Peace & Justice History for 11/2:

November 2, 1920

Socialist Party candidate Eugene V. Debs received nearly one million votes for President though he was serving a prison sentence at the time for his criticism of World War I and his encouraging resistance to the draft.
More on Debs ย 
November 2, 1982
Voters in nine general elections passed statewide referenda supporting a freeze on testing of nuclear weapons. Only Arizona turned it down.

Dr. Randall Forsberg, a key person behind the Freeze movement
Dr. Randall Forsberg
November 2, 1983

A bill designating a federal holiday honoring Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. (to be observed on the third Monday of January) was signed by President Ronald Reagan.
King was born in Atlanta in 1929, the son of a Baptist minister. He received a doctorate degree in theology and in 1955 organized the first major protest of the civil rights movement: the successful Montgomery Bus Boycott. Influenced by Mohandas Gandhi, he advocated nonviolent civil disobedience of the laws that enforced racial segregation.
ย 
The history of Martin Luther King Dayย ย ย (pdf)

https://www.peacebuttons.info/E-News/peacehistorynovember.htm#november2

We The People Are Doin’ It!!

An Ask for Facebook Users

I’m not on Facebook; never have been. I do order from Penzey’s, and because of that, I get their emails, which are awesome. Here is the body of today’s email with links, and another shout-out to any Facebook users who are called to help out with this. And, I think anyone in a position to share in some fashion is welcome to do so!

(Here should be a photo of a veteran who may be the subject of this. I’m sorry it won’t post.)
ย 
ย This really isnโ€™t a standard email, itโ€™s a Facebook post sent by email. But with one week to go and everything seemingly all tied up, sharing a glimpse of our past thatโ€™s at risk of becoming our future seems right. Please read and share.Thanks.

October 25, 2024 George Mullins voted. June 6, 1944 George came ashore in Normandy. He voted by mail. He insisted that the ballot needed to be taken to the post office and handed directly to the postal worker. โ€œCanโ€™t take any chances in these times.โ€

It was LST #311 that brought him 100 yards from the shore of Utah Beach on D-Day. The water was cold and up to his neck. He kept an eye on the shorter soldiers to make sure their heavy packs would not drag them under. Together they all made it ashore. So many of those George went ashore with never made it home.

George Mullins lived through the unfathomable violence it took to face down fascism. He made it home but left so much behind. Forever since he has had to carry a hurt and a loss that thankfully most of us have never known.

His experience has left him with thoughts on this election and about those who would once again intentionally unleash the unspeakable horrors he had hoped were forever in the past.

Two weeks ago George posted his thoughts onย his Facebook pageย for the book he wrote of his WWII experience,ย Foxhole.

Buy his book, I highly recommend it.

As is the nature of Facebook, and social media, and the times we live in, one of the most valuable pieces that will ever be written about this election now sits there with just 72 likes.

Georgeโ€™s daughter and longtime Penzeys customer, Sheila, wrote hinting that maybe I could bring more attention to his words. Yes. A very big Yes. Coincidentally enough (if there are coincidences) his were exactly the words I was then searching for.

Not eight hours before Sheilaโ€™s email arrived I had just finished rewatching Spielbergโ€™sย Saving Private Ryan. Iโ€™m convinced it is in the unspeakable sacrifice of so many Americans eighty years ago where the key to understanding just how much is at stake on 11.5.24 lives or dies.

But where to find the words? I looked toย Saving Private Ryanย because Spielberg has good words, and there are good words there but his, like mine, are of an outsider looking in. Where could I find the words I needed? And as fate would have it they arrived all tied neatly with a bow and accompanied by a breathtaking photo.

And I wonโ€™t give away all George Mullinsโ€™s words, please read all of them for yourself. But in short, today he is deeply troubled by the direction he sees our country heading.

