and activism on transgender legislation by subscribing. You help me keep this going and keep people informed.
Subscribe
ย
————————————————————————————-
ย
Amid a surge in anti-trans legislation in the US, attorneys prepared to mount a strong response. Their counterattack has finally arrived. In recent months, lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), Department of Justice, National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR), Human Rights Campaign (HRC), Lambda Legal, and several other organizations have contested laws banning gender-affirming care for transgender youth in states nationwide. Success stories are emerging, as seen in Missouri, where aย temporary restraining orderย has blocked the ban. With seven states facing lawsuits challenging such bans added in the last few months, the total number of states being sued over gender-affirming care prohibitions now stands at nine.
Many of these lawsuits are spearheaded by the ACLU, a prominent force in the fight against gender-affirming care bans. In seven out of nine states facing legal action, the ACLU serves as a primary organization representing the plaintiffs. Florida and Alabama stand as the exceptions, with Southern Legal Counsel, GLBTQ Legal Advocates & Defenders, the Justice Department, and the National Center for Lesbian Rights leading the challenges there. The NCLR and other organizations have also been active and serve as co-leads in states like Kentucky. The ACLU has played a significant role in opposing these discriminatory laws this year.
Earlier, the organization’s Deputy Director of Transgender Justice, Chase Strangio,ย delivered a powerful testimonyย against an anti-trans bill in Tennessee. In his testimony, he confidently asserted, “Tennessee will not be able to defend these laws.”
See his testimony here:
ย
Please support my independent reporting and activism on transgender legislation by subscribing. You help me keep this going and keep people informed.
Subscribe
ย
——————————————————————————
ย
Shortly after the Tennessee bill was passed, theย ACLU challengedย it in court on behalf of a 15 year old transgender girl. In aย press releaseย from the ACLU, the girl, whose name is not shared, stated,
โI donโt even want to think about having to go back to the dark place I was in before I was able to come out and access the care that my doctors have prescribed for me. I want this law to be struck down so that I can continue to receive the care I need, in conversation with my parents and my doctors, and have the freedom to live my life and do the things I enjoy.โ
The ACLU is attempting to ensure that the law meets that fate.
Today, Montana became the latest state toย face a lawsuitย over its gender-affirming care ban. Montana has emerged as a hotspot for some of the harshest anti-trans laws and actions this year. With aย gender-affirming care ban,ย drag ban, prohibition ofย gender markers on driver’s licensesย combined with aย rigid definition of sexย that excludes transgender individuals, and theย expulsion of the state’s first trans woman representativeย from the House floor, Montana has become a focal point for legal observers. The lawsuit is supported by prominent organizations, including ACLU Montana, Lambda Legal, and Perkins Coie, who are all committed to combating anti-trans measures in the state.
Jessica van Garderen, mother of a trans daughter in Montana and a plaintiff in the lawsuit, wasย quoted in a joint statement:
โIt is mentally and physically painful to feel like you are trapped in the wrong body. Going through puberty for the wrong sex is like having your body betray you on a daily basis. The only treatment we have found to be effective and give our daughter hope again is hormone therapy. The difference we have experienced is night and day and there is no going back. Taking away this crucial medical care is inhumane and a violation of our rights. We will fight this law for our daughter and every other family whose rights are being trampled.โ
There is ample reason to believe these lawsuits will succeed. So far, legal challenges against gender-affirming care bans and anti-trans policies have been effective. Bolstered by the recent Supreme Court precedent inย Bostock v. Clayton County, judges recognize that discrimination against transgender individuals constitutes sex discrimination and is prohibited under US law. Such policies also infringe on transgender people’s due process and equal protection rights.
Inย Alabama,ย Arkansas, andย Texas, courts have enjoined gender-affirming care bans and child abuse enforcement measures. Recentlyย in Missouri, a series of bans and restrictions targeting even adults were blocked, and this injunction will remain in place for at least two months while the case is under deliberation. It is clear that judges have shown little tolerance for anti-trans legislation.
States where lawsuits on gender affirming care bans have been filed include the following:
As the legislative season dies down, the narrative around transgender legislation is likely to slowly shift. Fewer laws will be passed targeting the community, although some states with legislative cycles that run throughout the year will continue to demand coverage. The focus will shift toward a massive, nationwide mobilization of constitutional lawyers dedicated to dismantling the anti-trans legislation that has proliferated this year. Considering their previous successes, news of victorious lawsuits should uplift the community during this phase. This period commences now.
ย
Please support my independent reporting and activism on transgender legislation by subscribing. You help me keep this going and keep people informed.
Republicans refuse to allow anyone to speak against what they want to do, even if that person is a fellow republican.ย ย This is because they demand to rule the public, not to serve the public.ย They demand power so they can use that power to force all others to follow their conservative religious dictates.ย And this is happening all over the country, as we have seen.ย ย Hugs
It happened again. Representative Chris Sander, a gay Republican, raised his hand to speak on a bill. Republicans instead chose to silence opposition and did not allow him to speak.
Please support my independent reporting and activism on transgender legislation by subscribing. You help me keep this going and keep people informed.
Subscribe
ย
——————————————————————————
ย
The Republican Party has repeatedly barred discussion on LGBTQ+ bills this year. Despite holding supermajorities in numerous instances, they have frequently silenced oppositional voices. Notably, in Oklahoma, GOP members censuredย Representative Mauree Turner, a Black, nonbinary representative. In Kentucky, an attempt was made toย hold a hearingย without any Democratic representatives. This was announced during a lunch break when microphones were turned off. A recentย incident in Montanaย saw transgender Rep. Zooey Zephyr ejected from the house floor and silenced simply for speaking to the harm these bills cause, preventing her from commenting on anti-trans bills. Today, in Missouri, the GOP restricted Democrats to 15 minutes of debate against a bill prohibiting gender-affirming care for trans youth. During the vote, gay Republican Rep. Chris Sander was denied the opportunity to speak against the bill despite signaling his intent, keeping his hand raised for the entirety of the vote.
The bill itself,ย SB49, bans gender affirming care for transgender youth. Though it grandfathers youth already receiving treatment in, there will be many trans youth on waitlists who will be entirely shut out. It also bans Medicaid coverage for transgender adults and surgery for transgender incarcerated individuals. All of these provisions are separate from the ongoing attempt by Missouri Attorney General Andrew Baileyโsย decision to limitย most care for transgender adults, banning many of them from transitioning – that decision isย currently blocked in courtย awaiting a final decision.
In a scene eerily familiar to many people who have paid attention to floor debates over anti-trans legislation, Missouri House Speaker, Rep. Dean Plocher, enacted a motion that restricted Democrats to a meager 15 minutes of total discourse on the bill. This appeared to be a calculated move to expedite the bill’s passage with minimal opposition. House Minority Leader, Representative Crystal Quade, used some of her time to denounce this tactic, arguing it silenced representatives’ speech and, in effect, muffled the voice of the citizenry they represent. This contention closely mirrors a recent incident in Montana involving Rep. Zooey Zephyr, who faced silencing and exile when the house speaker there denied her the right to speak.
That comparison would quickly grow stronger as a Republican, Representative Chris Sander, raised his own hand to speak. Local reporter Emily Manley reported that heย was never called onย despite continually keeping his hand raised. Because Republicans have a choice as to whether they acknowledge their own party member, they opted to not do so.
You can see Rep. Quadeโs initial criticism of the GOPโs silencing tactics and Rep. Sanderโs hand raised in this video:
ย
Please support my independent reporting and activism on transgender legislation by subscribing. You help me keep this going and keep people informed.