Jimmy Kimmel Tells the Truth About What’s REALLY Happening in LA

Donald Trump’s Chief Enemy: Stairs

Remember when the right freaked out because bike riding Biden fell on the Air Force 1 stairs as he ran up them?  Where are they now?  Remember when tRump needed a General to walk him down the ramp?  Well now tRump has falling on the Air Force 1 stairs.   So where is the outrage on the right?  tRump rides a gold cart on the green so he is supper fit, but Bide riding and exercising Biden in their mind was a feeble old man days into his term.   Hugs

 

The Port Huron Statement & More in Peace & Justice History for 6/11

June 11, 1962

Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) held its founding convention in Michigan and issued The Port Huron Statement, laying out its principles and program.
“In social change or interchange, we find violence to be abhorrent because it requires generally the transformation of the target, be it a human being or a community of people, into a depersonalized object of hate. It is imperative that the means of violence be abolished and the institutions—local, national, international—that encourage non-violence as a condition of conflict be developed.”

Complete text of the Port Huron Statement  (it’s a .pdf, in case you’re on a phone)
Students for a Democratic Society: A Graphic History: Paul Buhle, Editor 
June 11, 1963
Thich Quang Duc, a Buddhist monk from the Linh-Mu Pagoda in Hue, Vietnam, burned himself to death (self-immolation) in front of the U.S. embassy in downtown Saigon (now known as Ho Chi Minh City) to protest the the South Vietnamese regime the U.S. supported, and the war the Americans were waging.

A painting of the scene on the street as Thich Quang Duc self-immolates in protest of the government and war in Vietnam
June 11, 1963

Vivian Malone (later Jones) preparing to enroll at Alabama with Deputy Attorney Gen, Nicholas Katzenbach (L) at her side.
Alabama Governor George C. Wallace stood in the doorway of the University of Alabama in order to prevent the admission of two negro students in a failed attempt to maintain segregation in educational opportunities.
He was forced to step aside later in the day when Vivian Malone and James Hood were registered as students.
June 11, 1968
Daniel Cohn-Bendit, known as Danny the Red, arrived in Britain, stirring up fears of campus unrest. The 23-year-old Paris law student had been given permission to remain in the U.K. just 24 hours, but immediately threatened to defy the authorities and out-stay his official welcome [his visit was later legally extended to 14 days]. Cohn-Bendit, a German citizen, had been expelled from France in May for being an organizer of the French student and worker demonstrations which almost brought that country to a standstill the previous month.

Daniel Cohn-Bendit and a Paris policeman in 1968.
“I don’t know how long I will stay. I think it’s a free country” -Daniel Cohn-Bendit
He currently sits as a Green Party deputy in the European Parliament.
The news at the time 
Daniel Cohn-Bendit today 
June 11, 1970
Representative Martha Griffiths (D-Michigan) filed a discharge petition signed by a majority of all members of the U.S. House of Representatives, a seldom used parliamentary move, to bring the Equal Rights amendment to the House floor for consideration.
She saw this as the only way to get the constitutional amendment out of the Judiciary Committee where it had been held by its chairman, Emmanuel Cellar (D-New York), who had refused to even hold hearings on the matter. Representative Griffiths had introduced the amendment every year since 1948.

Representative Martha Griffiths from Detroit’s west side
June 11, 1988
100,000 marched from United Nations headquarters in New York City to Central Park during the 3rd U.N. Special Session on Disarmament. Though there had been progress in recent years on disarmament, the U.N. meeting yielded nothing but stalemate.
Read more 
June 11, 2010
Scientists studying the scale of the then-ongoing BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico doubled the previous estimate of the scale of the flow of oil into the Gulf. Initially, BP and the government had said that no more than 1000 barrels (42 U.S. gallons per barrel) per day were leaking, later raised to 5000.
The fine for oil spills was $4300 per barrel.