โ€œI didnโ€™t fight in World War II, standing on the front lines of history, so that we could one day find our country on the brink of dictatorship or authoritarian rule. The freedoms I defended, and believe in, the sacrifices my comrades and I made, were for the preservation of democracyโ€”of freedom, fairness, and the right to live without fear of tyranny.โ€

Thereโ€™s so much we take for granted, but all that George and those he fought alongside achieved came at a terrible cost. And as much as we know words like fascism, and Nazi, and even freedom, how much do we really understand this is about the difference between living free and having to live in fear of your government?

By 1944 everyone understood, but today itโ€™s something weโ€™ve forgotten, something we take for granted. George Mullins went ashore shoulder to shoulder with men like him willing to give their lives so that others may live free. Let that sink in.

And now the leaders of the Republican party are not only throwing that sacrifice away, they are forcing our children to relive it. Why? Because they donโ€™t have the strength to stand up to Donald Trumpโ€™s never-ending need for ever greater power. We must do better. We must share George Mullinsโ€™s warning.
(snip; an offer I’m not sure is appropriate to include here, but I can put it in comments if someone’s interested. I’m trying to stay on topic, without appearing to advertise, though advertisement is not the author’s intent. -A)

And two outstanding Steven Spielberg words.ย Iโ€™ve seenย Saving Private Ryanย several times since its release. Each time Iโ€™ve seen something new in it. This time I was struck by Tom Hanksโ€™s Captain Millerโ€™s words to Matt Damonโ€™s Ryan. โ€œEarn this.โ€

This time against the backdrop of this election it hit home more than before that these two words werenโ€™t between two people but between all those who gave so much and all of us who have lived our lives with the gifts their terrible sacrifice brought. Earn this. We truly do owe them that much.

And I did ask Georgeโ€™s daughter Sheila about what was going through his mind as he cast his vote in this election. She asked him over dinner. He told her this:
“When I voted I felt happy to place my signature on a ballot against the Dictator. I was hoping more people wake up and check the right box.โ€

That one of those white men struggling ashore on the 6th of June so many years ago should live to vote for Americaโ€™s first Black woman President is a testament to this country and to all who serve.

And I admit that at first I felt uncomfortable with Georgeโ€™s word Dictator. It felt over the top. But then it set in that he is the one who knows, not me.

He is the one with the knowledge, and the experience, and the words we all must learn if we are to go through what his generation went through and re-emerge once again as America on the other side.

So much to earn. So much at stake. Please help us help George Mullins’s message reach everyone while it can still make a difference.

And please visitย Georgeโ€™s Facebook pageย and share a like, a hug, or even a heart. He has already earned it and so much more. What a life.

Time for us to be worthy,
Bill
bill@penzeys.comย 

Message-Not Unappreciated

mostly to Ten Bears;

Not taking this personally, but: I do not read every link in every post every time. I do read at least one link from each post with a link, as soon as I get there. I admire that you can do that! And if you’re ready to quit, I don’t blame you. Do as you will, but you are not unappreciated, FWIW. ๐Ÿ–– โ˜ฎ ๐ŸŒž I hope we still get to see ya around!

Only The Decent People Can Save Us (Again) by Oliver Willis

Decency Is On The Ballot Read on Substack

(Plus Kal El bonus at the bottom.-A)

In the last few decades, we have been witness to systematic failures in American life. Time and time again the guardrails we believed existed turned out to be illusions, or at best, guardrails without any teeth. The courts, the financial institutions, the legislators, and especially the media โ€“ entrusted as the watchdogs of democracy โ€“ have absolutely failed.

There is only one group that, more often than not, has been up to the task: The people. The people keep showing up and at the very least, voting to put people in charge to clean up the messes. Of course, once those people are in office they too often respond with timidity and reluctance and donโ€™t go as far as necessary to exercise the mandate they have been given, but the people did their jobs.

In every presidential election since 1988, with the exception of 2004, a plurality or majority of the public voted for the Democratic candidate. That is a data point you rarely see repeated and I am quite certain that if it was Republicans with such a popular vote winning streak both the party and the media would never shut up about it. That is a triumph of decency. It would be easy for voters to be snowed under by the rightโ€™s avalanche of lies and hate, ably amplified by their buck-chasing friends in the press, but the voters keep seeing through it.

