Andrew Perry said his body was a temple. His drinking and vaping suggest otherwise.
This newsletter is free and goes out to over 26,000 subscribers, but it’s only able to sustain itself due to the support I receive from a small percentage of regular readers. Would you please consider becoming one of those supporters? You can subscribe via Patreon or the Subscribe button below! You can also make one-time donations through Venmo, CashApp, or PayPal.
The Iowa Supreme Court has rejected a nursing student’s plea that he deserved a “religious exemption” to getting vaccinated against COVID. His school didn’t buy his excuse, leading to a lawsuit, but the courts have upheld the school’s argument that religion had nothing to do with this and the guy has been lying about it the whole time.
In November of 2021, Andrew Perry, a nursing student at (private Christian school) Dordt University in Sioux Center, refused to get vaccinated before starting his clinical rotations. He needed the exemption, he said, because it violated his religious beliefs, but the school said no.
It all boiled down to the idea that religious beliefs must be “sincerely held” for the exemption to be granted and Perry didn’t have any credibility, something the Iowa Supreme Court noted in their decision.
For example, the school said, Perry didn’t even care about the issue. His anti-vax parents put him up to this: His mother Galyn said she wouldn’t pay for school if he got vaccinated. Perry himself said in an email to the chair of the nursing department, “I personally do not have a problem with the vaccine” and even “volunteered and received training to help give the vaccine to others.” When pressed in court to explain why he didn’t want to get vaccinated, religion didn’t even come up. It was all about his mother’s threat to stop paying for his education. Perry even admitted to the school that he was thinking about getting the vaccine behind his mother’s back.
Even though both sides tried to work out a compromise, there was no way around the vaccination. The school explained this wasn’t their decision, but rather a requirement of all the sites where students were receiving their training.
Eventually, Perry settled on the idea that religion would be his way out. The school said he just needed to prove he had religious reasons for not getting the shot—like a “published position” against vaccines from his denomination or proof that he had received religious exemptions during his K-12 education. He had neither.
Instead, Perry said “his body is a temple of God and that he must be a steward of his own body. Thus… if he were to knowingly put something in his body that would only hold risk for his body, he would be violating that religious belief.”
That wasn’t enough. The school needed documentation. He didn’t provide it. So they said no.
Eventually, after realizing 20 other nursing schools weren’t going to accept credits from this private Christian school and would also require him to get vaccinated, he settled for admission into Palm Beach Atlantic University—another private Christian school—and left Dordt.
But where the decision really gets interesting is the description of what Perry said under oath when he was cross-examined about the sincerity of his religious claims.
The court noted that “Andrew clearly did not have issues with introducing other things into his body that were unhealthy or a risk to his health.” Specifically, the court noted that “Andrew conceded that he had been drunk with friends in the past” and also that “he vapes nicotine.” The court also noted Andrew’s testimony “that Gayln objects to his vaping, but has never threatened to cut him off financially if he did not stop vaping.” “Gayln also never threatened to cut off Andrew financially for drinking alcohol to excess.”
Beautiful. His “temple” can’t handle vaccinations but it’s apparently fine with nicotine and alcohol. His mother knew about those things but never even suggested cutting him off for all that. (Perry’s lawyer later argued that this was unfair because the school didn’t know about his vaping or drinking, so how dare they use that against him? but the court didn’t buy that argument either.)
Making matters worse, Perry claimed not getting vaccinated was his decision… even though he also testified that his mother threatened to cut him off financially over it. Yet, when asked what he would do if she changed her mind, he said he would be fine with getting vaccinated.
This guy is an opposing lawyer’s dream.
Ultimately, the court didn’t buy his argument that Jesus was the reason he couldn’t get vaccinated. It was about money, and there’s no My-Mom-Pays-My-Tuition exemption to getting vaccinated. (The lower court even said “Andrew’s argument would have carried more sincerity if he had contended he was trying to follow the religious commandment of ‘honor thy father and mother’; however, that is not a claim that he ever asserted in this case.”)
You almost feel bad for Andrew because he had to make up all these lies to satisfy his batshit crazy mother, but he’s an adult, and he went along with it. So too damn bad. He can live with the consequences of knowing he couldn’t even overcome the extremely low bar of using your religion to get out of following a rule everyone else has to obey.
His desire would have made it easier for COVID to spread—which should have been a deal breaker for someone who wants to go into the medical field—but thankfully the school refused to honor that idiotic request and they were vindicated in court.
