This is linked in a Substack I read. In and on its own merit, I’m bringing it here for people to take a look. I think it’ll be worthwhile. I wish that people in Yemen and refugees from Gaza and people in all troubled places had this opportunity, but there it is; we have this. Anyway, take a look, subscribe if you like, or pass it along, and send a good thought into the universe on behalf of parents and children and stopping war.
Becoming a mother amid war in Ukraine by Anastasiia Lapatina
Two days after the birth of my daughter, Russia launched one of its largest air attacks on Kyiv. It was terrifying, but also entirely expected, and that’s the worst part. Read on Substack
Adidas has apologised to the model Bella Hadid after pulling adverts in which she was promoting a sport shoe first launched to coincide with the 1972 Munichย Olympics.
Adidas last week said it was โrevisingโ its campaign after criticism from Israel over Hadidโs involvement in the campaign for the retro SL72 trainers. Hadid is an American whose family has roots in Palestine.
The apology, issued on Instagram, said: โConnections continue to be made to the terrible tragedy that occurred at the Munich Olympics due to our recent SL72 campaign,โ referring to the 1972 Munich Olympics massacre when Israeli athletes were taken hostage by the Black September Organization, a Palestinian militant group. Eleven Israelis, a German police officer and five of the attackers died.
The statement continued: โThese connections are not meant, and we apologise for any upset or distress caused to communities around the world. We made an unintentional mistake. We also apologise to our partners, Bella Hadid, ASAP Nast, Jules Koundรฉ, and others, for any negative impact on them and we are revising the campaign.โ
On Friday, the German-based company had said in a statement it was โrevising the remainder of the campaignโ after criticism over Hadidโs involvement by Israel on X. โGuess who the face of their campaign is?โ read a post on Israelโs official account. โBella Hadid, a model who has a history of spreading antisemitism and calling for violence against Israelis and Jews.โ
Hadid had previously been criticised by Israel for allegedly chanting: โFrom the river to the sea, Palestine will be free,โon a march in 2021.
Adidas was condemned by some Jewish organisations, with the American Jewish Committee labelling its decision as either a โmassive oversight or intentionally inflammatoryโ. Others came out in support of Hadid. One fellow Adidas ambassador, the Palestinian-American author and activist Amani al-Khatahtbeh, posted an email she sent to Adidas on X, in which she said: โBella Hadid is a model of Palestinian origin that has been a much-needed outspoken advocate for human right.โ She added: โAdidasโs disappointing response conflates our Palestinian identity with terrorism.โ
Hadid, 27, whose father is the Palestinian businessman Mohamed Hadid, has been vocal in her support for Palestine. In May she expressed her solidarity by wearing a dress crafted out of red and white keffiyehs during the film festival in Cannes. In 2023 she denounced the far-right Israeli national security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir for saying Jewish settlers had more rights than Palestinians in occupied territories.
When she appeared on the cover of Vogue magazine in 2021, she said on Instagram: โA Palestinian girl on the cover of Vogue. The joy it brings me to say that โฆ I wonโt stop talking about the systematic oppression, pain and humility that Palestinians face on a regular basis.โ
Hadid, who recently launched her own wellness brand, has faced death threats for her outspoken support.
The apology to Hadid and her fellow Adidas partners comes amid reports that she is speaking to lawyers about her options.
So the other day I was so tired I couldn’t function.ย Ron got home after driving straight through to get home that night, so I was up until midnight after getting up at 3 am the morning before.ย ย So I was in no shape to blog.ย So I spent the day with my hubby after he got home from being on a long trip to bury his brother and seeing his family.ย Then I got up this morning at 3 am, and after feeding the cats I went on the MS site I always check first.ย I have been sharing and helping others on the site and have started to get quite a few doing private chats with me.ย They say I am kind, caring, and nice to talk to … I will take it.ย ย
But just before I was to get off there and go to my blog, a guy showed up blaming his once … unwanted … blow job from a man overturning his entire life and now he is anti gay people, rainbow flags, pride, and any showing of gays in society because they are all abusers and child molesters.ย He went on at length about how abusive and dysfunctional gay people were, how they were flaunting themselves in an abusive way in society, so on and so on.ย Remember he is in a site for males abused as children sexually and in other ways.ย ย
Anyone who knows me knows I can not resist such shit.ย He threatened right in his first post that if people said he needed therapy, he was bi or searching, or that he was a bigot then he was gone.ย I was like OK.ย I answered every paragraph he wrote, telling him he needed help professionally on some, telling him that because he says he now had thoughts of sex with men that he might be seeking and should again talk to professionals about it, as that is not the way sexual assaults work.ย One forced blow job doesn’t make a man who only thought of women before gay.ย I called out his bigotry when he posted how gays were now in schools with rainbow stickers to make kids gay.ย I even outright asked him if he was a troll.ย ย We will see.ย But I have been there on that site since basically 3 am to now nearly 1 pm.ย ย I am going to skip posts and go right to comments.ย Again like always if I missed your comment because it dropped off the list please resubmit it, I will do my best to reply.ย ย Hugs Scottie
The conservative blueprint envisions โa biblically basedโ definition of marriage and wants to protect adoption agencies that only work with Christians
Rebecca McCrayWed 24 Jul 2024 07.00 EDTShare
In 2021, Liz and Gabe Rutan-Ram decided to take the next step toward growing their family and applied to foster a child. After identifying a three-year-old in Florida who they hoped to ultimately adopt, the Rutan-Rams turned back to their home state of Tennessee to start training to become foster parents.