To be certain, there are structural barriers. Neither Al Gore nor Hillary Clinton became president even though the will of the American people said they should have been. And the presidencies of Bill Clinton, Obama, and Biden have had too many missed opportunities to push the ball forward, even though all three of these men had mandates to go quite far.

But what matters is that enough voters saw through the haze of absolute bullshit to send a message to do the right thing.

Here we are again. The Republican Party has always glowed bright with a hateful intensity, but Trump has allowed them to move that hate from Mitt Romneyโ€™s โ€œquiet roomsโ€ to spotlights like Madison Square Garden. The press and the oligarchs that own it at institutions like The New York Times, the Washington Post, the L.A. Times, CNN and others, are quite happy to make billions of dollars from GOP fueled hate, as long as they can make a buck. They just donโ€™t care about the consequences.

Voters still care. It may be naรฏve or cringe, or corny, but they believe. Voters have shown us that a majority of them are opposed to hate, opposed to racism, opposed to misogyny, opposed to treating people as second class based on their orientation. And a majority of them are pro-decency.

Yes, most of the pro-decency vote has a liberal ideology but it is more than that. There are people who just donโ€™t like being crude bigots that spend all of their time shoving the faces of the vulnerable into the dirt. There are more of us than there are of them, and they have to effectively cheat or rig the rules to overcome our numbers.

Decency is on the march, but we are at a breaking point, again. Election day or week is not a โ€œfever breakโ€ moment. No matter the outcome, but especially if decency is victorious again, we cannot go to sleep. The bad boss at the end of the game has not been defeated. 2004 showed us that. 2008 showed us that. 2012. 2016. 2020. The forces of darkness and depravity do not respect the will of the people and if you retreat, expecting that everyone will finally accept the supremacy of decency โ€“ the other side will see that as an opening.

The decent people need to stand up for what they believe in and then keep standing, keep pushing back, until the other people are broken โ€“ and then decency most continue to advance and remain forever vigilant.

I voted for decency, and I always will. I know Iโ€™m not alone.

If you like this newsletter, please consider becoming a paying subscriber by clicking here to join. I wonโ€™t be putting any of my regular columns behind a paywall and they will always be free. Thanks to everyone who has subscribed so far!

โ€” Oliver

Follow me, Oliver Willis, on Threads @owillis1977

Exclusive Kal-El Photo

Kal once again shows how excited he is to work by my side.

cartoonists4kamala

It’s kinda been a day so I’m just finishing off comics at 9:30 PM Sunday; I found this on the GoComics Non Sequitur page! So cool!

cartoonists4kamala

It’s fun to window shop-enjoy!

Mel Manuel, Trans Candidate for U.S. House, Injected T on Camera in a Campaign Ad

Manuel is running on a platform of abortion rights, universal healthcare, and gun control.

BY SAMANTHA RIEDEL

(Way to go-run for office! Especially in and as opposition to people like Steve Scalise-A)

A trans nonbinary Louisiana candidate for the U.S. House released a defiant campaign video this week, showing themself injecting testosterone to defend bodily autonomy.

Mel Manuel, who is running to unseat far-right House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, released the video on social media platforms on Tuesday. In the video, Manuel called on voters to โ€œtake a standโ€ while performing a routine testosterone injection.

โ€œI believe that you, not the government, own your own body,โ€ Manuel told viewers, wearing a โ€œMy Body My Choiceโ€ T-shirt. โ€œLGBTQ+ rights are human rights.โ€

Manuel, who is running on a platform of abortion rights, universal healthcare, and gun control, highlighted a recent analysis that found Republicans had spent more than $65 million in anti-trans advertisements since the start of August. They also promoted Louisianaโ€™s โ€œGeaux Voteโ€ app, which allows voters to find their polling location and get ballot information.