You can watch the full oral arguments here:
It feels rare for a court to reject someone’s request for a religious exemption because you can’t probe their mind. But in this case, there was plenty of evidence that religion played no actual part of Perry’s refusal to take public health measures. He lied about his faith and everyone caught him. You can’t say your body is a temple only when mommy won’t pay for tuition.
Part of me feels bad for the situation Andrew Perry was placed in, but he’s not a child. He couldn’t deal with his overbearing, crazy, conspiracy-believing mother, so she became everyone else’s problem.
The Iowa Supreme Court got this right. They didn’t rule against his religion; they ruled against his sincerity. That makes a huge difference. While religious freedom is important, it shouldn’t be used as some magical phrase to get out of anything you want. It shouldn’t be a loophole, even though that’s often what it seems to be these days.
To be clear, a religious exemption shouldn’t be automatic. Someone’s faith shouldn’t make it easier for others to get infected with a virus. But at the very least, you should have to prove you’re serious about your faith if you’re going to use that excuse to harm others, and this family couldn’t even do that.
I know I have been remiss for not keeping everyone up to date. But I have saved every incoming comment to get to. My focus has been to keep getting the cartoon / meme posts out and the news posts, but I really want to get back to focusing on comments.
My health had been getting better with the recent steriod shots I got. But then everything went bad. I stopped being hungry and my stomach stopped emptying to now when I ate a small amount for breakfast and it doesn’t look like I can eat anything more today / tonight. Ron offered to make a lazanna or order pizzas for me but I can’t swallow or eat. Plus I am so tired now all the time. I just want to go to bed. Yesterday I went to bed at 3 pm and did not get up until 5:20 am. But today I did the dishes. 2 days ago I made a loaf of bread in the new bread maker that came out grand, like my loaves used to. We sliced it today and Ron really loves it. I can’t eat any of it yet.
But don’t worry I will rebound soon. I dont have the results for many of the tests the doctors want. 4 days ago Ron made me a wonderful steak I loved. He cut it in half at my request so we both could enjoy it but then he cut his half in half again as he is not to have red meat. It took me two days to eat my portion but it was so good. He saved his second half for me to eat and I had it this morning. It tasted so grand. I love a good steak with buttered bread or a salad.
OK I am going to go to bed for a while. It is 4 pm here. But please know I see the comments and I am saving them. As soon as I get more energy I will reply to them, maybe tomorrow if I can wake up earlier enough. I am grateful to each viewer and each commenter. I hope this me being so tired, or not seeing well, or being in so much pain will soon end. It has to be right. The doctors are running tests, I had the endoscopy, which showed great problems which I need to scan the results and post them. The doctor took the biopsies. He told Ron and I after the procedure that my stomch had not emptied and he found liquid and food still in it after two days with out food. The pictures show three bright red spots on my stomach wall. I am not sure what that means. I had to push my follow-up appointment back a lot due to Ron wanting to be with me at my appointment but his sister scheduling an appointment she needed him at the same day and time. Anyway I love you all. I am going to bed now. I am really tired. Oh crap I promised Ron I would drink a nutritional drink before going to bed. I do not want to. Maybe if I just go to bed with out making any issue he will miss it. Hugs
Guess Trump's DOJ (Donald's Orwellian Justice) legal team had a new Comey hissy fit retaliation indictment all ready to go, or blanched one together real quick, as Comey's daughter won her case.DOJ charges ex-FBI Director James Comey in new case
As many of you surely know, prominent cultists and elected Republican routinely and falsely claim that mass shooters are transgender, often before the identity of the suspect is even known.
Widely-shared MAGA memes falsely list many mass shooters and domestic terrorists as transgender.
Among the most notorious for doing this is Libs Of TikTok creator Chaya Raichik.
Marc Rosenblum, whose blistering resignation letter from a decade-long career at DHS garnered national attention, says the government is overstating how many unauthorized immigrants have left the country during President Donald Trump’s second term.
Breaking news: A federal judge barred the Trump administration from cutting, damaging or impairing any more trees at East Potomac Park without first obtaining a court order, challenging President Trump’s plan to remake the public golf course.
“If Republican state officials refuse to certify a Peltola victory, then Senate Republicans argue the Senate rules would not allow the upper chamber to seat her when the Senate convenes for the new Congress on Jan. 3” thehill.com/homenews/sta…
“President Donald Trump and his allies have spent the final weeks before the midterms showering his supporters with a relentless stream of doubt about the legitimacy of the election, priming them to question results if Republicans lose.” http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/202…
Right-wing activist Seth Gruber says that God destroyed the world with a flood because everyone was "having gay sex orgies": "It was the LGBTQ movement that caused God to murder everyone."