But their plans quickly fell apart when the Christian state-funded foster care placement agency informed them by email that they โonly provide adoption services to prospective adoptive families that share our belief systemโ. The Rutan-Rams, who are Jewish, were out of luck.
โThereโs already emotions playing into wanting to be a parent, and then to have us attacked personally just made it that much harder,โ Liz Rutan-Ram told the Guardian.
The Rutan-Rams sued the Tennessee department of childrenโs services, arguing that a state law permitting private agencies to refuse to work with prospective parents on religious grounds violates the Tennessee constitutionโs equal protection and religious freedom guarantees. The case will soon go to trial.
The predicament facing the Rutan-Rams could become more common under a second Trump administration. Project 2025, a 900-plus page blueprint for the next Republican administration and the policy brainchild of the conservative Heritage Foundation, contains an explicitly sympathetic view toward โfaith-based adoption agenciesโ like the one that rejected the Rutan-Rams, who are โunder threat from lawsuitsโ because of the agenciesโ religious beliefs.
Project 2025โs Adoption Reform section calls for the passage of legislation to ensure providers โcannot be subjected to discrimination for providing adoption and foster care services based on their beliefs about marriageโ. It also calls for the repeal of an Obama-era regulation that prohibits discrimination against prospective parents and subsequent amendments made by the Biden administration.
Though Donald Trump has tried to distance himself from the project, his campaignโs own 16-page policy agenda echoes many of its goals, and his ties to the planโs architects are well-established. In Milwaukee last week, the Heritage Foundationโs role in the Republican national convention was on full display, both on welcome banners at the airport and in the millions of dollars invested in the event itself. Following Trumpโs announcement of his vice-presidential pick, the organizationโs president, Kevin Roberts, said he was โgood friendsโ with JD Vance, and effusively declared him โa man who personifies hope for our nationโs futureโ. Vance has previously said there were โsome good ideasโ in Project 2025.
Project 2025 is divided into four broad pillars, the first of which is to โrestore the family as the centerpiece of American life and protect our childrenโ. A conservative vision of family pervades the document, and the authors call on policymakers โto elevate family authority, formation, and cohesion as their top priority and even use government power, including through the tax code, to restore the American familyโ.
The plan envisions upholding โa biblically based, social science-reinforced definition of marriage and familyโ. It would remove nondiscrimination roadblocks governing faith-based grant recipients, such as the agency that denied the Rutan-Rams. The authors argue that โheterosexual, intact marriagesโ provide more stability for children than โall other family formsโ. In addition to calling for the passage of the Child Welfare Provider Inclusion Act, which would allow adoption and foster care agencies to make placement decisions based on their โreligious beliefs or moral convictionsโ, it also calls on Congress to ensure โreligious employersโ are exempt from nondiscrimination laws and free to make business decisions based on their religious beliefs.
To the Rev Naomi Washington-Leapheart, a professor of theology and religious studies at Villanova University and a queer parent, the image of family portrayed by the policy agenda is blatantly exclusionary. The Christian nationalist plan rejects unmarried parents, single parents and LGBTQ+ families.