โ€œTo my LGBTQ+ family and our alliesโ€ฆ No one is coming to save us,โ€ Manuel wrote in the video description. โ€œWe have to show up at the polls for ourselves and for those we love. Iโ€™ve spent the last year and a half campaigning because we need to speak up and be represented before itโ€™s too late. You can speak up now with your vote.โ€

Manuel is the cofounder of Queer Northshore, an LGBTQ+ activist organization based in St. Tammany Parish, and has previously organized against conservative book bans and anti-trans laws in the state. In contrast, Scalise has earned a reputation as a staunchly anti-LGBTQ+ Republican since first taking office in 2008, voting against the Byrd-Shepard Hate Crime Prevention Act, the repeal of Donโ€™t Ask, Donโ€™t Tell, and the Respect for Marriage Act; he is also firmly anti-trans, condemning โ€œthe left’s radical gender ideologyโ€ in a 2022 statement calling for trans girls to be banned from school sports. Scalise even once described himself as โ€œDavid Duke without the baggage,โ€ referring to the infamous former leader of the Ku Klux Klan.

Given that Manuel is running in opposition toย all that, injecting T on camera is a pretty big flex. Still, that doesnโ€™t necessarily mean they expect to win; as their campaign website notes, Manuelโ€™s goal is simply to get 35% of the vote. โ€œEven if your candidate doesnโ€™t win, if we can move the needle to 35 percent or 40 percent of the vote, that means the next progressive candidate will get more funding,โ€ they explained toย The Nationย last year. โ€œThereโ€™s a very, very small chance at winning, and I understand that, but we can still use the role of candidacy as a platform in and of itself.โ€

https://www.them.us/story/mel-manuel-campaign-ad-injection-testosterone

Intolerance and Judgmentalism

we could all use a Good News Tuesday by Jeff Tiedrich

(More good news, after Scottie’s video, as to the early voting news! Blue language alert, so no reading until you’re not somewhere the f-word is not acceptable. Else scroll just a bit, because of course the first sentence is joyous and contains the f-word. Also, italicized script beneath the suns are by the author, Jeff Tiedrich.)

Kamalaโ€™s up and Donnyโ€™s down Read on Substack

LA LA LA LA no reading here if you’re at work,

LA LA LA LA no reading here if you’re at work.

LA LA LA LA no reading here if you’re at work,

LA LA LA LA no reading here if you’re at work!

๐ŸŒž ๐ŸŒž ๐ŸŒž ๐ŸŒž ๐ŸŒž

Okay. Next line,

fuck this fucking nail-biter of an election. good news is out there โ€” letโ€™s have a look.

undecideds are deciding โ€” and theyโ€™re breaking towards Kamala Harris.

A majority of voters (80%) say they made up their minds about which candidate to support over a month ago, while 11% made up their minds in the last month, 6% made up their minds in the past week, and 3% still have not made up their mind. 

โ€œVoters who made their decision on who to support over a month ago break for Trump, 52% to 48%, while voters who made up their mind in the last month or week break for Harris, 60% to 36%,โ€ Kimball said. โ€œThe three percent of voters who said they could still change their mind currently favor Harris, 48% to 43%.โ€

I know, right? who could be undecided in a race thatโ€™s basically everyone gets a puppy vs diarrhea forever?

but there are huge swaths of votes who just donโ€™t pay attention to politics until the very last minute โ€” and now that theyโ€™re finally tuned in, itโ€™s dawning on them that wait, one of the candidates is ass-spraying mayhem? oh, fuck that shit.

think back to 1980. polling showed the race was a dead heat โ€” but in the final weeks, just about every goddamned undecided broke towards Reagan, and what looked like a nail-biter ended up being a blowout.

this year, however, it looks like the fence-sitters are doing the right thing.


hang on, you need some more good polling news? fine, be that way.

Kamala leads dong-obsessed fry chef Donny Convict in favorability by 11 percentage points, while 58% of registered voters fucking loathe Donny.

The nationwide poll, conducted last week, found Harrisโ€™s favorability to be significantly higher than Trumpโ€™s, with 51 percent of registered voters viewing Harris as a favorable candidate compared to just 40 percent who felt the same about Trump. Independent voters, notably, were equally split on their opinions of Harris, while the majority of independent votersโ€”58 percentโ€”felt negatively about Trump.

donโ€™t forget that this is going to be the first post-Roe national election.