The new estimate was between 20,000 and 40,000 barrels per day.
If the spill had been stopped that day (the well was not capped until early August), it would have exceeded the Exxon Valdez spill by a factor of eight.

https://www.peacebuttons.info/E-News/peacehistoryjune.htm#june11

Representation & Movies

Queer History 135: Let’s Go to the Cinema by Wendy🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈🌈

Queer Movie watching Read on Substack

The Blood-Stained Birth of Visibility

Picture this: It’s 1970, and America’s movie theaters reek of stale popcorn, cigarette smoke, and something else—the acrid stench of fear. Fear of bodies that didn’t conform, desires that couldn’t be spoken, identities that existed only in shadows and whispered confessions. Then, like a fucking earthquake splitting the earth’s crust, came The Boys in the Band—not tiptoeing through Hollywood’s garden of heteronormative roses, but kicking down the door with combat boots and declaring war on silence.

The Boys in the Band Blu-ray - Laurence Luckinbill

William Friedkin’s adaptation of Mart Crowley’s play didn’t just put gay men on screen; it threw them there bleeding, bitching, and beautifully broken. The audience could taste the bitter cocktail of self-loathing mixed with razor-sharp wit, could feel the electric tension crackling between characters who wielded words like switchblades. This wasn’t representation—this was revolution disguised as entertainment, a Molotov cocktail hurled at the pristine facade of American cinema.

The psychological impact on LGBTQ+ viewers was seismic. For the first time, queers sitting in darkened theaters saw themselves reflected not as tragic figures destined for suicide or sanitized saints, but as complex, contradictory, gloriously fucked-up human beings. The film’s unflinching portrayal of internalized homophobia—characters tearing each other apart with vicious precision—served as both mirror and exorcism. Viewers could finally name the demons that had been eating them alive, could see their own struggles projected thirty feet high in Technicolor fury.

Trans Bodies on Fire: The Gender-Fucking Revolution

Rocky Horror GIFs | Tenor

Before there was language, before there were support groups or pride parades, there was The Rocky Horror Picture Show—a glittering, sequined middle finger raised high against every gender binary that dared exist. Tim Curry’s Dr. Frank-N-Furter didn’t just cross-dress; he obliterated the very concept of fixed identity, serving looks that could melt steel and charm that could seduce a nun. The film became a weekly religious experience for outcasts and misfits, transforming movie theaters into sanctuaries where “abnormal” became sacrament.

The sensory assault was deliberate and intoxicating: the smell of cheap makeup mixing with nervous sweat, the sound of fishnet stockings ripping as audience members transformed themselves into their truest selves, the taste of liberation on tongues that had been silenced for too long. Rocky Horror created a space where gender became performance art, where conformity went to die, and where every Saturday night became a resurrection.

The psychological liberation was profound. Trans viewers found validation in Frank-N-Furter’s unapologetic embrace of fluidity, while questioning viewers discovered permission to explore identities they’d never dared name. The film’s interactive nature—audiences shouting back at the screen, participating in the narrative—created a communal catharsis that individual therapy could never match.

Orlando arrived two decades later like a ethereal fever dream, with Tilda Swinton embodying centuries of gender transformation through Sally Potter’s lens. Here was gender not as costume but as evolution, not as crisis but as natural progression. The film’s languid pacing forced viewers to marinate in ambiguity, to sit with discomfort until it transformed into acceptance, then into celebration.

movie gifs — The Crying Game — 1992 dir. Neil Jordan

The Crying Game hit different—like a sucker punch followed by a tender kiss. Neil Jordan’s thriller weaponized audience assumptions, then forced viewers to confront their own transphobia in real-time. The revelation about Dil became a cultural watershed moment, dividing film history into before and after. Suddenly, dinner table conversations across America were grappling with questions that had never been asked out loud.

The psychological impact on trans viewers was complex and often contradictory. Some found validation in seeing trans characters as more than punchlines or victims, while others felt exploited by the shock-value treatment of trans identity. The film sparked conversations that were long overdue, even when those conversations were messy, uncomfortable, and occasionally hostile.

Leather, Longing, and the Masculine Mystique

Cruising descended into theaters like a demon emerging from hell’s own basement, dragging audiences through New York’s leather underground with the subtlety of a sledgehammer to the skull. William Friedkin didn’t just film gay culture; he dissected it with surgical precision, exposing the raw nerves where desire meets violence, where identity becomes performance, where the line between hunter and hunted dissolves in strobe lights and poppers.

TV & FILM GIFs — Al Pacino as Detective Steve Burns Cruising (1980)...