A billboard in Milwaukee, part of a campaign by Americans United for Separation of Church and State, to raise awareness of Project 2025, that ran during the Republican convention. Photograph: Americans United for Separation of Church and State
โThe definition of family according to Project 2025 leaves a lot of folk out,โ Washington-Leapheart told the Guardian. โThis blueprint really delegitimizes the kinds of families that are day in and day out raising children, paying taxes, contributing meaningfully to society.โ
The Rutan-Rams have become the face of a campaign led by Americans United for Separation of Church and State, who are representing them in their lawsuit, that seeks to shed light on what they call the Christian nationalist goals of Project 2025. As part of the campaign, visitors to the Republican convention last week may have seen billboards reading โYou gotta keep โem separated,โ in reference to church and state.
Project 2025โs vision is already law in a number of states. The Rutan-Rams are battling a Tennessee law, modeled after similar laws in at least 10 other states, that permits faith-based foster care and adoption agencies to exclusively work with prospective parents who share their beliefs.
Amanda Tyler, executive director of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty and author of a book titled How to End Christian Nationalism, contends that the scale and reach of Project 2025 pose a far greater danger to democracy than a patchwork of state laws.
โWhatโs different about Project 2025 is the sweeping nature of its plan,โ said Tyler. โIt would really rewrite the federal government and change policies in so many different areas at once in a way that would hasten our journey down that road to authoritarian theocracy.โ
The Holston Home for Children in Tennessee, Project 2025 and the Heritage Foundation did not respond to requests for comment.
Tyler worries that Project 2025โs deliberate erosion of the separation between church and state, a founding principle embedded in the first amendment to the US constitution, will get a helping hand from the US supreme court, which has handed a series of victories in recent years to Christian activists. She specifically mentioned the 2021 decision in Carson v Makin, which struck down a Maine law that banned the use of public funds for religious schools. It was โan earthquake of a decision that a lot of people didnโt really pay attention to that has really opened the door to government funding of religionโ, said Tyler.
The threat of a theocracy doesnโt seem far-fetched to Washington-Leapheart.
โProject 2025 says that religion is a permanent institution that should influence American life,โ said Washington-Leapheart. โThat alone communicates the kind of arrogant way Christianity is situated as an inevitability. And itโs not. I say that as a Christian person who is firmly grounded in my faith. It is not an inevitable part of my identity, it is a choice I make every day.
On the secondย day of the Republican National Convention, I made my wayย backย to Milwaukeeโs symphony hall to attend a town hall hosted by the conservative parentsโ rights group Moms for Liberty. This wasnโt my first Moms for Liberty eventโIโve attended the annual summits for the past two years. Back inย 2022, Betsy DeVos, who served as former President Donald Trumpโs Secretary of Education, delivered the line that got the loudest applause. โWhile I know that everything we did was with the interest of kids in mind and policies that would really give as much power back to the states and local communities as we possibly could,โ she said, โI personally think the Department of Education should not exist.โ
At the time, that statement felt a little bit edgyโlike DeVos was saying the quiet part out loud. But two years later at yesterdayโs event, many of the panelists expressed that same sentiment as a a foregone conclusion. โThe fundamental problem that we have in the United States was the creation of the federal Department of Education,โ Rep. Harriet Hageman (R-WY) told the crowd of maybe 400 or so mostly white women. In his remarks, erstwhile GOP presidential hopefulย Vivek Ramaswamyย said, โWeโre not just going to reform the Department of Education, it means weโre going to get there and actually shut it down.โ
Does that mean that a ragtag group of moms single handedly turned the abolition of a behemoth government agency into a run-of-the-mill conservative talking point? Not exactly. On that issue and many others, Moms for Liberty has had a major assist from powerful conservative groups that share their goalsโand are shaping the Republican agenda for 2024.
Founded in 2021ย by three former school board members in Florida, Moms for Liberty rode the rising tide of anti-mask sentiment in the tumultuous year after schools were closed during the pandemic. The groupโs leaders capitalized on the backlash to the Black Lives Matter movement after the murder of George Floyd. In fact, Moms for Liberty was one of the most prominent early groups to criticize the teaching of ant-racist curriculum in schools, which theyย incorrectly referredย to as โcritical race theory.โ The group also vociferously opposed LGBTQ-inclusive lessons, and its members ledย campaignsย to rid classrooms and school libraries of books deemed inappropriate.
Over time, Moms for Liberty grew in both membership and influence. Today, the groupย countsย 130,000 members across chapters in 48 states. The organization groomed some members to run for local school boards, gradually expanding their influence throughout communities. Last year, all of the Republican presidential candidates, including former president Donald Trump, spoke at their annual conference in Pennsylvania.