But perhaps no Democratic stance resonated more with voters than abortion, which saw Harris lead Trump by 23 percent.

reproductive rights continues to be a losing issue for Donny, and heโ€™s still bragging about being the guy who shitcanned Roe.


Donny is being abandoned by his base.

white folks who never went to college have long been Donnyโ€™s most hardcore cultists โ€” but this year they seem to be suffering from Dear Leader Fatigue.

hereโ€™s CNNโ€™s Harry Enten to explain.

โ€œitโ€™s been a key demographic for him โ€” his base. and this is whatโ€™s so interesting โ€ฆ in fact, itโ€™s moving away from him. this is Trumpโ€™s margin with non-college white voters. this group is not moving towards him. itโ€™s moving slightly away. go back eight years ago, he won it by 33. you go back four years ago, he won it be 31. now we see heโ€™s only up by 27.โ€

Donnyโ€™s losing the people who have been filing out of his hate-rallies early.

after a half hour of listening to him drone on about sharks and batteries and Hannibal Lecter wants to have you for dinner, they turn to their spouse and say Lurleen, letโ€™s go home and see if NASCARโ€™s on TV.

plus-27 is still a fuck-ton of support from Donnyโ€™s base โ€” but in a close election, he canโ€™t afford to lose the additional 6% who voted for him in 2016. these people may never vote for Komrade Kamala, but enough of them may stay home on election day to make a difference.

weโ€™re all worried about post-election fuckery, but letโ€™s not forget that nearly all swing state governors are Democrats.

hereโ€™s WaPoโ€™s Jennifer Rubin to talk us all down off that ledge.

Constitutional expert Richard H. Pildes reminded us that scenarios involving mischief by governors are unlikely. โ€œIn nearly all the swing states, the governors are Democrats, who are hardly going to be receptive to any entreaties by Trump,โ€ he wrote. Even in Georgia, Gov. Brian Kemp and Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, both Republicans, โ€œhave done as much under fire as any political officials to prove their commitment to certifying an accurate, lawful count.โ€ And although a few local boards might refuse to certify, there are remedies in court. (A Georgia court recently rejected the notion that officials could refuse to certify results.)

and, on that note, some Arizona dipshit who thought she could fuck around with certifying her stateโ€™s 2022 senate race is now learning that finding out truly sucks.

An Arizona County elections official has agreed to plead guilty after she refused to certify the 2022 election in which Kari Lake lost to Katie Hobbs.

The Washington Post reported Monday that Peggy Judd, who helps lead Cochise County southeast of Phoenix, was indicted last year for allegedly โ€œflouting the stateโ€™s deadlinesโ€ for the 2022 election certification.

actions, consequences. itโ€™s nice when things work out in that order.


Jill Stein might be hurting Donny this year.

perpetual Kremlin dinner guest Jill Stein is like some fucked-up asteroid. every four years, her weird-ass orbit swings her too close to the Earth, and she ends up dicking with the tides and screwing with our electoral magnetic field.

Jillyโ€™s back, but a new poll apparently indicates that this year, sheโ€™s taking away votes from Donny.

A new poll suggests that Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein is drawing more voters from former President Donald Trump than from Vice President Kamala Harris.

The poll shows Harris leading Trump 49 percent to 47 percent. However, with Stein in the race, Trump’s support dips to 46 percent, while Harris maintains her 49 percent backing, suggesting that Stein draws more support from Trump than from Harris. Though Stein’s voter base remains relatively small, at about 1 percent, it could prove crucial in an election that hinges on tight margins in swing states.


the five innocent and exonerated black men known as the Central Park Five are suing Donny for defamation.

The five men who make up the Central Park Five and now call themselves the Exonerated Five have filed a defamation lawsuit against Donald Trump over his remarks during the presidential debate last month.