"Support Builds on the Right for Prosecuting Women Who Get Abortions. ‘What is the accountability for these women?’” Of course this where the GOP is heading. The GOP is about religious fascism. Oppressing women is a big part of that. Gift link below http://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/24/u…
BREAKING:Israeli election officials say they will not be extending voting hours tonight. The Likud party had requested an extension.It's currently 8:45 PM in Israel and polls close at 10 PM.
Despite the agency's human resources department saying he hadn’t even been onboarded, Jeremy Lewin oversaw the destruction of USAID. It’s not clear he had the legal authority to do so.
I am sorry. I worked all day on and off between needing to lay down or doing other things to try to manage my pain. I took extra medications which my doctors allow me to do when needed because if I don’t need them I don’t take them. With the cut back on medications those days are few and more rare. I got up at 4 am and started working on this post. However as I mentioned I can’t simply sit at the computer and copy and post stuff. My back won’t let me and the pain gets too intense even with medications so I have to go lay down on the bed.
That is so frustrating.
Then I get up and start again, but when I am posting from a site like Joe. My. God. He keeps posting far more than I can keep up. Ron was out with Diane his sister all afternoon, and when he got home he was very tired so needed to nap. So I tried to keep working. When he got up near 5 pm I was already in agony and had to take my evening medications for pain an hour early. Well 2 hours early as I am trying to switch them to 6-12-6 instead of earlier.
Ron realized that issue as soon as he got home but he was so tired I told him to go to bed, take a nap. But when he got up my stomach had totally shut down. He wanted to cook supper and I agreed as I could eat it for breakfast. He was upset and begged me to take a supplement drink which I did. I love him and I know he is worried about how weak and how I have very little interest in anything but the news and posting it I am. His sister has repeatedly tried to have him make me join both of them on their days out even if to just go out to eat. I just don’t want to. I care about her, I adore my husband and if she gives him an outlet I am OK with that. But I don’t have the energy to do so or join them.
Anyway please enjoy my day’s work. Loves and hugs to all. Hugs, Scottie
Trump:Somalia—98% of the people here now from Somalia don't work. They don't have to work because they steal so much. They all have a Mercedes-Benz. Low IQ, and they live better than you do.
Trump:I can see the fake headlines: "Trump is talking about all the money they're making while people are suffering." That will be the headline.I don't give a damn. We're making a fortune.
New Jersey GOP Mayor Matthew Bianchini faces criminal charges after going after a citizen and resident. MAGA is melting down because they thought Americans would be okay with what's going on.
Republican Mayor Matthew Bianchini of Pemberton Township Council, New Jersey. At the end Bianchini lunged at and threatened at resident Michael Sawka and saying "I'll get you. I'll fucking get you!" He tried to come for him a 2nd time too! WTF!?! How does that mayor still have a job?
House Judiciary Democrats have just released a 50-page report that pulls together years of assault allegations against Trump and his reported connections to Jeffrey Epstein.The report calls for a special counsel to investigate Trump's ties to Epstein.
At least four Trump merchandise stores have closed this year. Store owners say with Trump in his final term, there isn't as much to fire up his consumer fan base and sales have softened. n.pr/4Bm45o5
This is a remarkable portrait, and puts the general failure among our richest and most powerful people to risk anything at all in sharp relief.www.nytimes.com/2026/10/24/u…
JUST POSTED: A Russian energy giant has secretly moved to acquire a position in a massive Alaska gas project. Its part of talks between Witkoff/Kushner & Putin. But CEO of US company resigns after learning of Russian money in the project. A wowzer of a story.www.nytimes.com/2026/10/23/u…
A federal labor agency flagged so many problems in a recent arbitration filing that it suggested the Department of Health and Human Services used artificial intelligence to draft its brief.
Parnell had to drop out of GOP senate primary because he beat his ex-wife and children, losing custody of his kids. He is not a good person, so of course Hegseth wants him to be the next Army Secretary.
Top Democrats poised for powerful roles next year are demanding that major banks and ports preserve any records they have tied to potential imports or other deals involving Russian diesel.Exclusive: Democrats lay groundwork to probe Trump's diesel dealwww.axios.com/2026/10/26/d…
My heart is heavy. Walter Koenig, our Ensign Pavel Chekov, passed away early today.Walter and I met on the bridge of the Enterprise in the 1960s, and we stayed friends for nearly six decades. When Brad and I married in 2008, Walter stood beside us as our best man.