In its marketing, Moms for Liberty comes off as a group of like-minded people, mostly women, who all happened to come together because of a shared concern for children. Founders Tiffany Justice and Tina Deskovich, the website says, are just a couple of โmoms on a mission to stoke the fires of liberty.โ But as Iโve previouslyย reported, the organizationโs connections to the Republican party run deep. Its conferences have been sponsored by the GOP training group theย Leadership Instituteย and the conservative powerhouse think tank the Heritage Foundation. Earlier this week, after the RNC Heritage Foundation event, Moms for Liberty national director Catalina Stubbe told me that her group is โvery close friendsโ with Heritage, which was one of the sponsors of todayโs event, and whose president Kevin Roberts spoke on one of the panels.
ย
Considering the groupโs cozy relationship with Heritage, the RNC town hall panelistsโ focus on abolishing the US Department of Education shouldnโt be surprising. Project 2025, the 920-page conservative policy roadmap that Heritage spearheaded,ย callsย for the complete elimination of the Department of Education, along with the codification of parentsโ rights laws similar to those in Florida, which strictly limit teachersโ use of LGBTQ-inclusive curriculum and books.
After the event, I spoke to Lydia Dominguez, a Moms for Liberty member running for school board in Clark County, Nevada. Dominguez, the mother of two teenage boys, told me that she believed schools โare being oversaturated by national agendas.โ What kinds of national agendas? I asked. โTheyโre having CNN in the classroom,โ she said. โTheyโre pushing national topics such as the transgender topics, sexualized content.โ
โโโโโ She believed schools โare being oversaturated by national agendasโฆTheyโre having CNN in the classroom,โ she said. โTheyโre pushing national topics such as the transgender topics, sexualized content.โ โโโโโ
Monica Kepes serves as the secretary of a Moms for Liberty chapter in Washington County, Wisconsin. โI think the big bureaucratic institutions are instituting a lot of stuff that comes down through the education system,โ she said. โI think the bigger you get, the more power there is, the more chance corruption and all that kind of stuff.โ
At Moms forย Libertyโs upcoming 2024 summit, which will take place next month in Washington, DC, it seems unlikely that the group will be able to muster a repeat performance of the star-studded speaker roster from last year. So far, this yearโsย listย appears to be a grab bag of not especially famous ultra-conservative pundits, C-list comedians, and culture warriors. One reason for this lackluster lineup could be the fallout from a series of scandals in 2023. A group from a chapter in Kentuckyย posedfor a photo with the white nationalist group the Proud Boys. (Those members were later removed from the group.) Last year, a chapter leader in Indianaย quoted Hitlerย in a newsletter. On the last evening of the annual summit a few months later, Justice, the co-founder, said in a speech, โOne of our moms in a newsletter quotes HitlerโฆI stand with that mom!โ
Butย the most damagingย setbackcame in late 2023, when Christian Ziegler, chair of the Florida GOP, was accused of raping and illegally filming a woman who had been involved in a sexual relationship with him and his wife, Bridget Ziegler, a founding member of Moms for Liberty. As Iย wroteย at the time, the situation was especially awkward because Ziegler helped craft Floridaโs so-called โDonโt Say Gayโ parentsโ rights law, which forbids teachers in the state from talking about same-sex relationships. โThe irony is crazy because you have this woman and her husband who are so concerned with preventing children from hearing anything that doesnโt totally align with their values,โ one Florida mom told me at the time. โAnd then itโs like, Iโm having to explain a three-way to a 12-year-old this week.โ (Christian Ziegler has beenย clearedย of rape charges; in March, the Florida state attorneyโs officeย declinedย to criminally charge him for illegally filming the sexual encounter because of insufficient evidence.)
ย
Unsurprisingly, no one mentioned the sex scandal (or any of the other ones) at the town hall event. But on one panel, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis took a victory lap about a bill Ziegler helped to create. โIt used to beโฆyou didnโt have to worry about your kid going to kindergarten and being told that they should change their gender,โ he said. โWe put the kibosh on that in Floridaโwe said, โWe are not going to be indulging in things like gender ideology in our schools.โโ The crowd whooped with approval.