During the debate he said: “They admitted โ€” they said, they pled guilty. And I said, well, if they pled guilty they badly hurt a person, killed a person ultimately. And if they pled guilty โ€” then they pled weโ€™re not guilty.”

At the time of the trials, each had pleaded not guilty, and the victim of the attack survived.

ok, this one is not election-related news โ€” but it still makes me laugh to see Donny get served another big, fat slice of Justice Pie.


Donny continues to be an increasingly-deteriorating imbecile.

โ€œitโ€™s as big a waterโ€” yโ€™know, itโ€™s as big a water-storm, they say, as weโ€™ve ever seen.โ€

โ€˜water-storm?โ€™ the word is hurricane, you decompensating dotard.

Alexa, whatโ€™s aphasia?

Aphasia is a language disorder that affects how you communicate. It’s caused by damage in the area of the brain that controls language expression and comprehension. Aphasia leaves a person unable to communicate effectively with others.

Alexa, can aphasia be a sign of dementia?

what the fuck do you think?


so, thereโ€™s lots of good news all around โ€” but as a commenter under yesterdayโ€™s post said, โ€œwe still have to fight like weโ€™re ten points down.โ€ that person is exactly right. we donโ€™t have the luxury of complacency. thatโ€™s how we fucked it up in 2016 โ€” we all thought Hillaryโ€™s got this in the bag, and so we blew up the balloons and popped the champagne way too early, and too many of us decided it was totes okay stay home on election day. after all, Nate Silver promised us that Hillary had a 99% chance of victory, right? but polls donโ€™t vote โ€” people do.

this year, we all understand the assignment.

Kamala understands the assignment, too. unlike the email lady in 2016, Kamala and Uncle Tim are hitting all the swing states. meanwhile, Donny Convict is squandering his time doing vanity rallies in places like California and New York โ€” states he hasnโ€™t a snowballโ€™s chance of winning.

14 days to the election. if we vote, we win.

Things to Remind People in the Grocery Line

or wherever mentions of prices, and whatever else has improved since Pres. Biden took office. I post this because my own US Rep is campaigning about how bad everything is, with facts from the Don’s admin when they’re facts at all. I’m certain he’s not the only “safe” (I voted for the Dem-we actually have a Dem running!) Republican running for the US House, as they’re all up for election every two years. Anyway, he makes the claims that things are bad under Biden-Harris, and how he’s just focusing on improving those very things that have improved thanks to Biden-Harris and the legislators who managed to get things passed (most Republicans are not among those legislators, btw.) Anyway, here’s Heather Cox Richardson:

October 17, 2024

Heather Cox Richardson

Oct 18, 2024

In a new rule released yesterday, the Federal Trade Commission requires sellers to make it as easy to cancel a subscription to a gym or a service as it is to sign up for one. In a statement, FTC chair Lina Khan explained the reasoning behind the โ€œclick-to-cancelโ€ rule: โ€œToo often, businesses make people jump through endless hoops just to cancel a subscription,โ€ she said. โ€œNobody should be stuck paying for a service they no longer want.โ€ Although most of the new requirements wonโ€™t take effect for about six months, David Dayen of The American Prospect noted that the stock price of Planet Fitness fell 8% after the announcement. 

When he took office in January 2021, with democracy under siege from autocratic governments abroad and an authoritarian movement at home, President Joe Biden set out to prove that democracy could deliver for the ordinary people who had lost faith in it. The click-to-cancel rule is an illustration of an obvious and long-overdue protection, but it is only one of many waysโ€”$35 insulin, new bridges, loan forgiveness, higher wages, good jobsโ€”in which policies designed to benefit ordinary people have demonstrated that a democratic government can improve lives.

When Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen spoke to the Council on Foreign Relations yesterday, she noted that the administration โ€œhas driven a historic economic recoveryโ€ with strong growth, very low unemployment rates, and inflation returning to normal. Now it is focused on lowering costs for families and expanding the economy while reducing inequality. That strong economy at home is helping to power the global economy, Yellen noted, and the U.S. has been working to strengthen that economy by reinforcing global policies, investments, and institutions that reinforce economic stability. 

