Debunking David Barton’s Favorite Falsehood About the Bible and Circuit Courts

Kyle MantylaBy Kyle Mantyla | February 14, 2023 4:28 pm

It has been well-documented that Christian nationalist pseudo-historian David Barton routinely misuses and misrepresents both American history and the Bible in order to promote his right-wing political agenda.

For decades, Barton has worked diligently to convince conservative Christian activists that the Founding Fathers intended for the United States to be an explicitly Christian nation that operates according to biblical precepts. He has doggedly worked to “prove” these claims by incessantly (and falselyinsisting that multiple passages of the Constitution were taken directly out of the Bible and that our laws and branches of government were crafted based on biblical principles.

These false claims have a political purpose. In 2022, Barton traveled around the country on behalf of an organization called Faith Wins, working to mobilize Christian voters heading into the midterm elections by telling them that, according to the Bible, they were responsible for choosing our elected leaders.

An example of the sort of disinformation Barton peddled was on display when he spoke at Radiant Church in Colorado last September. During his presentation, Barton falsely asserted that jurist James Kent set up federal circuit courts and that the concept of circuit courts was rooted in 1 Samuel 7:15-16. That passages reads, “Samuel continued as Israel’s leader all the days of his life. From year to year he went on a circuit from Bethel to Gilgal to Mizpah, judging Israel.”

“James Kent, he’s known as the father of American jurisprudence,” Barton said. “He’s one of the two guys who helped set up the American judicial system. And when he set it up, he set it up with circuit courts. … Back at the beginning, when we had the original Supreme Court justices, they got on their horse, and they rode from town to town and from state to state to have court meetings.”

“And so we have this concept of circuit judges set up, and the guy who set it up said, ‘Well, we got it out of 1 Samuel 7:15-16,’” Barton continued. “It says that Samuel judged Israel, and Samuel rode the circuit. [Kent] said that if that’s the way the Bible does judges, then that’s a good way for us to do judges too.”

We had heard Barton make this claim multiple times before, but didn’t realize how wrong Barton was until we recently read the book, “John Jay: Founding Father,” by Walter Stahr. Jay served as the very first chief justice of the Supreme Court, a position to which he was nominated by President George Washington in 1789 on the same day that Washington signed the Judiciary Act of 1789, which created the federal court system.

As explicitly laid out in the Judiciary Act of 1789, Jay and his colleagues were required to travel among the 13 circuit courts established throughout the nation and hear cases in conjunction with local district judges.

While Kent was an acclaimed jurist in the Founding Era, he played no role in crafting this legislation, establishing circuit courts, or in helping to “set up the American judicial system.” In fact, Kent never even served in Congress, and the Judiciary Act of 1789, which laid out the concept of circuit courts, was drafted by Sen. Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut.

Barton, of course, provided no evidence to support his claim regarding Kent’s supposed biblical inspiration for creating circuit courts during his presentation. But when Barton made this same false claim in his 2012 book, “The Founder’s Bible,” he cited “The Memoirs and Letters of James Kent.” Predictably, if one actually checks Kent’s memoirs, all that is found is an undated passage in Kent’s diary noting that “the Jewish judges rode the circuits” along with the quote from 1 Samuel.

This is, once again, an example of Barton exploiting the biblical and historical ignorance of his own audiences to feed them a false narrative regarding the founding of this nation that serves primarily to promote his own modern-day right-wing political agenda.

We need your help. Every day, Right Wing Watch exposes extremism to help the public, activists, and journalists understand the strategies and tactics of anti-democratic forces—and respond to an increasingly aggressive and authoritarian far-right movement. The threat is growing, but our resources are not. Any size contribution—or a small monthly donation—will help us continue our work and become more effective at disrupting the ideologies, people, and organizations that threaten our freedom and democracy. Please make an investment in Right Wing Watch’s defense of the values we share.

More Alarm Raised Over GOP Christian Nationalism

Read the full article. There so much more. No paywall. As Right Wing Watch has exhaustively documented for years, Barton tours the country, telling avid Christian audiences that virtually every line of the US Constitution and the Declaration of Independence was taken verbatim from the bible. Barton is such a notorious liar that even his own Christian publishing house retracted his book. And now he’s advising the Speaker of the House.

Thumbnail

the founding fathers knew of the massacres that happened in europe over whether you were protestant or catholic so, of course, they did not want that to happen here, and thus we have freedom of religion. Stupid republicans.