The Plain Dealer editorial board endorses Democrat Amy Acton for Ohio governor, citing her preparedness and community engagement, while condemning opponent Vivek Ramaswamy's weaponizing of Acton's childhood sexual abuse for political points.
I have not given a large update on Ron’s health after his eye surgery nor on my own health. Good news is Ron had his cataract surgeries and his eyes are wonderfully improved. Ron wore glasses since he was in the second grade and now no longer needs to do so daily. His eye sight is now 20 / 25. In fact he now only needs 1.5 readers for fine print.
My health how ever has been deterrating steadly. I wont go into the speculations on it as I am going through the tests. I will say my blood work is very unnormal. The blood cells are wrong, the white and red blood cells are too low or deformed. My PSA has jumped to 7 in only 3 months.
I won’t go into the speculations as we only have fear causing “it could be this and we need to test for that”. I will tell you what is going on with me and how I feel. I have no energy. I used to wake up between 3 and 5 am and be full of energy to the point that when Ron got up he hated it. Now I can’t get up. I go to bed between 3 or 4 pm and stay there until 5 or 6 am and then go back to bed by 9 or 9:30. My pain levels have soared at a time I have been told that both my pain pills and treatments are being restricted. Not due to my situation but because RFK Jr., a former adict is trying to deny pain relief to everyone who needs it in the US. The clinic I see recently had a provider abusing trigger point steriod injections which I desperately need desperately due to back spasms, so the doctor in charge lowered the procedure to 3 times a year that a person can get steriods. The provider in question only did the steeriod injections without doing any other treatments, I get all the other treatments. But I need steriod injections into my destroyed shoulders, spine vertabrea, and also the muscles. So I have to talk to the in charge pain doctor about his ruling.
So along with my pain levels soaring and my blood labs being far outside the normal range I am suffering from extreme fatigue, weakness, and the inability to eat. I use yogurt and supplement drinks. I normally have a small yogurt and drink for breakfast if I am not vomiting or nauseated. Later that day Ron will try hard to get me to eat some soild food but mostly I can only get some soup down and have it stay down. If I have solids it has to be a small amount.
So that explains why I miss getting to the comments. I do read them and then save them in open tabs. I will reply to them soon. But right now I am on full liquids and tomorrow only clear liquids until 6 pm. Then Tuesday at 8:50 I check in for my upper GI. Then later in the month I will repeat the prep for a lower GI.
I can’t do both because I have gastroparisis and that means my stomach is slow to empty due to neurological damage. So they are afraid to do both until they can examine my stomach and make sure I won’t asperate during the procedure. I have been seeing doctors 2 or 3 times a week now and it just leaves me in a lot of pain and exhausted. I am trying to get the cartoons / memes / and news posts ahead so on days I can’t sit at the computer the post will get out. I do try to post news stuff but I simply put the articles in a tab to post when I can. So this is what is going on. The posts of memes and cartoons are the easiest for me to see.
Oh I forgot I started with the University of Miami in Naples to have my cataracts removed. They called me last monday but I have not felt well enough or had the energy to call them back. I will try to do it this week. Ron worries I am not strong enough right now for the hour long trips both ways and the procedures.