โ€œOver the past four years, the world has been through a lot,โ€ Yellen said, โ€œfrom a once-in-a-century pandemic, to the largest land war in Europe since World War II, to increasingly frequent and severe climate disasters. This has only underlined that we are all in it together. Americaโ€™s economic well-being depends on the worldโ€™s, and Americaโ€™s economic leadership is key to global prosperity and security.โ€ She warned against isolationism that would undermine such prosperity both at home and abroad.

The numbers behind the proven experience that government protection of ordinary people is good for economic growth got the blessing of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences on Monday, when it awarded the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences to Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson, both of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and to James Robinson of the University of Chicago. Their research explains why โ€œ[s]ocieties with a poor rule of law and institutions that exploit the population do not generate growth or change for the better,โ€ while democracies do.   

Although democracy has been delivering for Americans, Donald Trump and MAGAs rose to power by convincing those left behind by 40 years of supply-side economics that their problem was not the people in charge of the government, but rather the government itself. 

Trump wants to get rid of the current government so that he can enrich himself, do whatever he wants to his enemies, and avoid answering to the law. The Christian nationalists who wrote Project 2025 want to destroy the federal government so they can put in place an authoritarian who will force Americans to live under religious rule. Tech elites like Elon Musk and Peter Thiel want to get rid of the federal government so they can control the future without having to worry about regulations. 

In place of what they insist is a democratic system that has failed, they are offering a strongman who, they claim, will take care of people more efficiently than a democratic government can. The focus on masculinity and portrayals of Trump as a muscled heroโ€š much as Russian president Vladimir Putin portrays himself, fit the mold of an authoritarian leader.

But the argument that Americans need a strongman depends on the argument that democracy does not work. In the last three-and-a-half years, Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris, and the Democrats have proved that it can, so long as it operates with the best interests of ordinary people in mind. Trump and Vanceโ€™s outlandish lies about the federal response to Hurricane Helene are designed to override the reality of a competent administration addressing a crisis with all the tools it has. In its place, the lies provide a false narrative of federal officials ignoring people and trying to steal their property.  

Their attack on democracy has another problem, as well. In addition to the reality that democracy has been delivering for Americans for more than three years nowโ€”and pretty dramaticallyโ€”Trump is no longer a strongman. Vice President Kamala Harris is outperforming  him in the theater of political dominance. And as she does so, his image is crumbling.

In an article in US News and World Report yesterday, NBCโ€™s former chief marketer John D. Miller apologized to America for helping to โ€œcreate a monster.โ€ Miller led the team that marketed The Apprentice, the reality TV show that made Trump a household name. โ€œTo sell the show,โ€ Miller wrote, โ€œwe created the narrative that Trump was a super-successful businessman who lived like royalty.โ€ But the truth was that he declared bankruptcy six times, and โ€œ[t]he imposing board room where he famously fired contestants was a set, because his real boardroom was too old and shabby for TV,โ€ Miller wrote. While Trump loved the attention the show provided, โ€œmore successful CEOs were too busy to get involved in reality TV.โ€ 

Miller says they โ€œpromoted the show relentlessly,โ€ blanketing the country with a โ€œhighly exaggeratedโ€ image of Trump as a successful businessman โ€œlike a heavy snowstorm.โ€ โ€œ[W]eโ€ฆdid irreparable harm by creating the false image of Trump as a successful leader,โ€ Miller wrote. โ€œI deeply regret that. And I regret that it has taken me so long to go public.โ€ 

Speaking as a โ€œborn-and-bred Republican,โ€ Miller warned: โ€œIf you believe that Trump will be better for you or better for the country, that is an illusion, much like The Apprentice was.โ€ He strongly urged people to vote for Kamala Harris. โ€œThe country will be better off and so will you.โ€ 

A new video shown last night on Jimmy Kimmel Live even more powerfully illustrated the collapse of Trumpโ€™s tough guy image. Written by Jesse Joyce of Comedy Central, the two-minute video featured actor and retired professional wrestler Dave Bautista dominating his sparring partner in a boxing ring and then telling those who think Trump is โ€œsome sort of tough guyโ€ that โ€œheโ€™s not.โ€ 