“Many professional historians dismiss Mr. Barton, whose academic degree is in Christian Education from Oral Roberts University, as a biased amateur who cherry-picks quotes from history and the Bible.”

Jay W. Richards, senior fellow at the Christian conservative Discovery Institute, said in 2012 that Barton’s books and videos are full of “embarrassing factual errors, suspiciously selective quotes, and highly misleading claims.”

– Wikipedia entry under his name

Same as Creationists who are all lying amateurs who cherry picks quotes, articles, and outdated materials from the Bible, history, and especially science.

 

so true,some nutcase politician from NC runs bible classes on sunday..tells the kids that satan created ALL the fossil evidence,just to confuse us and ,that the earth is truly only 6k years old (sigh)..Bartons got plenty of company in the b/s dept.

Thumbnail
 

It was noted that Jefferson felt that the inclusion of any Christian language must be excluded, as he felt that in the future, that enlightened Americans would move away from Christianity, but such any Christian language included in the Constitution might invalidate or complicate its interpretation by a more enlightened America.

…And look where we are with theocrats at the gates, claiming gawd is in the Constitution…somewhere.

Christianity is the most perverted system that ever shone on man.
-Thomas Jefferson, letter to his nephew
“The United States is in no way founded upon the Christian religion.” — George Washington & John Adams in a diplomatic message to Malta
“This would be the best of all possible worlds, if there were no religion in it.” — John Adams in a letter to Thomas Jefferson
“I do not find in orthodox Christianity one redeeming feature.” — Thomas Jefferson
“Lighthouses are more useful than churches” — Benjamin Franklin
“The day will come when the mystical generation of Jesus, by the Supreme Being as his father, in the womb of a virgin, will be classed with the fable of the generation of Minerva from the brain of Jupiter.”
-Thomas Jefferson, letter to Adams

Thumbnail
 

It’s fascinating watching a major country turn into an extremist theocracy in real-time. Historians are gonna have a field-day. Foreign historians, you understand. Only bible history will be allowed in the USA.

I’ve seen two other countries slide into theocracy in my lifetime, Iran and Turkey, although Turkey has some ways to go.

 

Quite a few others that aren’t full theocracies, but share a lot of the same issues. A lot of them were Eastern Bloc countries.

Israeli strikes kill multiple civilians at shelters in Gaza combat zone, as Blinken seeks more aid

https://apnews.com/article/israel-hamas-war-gaza-news-11-4-2023-baf5a858e29aa6a4b8100e3afc5afdf2

Read the title again please before the article.  No justification for this!  Israeli officials keep saying there was no justification for the attack on them by Hamas, OK but there is no justification for what Israel is doing now to a captured people who can not fight back and can not escape.  There is a video at the link.  Hugs.  Scottie


https://apnews.com/16c1fcdc8255451b9503b3d0a038ca1f

A Palestinian checks the destruction after Israeli strikes on the Gaza Strip in Khan Younis, Friday, Now. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Fatima Shbair)

In this undated photo provided by the Israeli military, Israeli troops are seen during a ground operation in the Gaza Strip. Israeli ground forces have been operating in Gaza in recent days as Israel presses ahead with its war against Hamas militants. (Israel Defense Forces via AP)

A man steps over the bodies of dead and injured Palestinians lying on the ground following an Israeli airstrike outside the entrance of the al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Abed Khaled)

Palestinian child wounded in Israeli bombardment is treated in a hospital in Deir al Balah, south of the Gaza Strip, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Hatem Moussa)

An Israeli reservist soldier collects family albums from his mother's house, a day after the house was hit by a rocket fired from the Gaza Strip, near Tel Aviv, Israel, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Ohad Zwigenberg)

Palestinian points at destruction by the Israeli bombardment of the Gaza Strip in the Maghazi refugee camp, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Hatem Moussa)

Smoke rises following an Israeli airstrike in the Gaza Strip, as seen from southern Israel, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Leo Correa)

Family members carry Moataz Abu Al-Nada, a Palestinian militant who was killed in an Israeli airstrike on Jenin refugee camp in the West Bank, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Majdi Mohammed)

An injured Palestinian boy is carried from the ground following an Israeli airstrike outside the entrance of the al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City, Friday, Nov. 3, 2023. (AP Photo/Abed Khaled)

 

Israeli troops have been tightening their encirclement of Gaza City with army videos showing ongoing battles with Hamas militants (4 November).