The film’s sensory assault was overwhelming: the throb of disco basslines that you felt in your chest cavity, the smell of leather and sweat and something darker, the visual overload of bodies in motion, muscles straining against restraints both literal and metaphorical. Al Pacino’s descent into this world became every viewer’s journey into their own shadow self, the parts of desire that polite society pretended didn’t exist.

The psychological effects were explosive and divisive. Gay men in theaters found themselves simultaneously aroused and terrified, seeing their community’s most extreme margins projected for mainstream consumption. Some felt exposed, violated, their private world stripped naked for heterosexual titillation. Others felt liberated by the film’s refusal to sanitize gay desire, its acknowledgment that sexuality could be dangerous, transgressive, and transformative.

Sunday Bloody Sunday offered a different kind of revelation—mature, sophisticated, unapologetically honest about love’s messy realities. John Schlesinger’s triangular love story featuring Peter Finch as an openly gay man navigating desire without shame created a new template for queer cinema. This wasn’t tragedy or comedy; this was life, served neat without the chaser of societal judgment.

The film’s matter-of-fact treatment of gay relationships was revolutionary in its ordinariness. No coming-out trauma, no tragic endings, no apologetic explanations—just human beings loving, losing, and continuing to breathe. For LGBTQ+ viewers, this representation was oxygen for souls that had been suffocating on a diet of tragic queers and comedic stereotypes.

Lesbian Desire: From Shadows to Sunlight

Lesbian cinema in this era moved from whispered suggestions to bold declarations, from tragic endings to triumphant beginnings. The Killing of Sister George emerged from the underground like a feral cat, all claws and snarls and magnificent rage. Robert Aldrich’s brutal examination of lesbian relationships didn’t flinch from ugliness—the manipulation, the internalized homophobia, the way oppression could turn love into a weapon.

Beryl Reid’s performance was a masterclass in controlled demolition, watching a woman destroy everything she touched while desperately grasping for connection. The film’s unflinching portrayal of lesbian relationships—complex, messy, and occasionally toxic—provided representation that was real rather than idealized. For lesbian viewers, seeing their community portrayed with full humanity, including its shadows, was both painful and profoundly validating.

Desert Hearts offered redemption and possibility, Donna Deitch’s adaptation of Jane Rule’s novel serving up hope like cold water in a desert. Set in 1950s Reno, the film followed an academic’s journey from divorce to self-discovery, from social conformity to authentic desire. The Nevada landscape became a metaphor for internal transformation—vast, beautiful, and dangerous.

movie gifs — Desert Hearts (1985) Directed by Donna Deitch

The sensory details were crucial: the crack of pool balls echoing like gunshots, the smell of cigarettes and whiskey mixing with perfume and possibility, the heat radiating from skin finally allowed to want what it wanted. For lesbian viewers, Desert Hearts offered a template for their own coming-out narratives—messy, beautiful, and ultimately triumphant.

Lianna brought lesbian experience into the suburban mainstream with John Sayles’ sensitive direction. The film’s psychological realism was groundbreaking—showing the internal process of sexual awakening without sensationalizing or pathologizing it. Viewers could taste the protagonist’s confusion, feel her excitement and terror as she navigated new desires while dismantling old assumptions about herself.

The AIDS Crisis: Love in the Time of Dying

Longtime Companion arrived like a punch to the solar plexus, chronicling AIDS’ devastating impact on a circle of gay friends with unflinching honesty. Norman René’s ensemble piece transformed personal tragedy into universal human drama, forcing audiences to confront the epidemic’s toll not through statistics but through faces, voices, and stories.

The film’s emotional brutality was necessary and healing. Viewers experienced the full spectrum of grief—denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and something resembling acceptance. The beach scene, where surviving characters imagine their dead friends joining them one last time, became a collective catharsis for a community drowning in loss.

For LGBTQ+ viewers, Longtime Companion provided validation for their grief, rage, and resilience. The film acknowledged that gay relationships were worth mourning, that gay lives had value, that gay love deserved recognition. In a world that often seemed indifferent to queer suffering, the film became a memorial, a battle cry, and a love letter all at once.

Blog - The Film Experience

Parting Glances offered a different perspective on the crisis—intimate, funny, and heartbreakingly human. Bill Sherwood’s New York snapshot captured gay life with humor and tenderness, refusing to let AIDS define the entire gay experience. The film’s portrayal of friendship, love, and community in the face of mortality provided a blueprint for survival.