The Republican Party seems to agree. Its officialย platform, released last week, calls for funding cuts for schools that embrace โwokeโ policies like LGBTQ-inclusive curriculum. This serves as a reminder that even though Moms for Libertyโs star appears to have dimmed over the past year, the reverberations from its movement will be felt for years to come. Moms for Liberty, cofounder Tina Descovich told the crowd, โis here to fight, fight, fight, and win, win, win.โ She paused. โAnd winning we are.โ
I did not post the full X / tweets about Kamal nor about Pete because they are exceedingly racist, bigoted and crude, a typical maga response to anything not straight cis white.ย I am sick of these people that tRump enabled and the sooner we beat tRump soundly and put his people back under their rocks they crawled out from for good the better for the US.ย But seriously if this racist bigotry is the best they can do, we already won.ย ย Hugs.ย Scottie
——————————————————————————————————–
For a lot of conservatives, all they can say about Kamala Harris are gross, sexist comments.
Vice President Kamala Harris speaks with D.L. Hughley highlighting how the Biden-Harris Administration has taken historic steps to advance economic opportunity by improving access to housing, creating jobs and investing in small businesses as part of her nationwide Economic Opportunity Tour on Thursday May 16, 2024 at Discovery World in Milwaukee, Wis.Photo: Jovanny Hernandez / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK / USA TODAY NETWORK via IMAGN
Republican Missouri secretary of state candidate Valentina Gomez just went on an unhinged rant attacking Vice President Kamala Harris on X, where she called her a โlittle wh*re,โ as conservatives posted misogynist memes and jokes about Harris.
โKamala Harris slept her way to the top, and Tulsi Gabbard already destroyed and exposed her in 2020. Kamala is just another DEI hire, and President Trump is going to eat her alive,โ she said in a video.
She could become president. Hereโs a closer look at her history on LGBTQ+ stances.
โKamala Haris is a little wh*re,โ Gomez wrote when posting her video. [Update: The X post was put on โlimitedโ visibility by Xย on July 22, 2024, hours after this article was published.]
โ Valentina Gomez (@ValentinaForSOS)ย July 21, 2024
The comment regarding Harris allegedly having sex to advance her career, alongside the โlittle wh*reโ comment, reflects recent bouts of misogyny against the vice president in an attempt to discredit her. Harris is the first woman to ever be vice president of the United States and could be the first woman president of the country.
The claim has also notably been spread by far-right figurehead Matt Walsh, who said on X,ย โKamala Harris got her start in politics by sleeping with Willie Brown. She became Vice President because Biden needed a non-white female on the ticketโฆ Sheโs made a career out of begging for hand outs from powerful men. A thoroughly unimpressive human being.โ
ย
These claims refer to a short relationship Harris had with former San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown 30 years ago, before he became mayor. There is no evidence that she only had a relationship with him to bolster her career. In aย Reuters fact check, both Harris and Brown disputed that this relationship led anywhere and instead regarded it as largely irrelevant.
Other users attacked her as a โside chickโ of Brown, referring to the fact that Brown was technically married during his time dating Harris. However, Brown was separated from his wife, making this claim misleading at best.
ย
Other conservatives, though, just posted gross memes about Harris that sexualized her, showing both sexism and misogynoir, or the combination of sexism and racism directed at Black women.
This is seen with one post comparing Harris to the โHawk Tuahโ girl, someone known in aย viral memeย about engaging in fellatio.
ย
One X user continued these claims, referring to her as โarm candyโ for reality TV show host Montel Williams. The twoย briefly datedย in 2001, however Williams has said since that he has โgreat respect for Sen. Harris.โ
ย
Right-wing commentator Konstantin Kisin referred to her as a โvagina of colour,โ and another user referred to her and out Transportation Secretary โ and possible running mate โ Pete Buttigieg as the โblowjob ticket,โ reflecting both misogyny and homophobia.
ย
One political cartoonist made a comic of Harris giving fellatio to the Washington Monument, while another user made a post suggesting Harris wants to perform sexual acts on enough voters to get elected.
ย
Another user documented multiple accounts making memes of Harris engaging in sexual acts to various different presidential logos.
Once prominent and now largely forgotten alt-right icon and โex-gay trollโ Milo Yiannopoulos made a post encouraging people to rely on him for objectification of Harris.
ย
The attacks against Harris have been reflected in merchandise made about her. One shirt being sold says โJoe and the Hoe Gotta Goe,โ a slogan thatโsย parrotedย in other right-wing merchandise that, while not officially endorsed by the GOP, has nevertheless been prominent among the Republican voter base
Gomezโs claim about former Rep. Tulsi Gabbard (I-HI) attacking Harris is rooted in an oldย political debateย where Gabbard criticized Harrisโs history as Californiaโs attorney general, pointing out her thousands of convictions of people who used cannabis. Additionally, Gabbard criticized Harrisโs handling of people on death row, alleging that Harris could have done much more to protect innocent individuals.