BY NAJIB JOBAINSAMY MAGDY AND DAVID RISING
Updated 8:29 AM EDT, November 4, 2023

RAFAH, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli military strikes killed multiple civilians Saturday at a U.N. shelter and hospital in the main combat zone in the Gaza Strip as the assault intensified on the besieged enclave’s Hamas rulers amid growing international uproar over the soaring death toll and deepening humanitarian crisis.

Israel’s military has said it has encircled Gaza City, the target of its offensive to crush Hamas, but on Saturday offered a three-hour window for residents trapped by the fighting to flee south.

The new attacks came as U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken was in the region trying to find ways to ease the plight of the civilians caught in the fighting. He met with Arab foreign ministers on Saturday in Jordan, the day after talks in Israel with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who insisted there can be no temporary cease-fire until all hostages held by Hamas are released.

The Israeli military has repeatedly demanded that northern Gaza’s 1.1 million residents flee south as it escalates bombardment of the north and tightens the noose around Gaza City. However, some of those traveling south were killed during their journey in recent days, and Israel has continued bombing in the south, saying it is striking Hamas targets.

 

Bassem Youssef vs Piers Morgan ROUND 2 (incredible conversation)

Great history lesson on how Israel was created and the people already in Palestine.  The person being interviewed, Bassem Youssef, goes back to 1914.  Lance gives more information towards the 42 minute mark.   This is a great listen if you want to know about this conflict.   Hugs.  Scottie

While most (myself included) thought this would be another satire filled embarrassment for Piers Morgan, Bassem Youssef uses the platform to educate the world on Palestine.

AXIS of EVIL – a Parody | Don Caron & Freedom Toast

The lyrics were provided by The Freedom Toast. Performance by Don Caron and the Band – The original song, if you don’t recognize it, is Pop Goes the Weasel. The skeleton animations are courtesy of Green Screen Brasil. The band is listed below:

Audio Shows Mike Johnson Promoting Ex-Gay Torture

I have been reading rumors that Mike Johnson was a regular in a popular gay bar and was well known to go home with men.  He also is said to be currently exchange emails with the boy about their shared “addiction to porn and masturbation”.  He adopted the boy who was 14 when he was a single man, just as Matt Gaetz adopted the preteen Nestor.  I am not able to confirm yet the gay rumors, and there is no reason to suspect child abuse just because he was single at the time of adoption, but I do find it weird to be sharing with your son that you have an addition to porn and love to masturbate?  But I am sure the truth will come out.  So many of these rabid anti-gay religious people are gay and think god will cure them.   It is the same with gay guys who go into the military to “man up and go straight”.  It doesn’t work.  Hugs.  Scottie


 

“It’s time for an honest conversation about homosexuality. There’s freedom to change if you want to. Our race, the size of our feet, the color of our eyes, these are things we’re born with and cannot change. But what these adult advocacy groups like the Gay Lesbian Straight Education Network are promoting is a type of behavior. Homosexual behavior is something you do. It’s not something that you are.” – House Speaker Mike Johnson, speaking about the now-defunct ex-gay torture group Exodus International and his joint mission with them on a Christian counter protest to the annual anti-bullying Day Of Silence. As you’ll see in the clip below, Johnson goes on to blame the acceptance of homosexuality for the fall of the Roman Empire. Yes, really.

 

“The guilty dogs bark the loudest.” – My late grandmother Gigi Love.

Lady’s and Gentleman, looks like we’ve got an “ex” gay on our hands.

No, we have a bisexual who can choose to be gay or to be straight. He just doesn’t know that he’s bi.

The real choice is to be open about who one is (bi, queer, whatever) and thus live a happy, productive life! Or, to pretend to hide (closet) oneself from who one is and thus make themself, and everyone else as well, miserable!

I’m always reminded of the line from the movie Auntie Mame (1958) with Rosalind Russell as Mame Dennis where she says, “Life is a banquet and most poor suckers are starving to death!

What I hear him saying is . . . he’s gay, but doesn’t let himself have sex, or even loving relationships, with men (including himself).

If you say it’s a constant struggle not to be gay, you’re probably gay.

If you say it’s your choice to be gay, you’re probably bisexual.

I can’t wait for a former college roommate to spill the beans about this creep.

His religion won’t allow him.