OK this got longer than I planned. If you reply I will save it in an open tab to respond to after I feel stronger or I have more news to share. I was working on the cartoons / memes / news post for 14th because it maybe that I may not be able to be at my computers for a few days, so I am trying hard to get posts ahead. Sadly with everything going on with me and Ron’s sister being here he totally stopped work on my new office with lots more light and windows. I understand why. Thank you to everyone who still comes here and reads what I post. Some times the videos are the only thing I can post or see for a while until I lay down and recharge. I find I am so tired I just watch the videos and lose track of time. I fall asleep at my desk a lot now. I value everyone of you and when I get better I will be much quicker to respond to you. Hugs
We need to add our voices to stop this assault on trans people. Notice it starts with trans kids being denied care and then moves to banning funding for poor or disabled adults. This is about hate, disgust, and bigotry driven by religion or misinformation. Notice that the article adds the information that no sexual reasignment surgery is done on minors something this group pushes as they know the “we must protect the children” is an easy sell. Everyone wants to protect children including the parents of transitioning kids who will have extreme stress and emotional disrest that could lead to suicide or self-harm. Trans minors get to socailly transition until puberty and then they are put on puberty blockers so they do not suffer from going through the wrong puberty for how they feel inside. Puberty blockers once stopped if not replaced with HRT the young person simply goes back through puberty of the sex assigned at birth. Socail transitioning means a name they choose to be called hair cuts that they prefer, and clothing they wish to wear all the genders they feel they are. These people don’t care about the individual kids, they care about the cause. They want trans people not to exist and they really don’t want those that pass because of puberty blockers to exist. That is the point they are driving to. It all comes down to forcing people to live their lives by our church doctrines or by our rules rather than live and let others live their lives. It is about enforcing a hedgomony of everyone being the same as cis straight people, which leads to everyone being one race is superior. We have to do everything possible to defend our trans folk because the corporate democrats got scared by the right into thinking that if they stop fighting for the rights of the vulnerable they will be accepted by the right. Sadly what happens when the rights of one group are abandoned the haters come for the next vulnerable of the group. The hater Christian right is already pushing for the over turning same-sex marriage as they feel they are winning on the wipe the trans out of existence. Hugs
A sign directs Election Day voters to the ballot drop box and polling center at the La Familia Recreation Center in Denver Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024. (Photo by Lindsey Toomer/Colorado Newsline)
Two ballot measures that would restrict rights for transgender children in the state will appear on the Colorado ballot in 2026.
Protect Kids Colorado, a coalition led by prominent anti-LGBTQ+ activist Erin Lee, submitted signatures in February for ballot measures that would prevent transgender children from participating in school sports and receiving gender-affirming surgeries. Lee led several anti-LGBTQ+ initiatives that the Colorado Title Board rejected ahead of the 2024 election.
There isn’t clear data on the number of transgender student athletes in Colorado, and the two major hospitals that provide gender-affirming care to minors in the state do not offer surgeries to minors.
“Across Colorado, citizens are stepping forward because they believe the legislature has failed to protect children and families,” Lee said in a statement. “When elected officials refuse to act, the people of Colorado are using their constitutional right to bring these issues directly to the ballot.”
LGBTQ+ advocacy organizations in Colorado oppose both measures.
“Coloradans have always valued individual freedom and the rights of families to make private decisions without political interference, but these measures would go against those core values,” Nadine Bridges, executive director of One Colorado, said in a statement. “One could expose students to invasive inspections just to play sports, while the other would place politicians between families and their doctors in deeply personal health care decisions. That kind of government overreach puts privacy and dignity at risk and doesn’t align with our Colorado values.”
Ballot Initiative 110 would prohibit health care professionals from knowingly performing any surgery on a minor “for the purpose of altering biological sex characteristics.” The measure would also prohibit state and federal funding including Medicaid from being used to pay for gender-affirming procedures.
Children’s Hospital Colorado and Denver Health have paused gender-affirming care for youth amid the Trump administration’s threats to pull Medicaid and Medicare funding entirely.
Ballot Initiative 109 would add language in state statute to define boys and girls based on physical anatomy, excluding transgender people.
Sports teams sponsored by schools or athletic associations would be required to expressly designate those teams for men, women or co-ed. Schools and their athletic departments would be required to adopt policies implementing the requirements of the initiative.
The measure would not affect any student’s ability to participate in co-ed sports.
The state’s commissioner of education would be tasked with enforcing the measure, and would have discretion to determine how to “take appropriate remedial action” against any school not in compliance with its requirements.
The Colorado secretary of state’s office verified that Initiative 109 had enough petition signatures Monday and that Initiative 110 had enough petition signatures Tuesday.
Bruce Parker, executive director of Rocky Mountain Equality, said Coloradans “don’t need outside interests to tell them how to raise their families.”
“In the coming months we are going to hear intentional lies from anti-trans extremists about this ballot measure,” Parker said in a statement. “They aren’t being honest about their agenda to erode privacy and access to credible medical care they don’t agree with. Their next targets are care for trans adults and abortion services if we let them get away with this.”
Protect Kids Colorado is also backing a ballot measure to increase penalties for child human trafficking in Colorado. The election will occur on Nov. 3.
Lindsey Toomer
Lindsey Toomer covers politics, social justice and other stories for Newsline. She formerly reported on city government at the Denver Gazette and on Colorado mountain town government, education and environment at the Summit Daily News.
Colorado Newsline is part of States Newsroom, the nation’s largest state-focused nonprofit news organization.