Working out in a gym, Bautista insults Trumpโ€™s heavy makeup, out-of-shape body, draft dodging, and physical weakness, and notes that โ€œhe sells imaginary baseball cards pretending to be a cowboy firemanโ€ when โ€œheโ€™s barely strong enough to hold an umbrella.โ€ Bautista says Trumpโ€™s two-handed method of drinking water looks โ€œlike a little pink chickadee,โ€ and goes on to make a raunchy observation about Trumpโ€™s stage dancing. โ€œHeโ€™s moody, he pouts, he throws tantrums,โ€ Bautista goes on. โ€œHeโ€™s cattier on social media than a middle-school mean girl.โ€

Bautista ends by listing Trumpโ€™s fears of rain, dogs, windmillsโ€ฆand being laughed at.โ€ โ€œAnd mostly,โ€ Bautista concludes, โ€œheโ€™s terrified that real, red-blooded American men will find out that heโ€™s a weak, tubby toddler.โ€ Calling Trump a โ€œwhiny b*tch,โ€ Bautista walks away from the camera. 

The sketch was billed as comedy, but it was deadly serious in its takedown of the key element of Trumpโ€™s political power.

And he seems vulnerable. Forbes and Newsweek have recently questioned his mental health; yesterday the Boston Globe ran an op-ed saying, โ€œTrumpโ€™s decline is too dangerous to ignore. We can see the decline in the former presidentโ€™s ability to hold a train of thought, speak coherently, or demonstrate a command of the English language, to say nothing of policy.โ€ 

Trumpโ€™s Fox News Channel town hall yesterday got 2.9 million viewers; Harrisโ€™s interview got 7.1 million. Today, Trump canceled yet another appearance, this one with the National Rifle Association in Savannah, Georgia, scheduled for October 22, where he was supposed to be the keynote speaker.

Meanwhile, Vice President Harris today held rallies in Milwaukee, Green Bay, and La Crosse, Wisconsin. In La Crosse, MAGA hecklers tried to interrupt her while she was speaking about the centrality of the three Trump-appointed Supreme Court justices to the overturning of the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision that recognized the constitutional right to abortion. 

โ€œOh, you guys are at the wrong rally,โ€ Harris called to them with a smile and a wave. As the crowd roared with approval, she added: โ€œNo, I think you meant to go to the smaller one down the street.โ€ 

โ€”

Notes:

https://www.npr.org/2024/10/16/nx-s1-5154814/click-to-cancel-subscriptions-memberships-ftc-rule

https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/10/federal-trade-commission-announces-final-click-cancel-rule-making-it-easier-consumers-end-recurring

https://www.msnbc.com/the-reidout/reidout-blog/dave-bautista-trump-jimmy-kimmel-masculinity-rcna175963

https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy2654

https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2023/03/29/remarks-by-president-biden-at-the-summit-for-democracy-virtual-plenary-on-democracy-delivering-on-global-challenges/

https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2024/press-release/

https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2024/popular-information/

https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-ditches-nra-event-latest-cancellation-1970902

https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2024-10-16/we-created-a-tv-illusion-for-the-apprentice-but-the-real-trump-threatens-america

https://www.newsweek.com/kamala-harris-fox-news-interview-ratings-donald-trump-1970906

https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/10/16/opinion/trump-cognitive-decline-press-republicans/

https://www.forbes.com/sites/saradorn/2024/10/16/trumps-unwieldy-speeches-raise-questions-about-his-mental-acuity/

https://www.newsweek.com/dancing-donald-trump-clearly-steep-decline-opinion-1969551

X:

ddayen/status/1846991070309101761

ddayen/status/1847011806587634007

carlquintanilla/status/1847051458618736920

KamalaHQ/status/1847026957407449361

YouTube:

watch?v=rn-Dw2JUVmo&t=910s (video starts at 15.23)