His religion is a choice, his choice.

This fall of the Roman Empire hypothesis is so irritating, because it is demonstrably false. Homosexuality was considered to be a normal facet of human sexuality in Europe for millennia. Rome fell after it was Christianized and Abrahamic prohibitions were introduced into Europe for the first time.

Wow, they really are recycling all the oldies for this tour.

When someone says “every empire that fell accepted homosexuality”, I ask “name me one empire that didn’t fall.” They can’t. Empires rise and fall. Empires eventually overreach. It’s unsustainable. So of course they always collapse. It’s just a question of when.

I think plague, Germanization of the army, and widespread use of lead piping also had something to do with the Western Roman Empire’s demise.

Yeah, there was a lot going on:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/…

Note that the article doesn’t mention “homosexuality” at all. Know what it does mention as a factor? Religion.

Nor is homosexuality mentioned in “The Fall of the Roman Empire” (1964). I’m not ready to watch all three hours to be sure of that, although there are some compelling gladiator scenes.

 

 

XD

It just bugs me when I see that crap pushed. I took a couple of courses on Rome back in college (yay, History 114A through 114C!), and the collapse of the Western Empire is a *huge* subject, one that I doubt people like Johnson have ever studied in any detail.

Some of the thesis of E. Gibbon’s “Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire” was that Christianity, and it’s divisions, politicization, and diversion of resources of the Empire to the Church, was responsible for the Empire’s fall.
It’s not generally accepted today, but his critique is worth noting.
When I tell people talking about “Roman Decadence destroyed the empire” that Rome didn’t fall (in 410 CE) until Christianity was Established as the sole religion, and Alaric the Goth was as Christian as Pope Honorius, they don’t believe me.
And then there’s that inconvenient Byzantine empire surviving another 1000 years…

I would dispute whether it was known as “homosexuality,” as such.

Our concepts of sexuality and sexual orientation really emerged in the 19th century, and I think it’s questionable at best, to impose these concepts onto antiquity.

Sexual behavior was all about the person who had the POWER to do what he (yes, always he) wanted. Generally, however, high status males were presumed to want to reproduce, legitimately, to produce an heir(s). Anything other than that was, again, about the power to do it. Women, slaves, certain untouchable classes had NO power, and anything could be done TO them.

I reeeeeeeeally don’t want to Go Back to what was considered “normal” in antiquity.

Destitution: UK

Just some things I found this morning

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

Thumbnail

The Birthing Persons SAGA will never end (Ana Kasparian on PBD podcast)

This is again another video on Anna’s hard right turn on trans people, which I guess is only to get her a better gig else where.   She keeps going on that she objects to doctors forms or offices calling pregnant trans males birthing persons.  But Anna has fervently claimed she doesn’t want kids and won’t have them.  So the term doesn’t apply to her at all.  She tries to claim the term is the same as the N word, but that is not used in any medical setting or forms at all.  She is tilting at windmills here.  She says she wants to be called a woman, and yes that is her right.  And if she was ever pregnant her doctor would honor that.   So why is she against what other people want to be called.   Her stance makes no sense when you look at it.   She got her plastic surgery nose out of joint and is making that the hill to die on.   Again the question is why?  But it is getting her a lot of attention and air time play on right wing podcasts / blogs.  So you ask why she has gone so far out on this that no one is calling her and making it her claim to fame?  Is she the new Riley Gaines, who made an entire media career over complaining she tied with a trans woman for fourth place!     Hugs.  

Before he became a politician, House Speaker Mike Johnson partnered with an anti-gay conversion therapy group

https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/01/politics/mike-johnson-kfile-invs/index.html

Every major medical association affirm that conversion therapy is torture and not medically sound.  It doesn’t work and creates lifelong issues and problems.  It is abuse.  Sexual orientation is something one is born with.   No matter who you find sexually attractive, ask your self when you choose that?   Who sits down with a bunch of different pictures of men and women and says you know I think I will be sexually attracted to these.  It is a body reaction, not a mental one.  My dogs that love gravy these people understand that because they use torture methods including some put electrodes on kid’s scrotum to shock them if they get excited over male nudes.   WTF, no one chooses and these people did not choose who they are attracted to and get the tingles from.  The fact is they demand we all ignore reason and medical science so their holy book written 2,500 years ago when people were ignorant even of germs that caused sickness is correct.  Yes they tell us, just ignore everything that makes sense and the medical people are telling us to that the desert nomads of 2,500 years ago are correct.   The want an old dusty geopolitical warlord text to relate to our modern life.  Why did their god not know about cell phones?  Why wait to give life-saving health information to the people.  Because their god only knew what the people 2,500 knew.   Do they really want to claim that is the highest pinnacle of human knowledge?   But what is telling is his organization tells kids / teens they don’t need to accept kids who are different.   He is telling kids to not be tolerant or even accepting of LGBTQIA kids in schools.   Just like he doesn’t want to accept or tolerate that there are LGBTQIA people in society he has to accept are there.    Kill them all, or if you can not do that, just make don’t say gay laws that erase them from society.   Hugs.  Scottie