International Voices: Expanding the Revolution

The revolution wasn’t contained by borders. My Beautiful Laundrette mixed racial politics with queer desire against Thatcherite Britain’s backdrop, creating social dynamite that exploded conventions about class, race, and sexuality. Stephen Frears’ direction transformed a love story between Omar and Johnny into a meditation on identity, economics, and the price of conformity.

The film’s sensory details were crucial—the smell of industrial detergent mixing with forbidden desire, the sound of washing machines providing rhythm for secret encounters, the visual contrast between public respectability and private rebellion. For viewers navigating multiple marginalized identities, the film offered recognition that oppression could be intersectional and resistance could be revolutionary.

Entre Nous explored female friendship and desire in post-war France with Diane Kurys’ autobiographical honesty. The film’s examination of emotional intimacy challenging conventional marriage provided a template for understanding relationships that existed outside traditional categories. The psychological complexity of female friendship—its intensity, its potential for transformation, its threat to established order—was portrayed with rare sensitivity.

The Aesthetic Revolution: Beauty as Resistance

These films didn’t just tell different stories; they created new visual languages for desire, identity, and rebellion. The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert transformed the Australian outback into a canvas for drag performance and self-discovery, proving that authenticity could flourish in the most unlikely places.

The film’s sensory explosion was deliberate—the clash of sequins against red dirt, the sound of high heels on desert sand, the taste of dust and dreams mixing in the desert air. For drag performers and gender-nonconforming viewers, Priscilla offered validation that their art was transformative, their visibility was revolutionary, their existence was celebration.

the adventures of priscilla queen of the desert gif | WiffleGif

Death in Venice provided a different aesthetic—operatic, obsessive, and devastatingly beautiful. Luchino Visconti’s adaptation of Thomas Mann’s novella used Gustav Mahler’s music to underscore Dirk Bogarde’s descent into forbidden desire on plague-ridden Italian shores. The film’s lush visuals and overwhelming music created a sensory experience that bypassed rational thought, speaking directly to the subconscious where desire lives.

Psychological Warfare: The Internal Revolution

The psychological impact of these films on LGBTQ+ viewers cannot be overstated. For generations raised on invisibility or tragic representation, seeing complex, fully-realized queer characters was transformative therapy. These films provided:

Validation: Characters who experienced similar struggles, desires, and triumphs Language: Words and concepts for experiences that had been nameless Community: The knowledge that others shared these experiences Hope: Evidence that queer lives could include joy, love, and fulfillment Rage: Permission to be angry about oppression and discrimination Pride: Models for living authentically despite social pressure

The films also created psychological discomfort that was productive. They forced viewers to confront internalized homophobia, challenge assumptions about gender and sexuality, and grapple with the contradictions between public personas and private desires.

Cultural Warfare: Changing Hearts and Minds

These 24 films didn’t just reflect cultural change; they catalyzed it. Each screening became an act of resistance, each ticket purchase a vote for visibility, each conversation sparked by these films a crack in the foundation of heteronormative assumptions.

The films created cultural currency for LGBTQ+ experiences. References to Rocky Horror became shorthand for gender fluidity. The Boys in the Band provided vocabulary for gay male relationships. Desert Hearts offered a template for lesbian coming-out narratives. These films became cultural touchstones, reference points for understanding and discussing queer experience.

The broader cultural impact was seismic. Mainstream audiences encountered LGBTQ+ characters as fully-realized human beings rather than stereotypes or cautionary tales. The films forced conversations that hadn’t happened before, challenged assumptions that had gone unquestioned, and planted seeds of empathy in hostile soil.

The Legacy: Revolution Continues

These 24 films from 1970-1995 created the foundation for everything that followed. They proved that LGBTQ+ stories could be commercially viable, critically acclaimed, and culturally significant. They trained audiences to expect complexity rather than stereotypes, authenticity rather than exploitation.

The psychological impact on LGBTQ+ viewers created ripple effects that continue today. Viewers who found validation in these films went on to create art, build families, fight for rights, and live openly. The films provided models for resistance, templates for authenticity, and permission to exist unapologetically.

The cultural impact was equally profound. These films shifted the conversation from whether LGBTQ+ people deserved representation to how that representation should evolve. They created space for the explosion of queer cinema that followed, from Brokeback Mountain to Moonlight to The Danish Girl.