This claim reflects the widespread public concern about Harrisโs history as a prosecutor with many likening the candidate to a corrupt police officer. This is further reflected in criticism about her denying a trans womanย gender-affirming careย while in prison. She has since walked back on this decision.
Nevertheless, the misogyny reflected among right-wing criticisms largely ignores any critiques of her policy positions and instead aims to reflect on her sexual and romantic history. This neglects her substance as a person and a candidate and swipes aside any debates about her merit as a candidate. Notably, these types of posts are rarely directed at male candidates.
Gov. Ron DeSantis speaks during a press conference at the FGCU Kapnick Education and Research Center in Naples on Tuesday, April 23, 2024.Photo: Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida / USA TODAY NETWORK
While Republican lawmakers have repeatedly failed to pass legislation to prevent transgender people from updating their birth certificates to reflect their gender identity, the state has nonetheless been denying requests from both trans adults and minors to do so for the past year.
According toย The 19th, since last year, trans minors and adults in the state have received letters from the Florida Department of Healthโs Bureau of Vital Statistics denying their requests for amended birth certificates even when all their other government-issued ID documents reflect their gender identity and despite the fact that they have provided documentation of their gender transition that has previously been accepted.
In one March 2024 letter reviewed by the outlet, the agency said that documentary evidence provided by the applicant โdoes not establish that the sex identifier on the birth record contains a misstatement, error, or omission.โ
Another from August 2023 said that for trans minors, โdocumentary evidence established prior to the childโs seventh birthday is required,โ while a separate letter says that trans adults must provide documentation โestablished prior to the registrantโs 18th birthday.โ Asย The 19thย notes, for many trans people who were either unaware of or still figuring out their gender identity or were unable to access gender-affirming care as children, either requirement would be nearly impossible to provide.
Simone Chriss, an attorney with Florida-based Southern Legal Counsel (SLC), toldย The 19thย that of the around 80 clients she has worked with since August 2023 who have appealed the agencyโs denials, none have been able to obtain an amended birth certificate reflecting their gender identity. Most of her clientsโ appeals, she said, โare just being ignored.โ
โIโve filed many,โ said Chriss, who is also the director of SLCโs transgender rights initiative. โThereโs at least five that I have pending at this moment that the department hasnโt responded to.โ
ย
Since 2018, trans Floridians have been able to provide documentation from a doctor showing that they have received gender-affirming care in order to get their birth certificates updated to reflect their gender identity. Before that, only trans people who could provide proof of gender-affirming surgery could qualify for an amended document.
In 2023, Florida Republicans tried to pass a bill that would have banned the state from changing gender markers on birth certificates. Another bill, introduced earlier this year, would have required state IDs and licenses to reflect a personโs sex assigned at birth. Both pieces of legislation failed to pass.
But that has not stopped state agencies from denying trans people updated documents. In a January letter, Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (FHSMV) deputy executive director Robert Kynochย rescinded the agencyโs previous policyย allowing individuals to correct the gender markers on their driverโs licenses after transitioning.
ย
โThe term โgenderโโฆ does not refer to a personโs internal sense of his or her gender role of identification, but has historically and commonly been understood as a synonym for โsex,โ which is determined by innate and immutable biological and genetic characteristics,โ Kynochโs letter read in part. Allowing people to alter their licenses based on gender identity, he wrote, โundermines the purpose of an identification record and can frustrate the stateโs ability to enforce its laws.โ
โMisrepresenting oneโs gender, understood as sex, on a driver license constitutes fraud,โ the letter continued, โand subjects an offender to criminal and civil penalties, including cancellation, suspension, or revocation of his or her driver license.โ
Asย The 19thย notes, the departmentโs rule was not prompted by any legislation. Similarly, the Florida health departmentโs Bureau of Vital Statisticsโ denials of trans peopleโs requests for amended birth certificates do not reflect any new state law, and have resulted in trans Floridians spending hundreds of dollars to obtain previously accepted documentation only to have their requests denied.
ย
As Human Rights Campaign President Kelley Robinson noted in a statement following Kynochโs January letter, policies denying trans people documents that reflect their gender identity result in their being outed โanywhere they use a driverโs license or identification document,โ potentially subjecting them to harassment, discrimination, or worse.
Southern Legal Counselโs Chriss toldย The 19thย that the organization plans to challenge the stateโs birth certificate policy in federal court.