 

Read the full article. There’s much more. No paywall.
As I previously reported, Johnson and Alliance Defending Freedom helped create the so-called Day Of Truth as an on-campus Christian counter protest to GLSEN’s annual anti-bullying Day Of Silence.
Per CNN’s new reporting, Mike Johnson collaborated with Exodus for years on the Day Of Truth.
When Exodus finally collapsed in 2013, founder Alan Chambers issued a lengthy apology and admitted on CNN that ex-gay torture had never turned any of his thousands of victims heterosexual. Not a single one. Video below.

 

Exodus was a steaming pile of self hating homos hitting on each other. If Johnson was working with them, he was likely fucking around with one or more of them. There is tea that needs to be spilled.

A Netflix documentary call Pray Away dropped earlier this year. Tip of the iceberg stuff. There is another (now out) gay man that spent his professional life working for the LDS church and living a lie. He is now speaking his truth. Johnson has got gay face to the level that breaks my gaydar machine to a smoking ruin. I grew up among people just like him.

Exodus is an example of that fine xstian love bullshit. This presumably straight guy and his ilk should be forced into homosexual conversion, although, I suspect that they are, in reality, self-hating (for whatever reason) Gays who tried to convince themselves and the desperate Gays and/or their families who attended conversion camps that it could be done. If by some chance you have not seen “Boy Erased” I highly recommend it. It’s a very well done feature film on this very subject. IMHO it’s a 5 star winner. “Fair Haven” is another good one. There are a number of films on the subject. https://en.wikipedia.org/wi…

In the Netflix documentary, Pray Away, your assertions are confirmed. There wouldn’t need to be any homosexual conversion because most of them were gayer than geese the entire time. Imagine that. Several of the leaders admit to the lie. Boy Erased was heartbreaking, and Fair Haven really drove home the isolation and self hatred that many of us have been forced to carry.

I hope his “adopted” African American son steps forward with clarification on their relationship. I have a strong suspicion Johnson does not want that to happen.

I think he’s 40/in his 40s now? The article I read said he went into Johnson’s “custody” when he was 14 and Johnson was something like 27. Or maybe younger. It was before he was married. Strong “Nestor” vibes there.
That’s not to say that a young, single man can’t adopt a teenager he wants to help, just that it’s unusual enough that there should maybe be some extra scrutiny of the situation.

Republicans were actually really smart about how they slipped this guy in under the radar. People actually believed that the chair would remain vacant because the GOP couldn’t get their shit together… but in fact, they were just holding out for a true Nazi to install.

There’s a couple of TikTok videos going around in which Louisiana locals claim that Johnson was once a well-known patron at the Baton Rouge gay bar Central Station. I’ve found no reputable reporting on this, but nothing would be surprising when it comes to closeted Republicans.

Here’s one of those TikTok clips: https://www.tiktok.com/@mam…

Methinks He Doth Protest Too Much is entirely a thing.

maybe that is why he has a covenant marriage, so he can’t get out of it.

The Apache Drive-In over in Tyler, Texas is closer. It’s long been a hookup spot for the sexually frustrated from East Texas and northwest Louisiana.

As someone pointed out he adopted a 14yo boy when he was 25 or 26 and then married a conversion therapist 2 years later.

Hmmm. Wonder how long it took him to seek out the therapy?

You seem to think he sought therapy, instead of the obvious, got a beard

Thumbnail
 

So, it’s confirmed Johnson is in favor of mentally abusing teens all to convert and satisfy his perverted version of “Christianity”.

Oh of course. Because they know that eventually many of these confused gays will commit suicide and nothing would make them happier than for all homos to knock themselves off of the planet .