Conclusion: The Ongoing Revolution

These 24 films didn’t just entertain; they waged war against invisibility, fought battles against shame, and won victories for authenticity. They transformed movie theaters into battlegrounds, screens into mirrors, and stories into weapons of mass liberation.

The revolution they started continues in every Pride parade, every coming-out conversation, every film that dares to show LGBTQ+ characters as complex, worthy, and fully human. These films proved that visibility is power, that stories can change hearts, and that cinema can be a force for liberation.

For LGBTQ+ viewers who discovered these films in darkened theaters, on late-night television, or through word-of-mouth recommendations, the impact was profound and lasting. These films didn’t just reflect their experiences; they validated their existence, honored their struggles, and celebrated their humanity.

The blood, sweat, and tears that went into making these films—both literally and metaphorically—created a legacy that continues to inspire, challenge, and transform. They remind us that art can be revolutionary, that visibility is political, and that sometimes the most radical act is simply refusing to disappear.

These 24 films blazed a trail through the wilderness of cultural invisibility, creating a path that others could follow. They proved that LGBTQ+ stories weren’t just worth telling; they were essential to telling the complete story of human experience. The revolution they started continues, and their impact will be felt for generations to come.

Citations

  1. Rich, Ruby B. 2013 “New Queer Cinema: The Director’s Cut“
  2. Turner, K. 2023 “The Queer Film Guide: 100 great movies that tell LGBTQIA+ stories”

The Majority report is really showing what tRump / ICE / police are doing including shooting reporters. Thug behavior

 

Women’s Peace Crusade in Scotland, and More in Peace & Justice History for 6/10

June 10, 1917
The Women’s Peace Crusade in Scotland launched a three-week campaign of street meetings and demonstrations in dozens of towns to build support for peace in the midst of what was then called The Great War (now known as World War I).
More about the Womens’s Peace Crusade
June 10, 1937
The mayor of Monroe, Michigan, organized a citizens’ posse of some 1400 vigilantes, armed with baseball bats and tear gas, to combat the union organizing drive at local Newton Steel. The mob threw a dozen of the picketers’ cars into the River Raisin.

Steelworkers’ cars were rolled into Monroe, Michigan’s River Raisin by strike breakers recruited by the mayor.
The 120 striking steelworkers and their supporters were working to form unions in the “Little Steel” companies which, unlike U.S. Steel, continued to resist unionization. Newton had just been purchased by Republic Steel [see Chicago’s Memorial Day Massacre [May 30, 1937].
The whole story 
(Note from Ali: the link in the newsletter was no longer functional. Doing a search of cars going into the River Raisin is really interesting, even simply in modern times! I had to search the specific date to get this report. Seems like an “active” place, there in Monroe!)
June 10, 1963
The “Equal Pay Act of 1963” was passed and signed into law; it guaranteed women equal pay for equal work. The legislation was a result of the recommendations of President John F. Kennedy’s Commission on the Status of Women.

The law itself 
June 10, 1980
Nelson Mandela’s first writings, and those of other imprisoned anti-apartheid leaders, were smuggled out and made public while they were imprisoned on South Africa’s Robben Island.
“
As I read these fascinating essays, I was struck so forcibly by the importance of memory, of history, for both the individual and the community. . . . I pray that our people and especially our children will, by reading this collection of essays, remember the very high price that has been paid to achieve our freedom.” – Desmond Tutu, from the foreword
 
Nelson Mandela’s cell on Robben Island, where he spent 17 years
Review of Reflections in Prison 
Portions of the book 

https://www.peacebuttons.info/E-News/peacehistoryjune.htm#june10

Julia Ward Howe, Women in Black, & More, in Peace & Justice History for 6/9

June 9, 1872
Julia Ward Howe, an abolitionist and the composer of “Battle Hymn of the Republic,” tried to establish the Mothers’ Peace Day Observance on the second Sunday in June. In 1872 the first such celebration was held and the meetings continued for several years. Her idea was widely accepted, but she was never able to get the day recognized as an official holiday. Mothers’ Peace Day was the predecessor of the Mothers’ Day holiday in the United States now celebrated on the third Sunday of May.

Julia Ward Howe ca.1898
Her proclamation read in part:
“As men have often forsaken the plough and the anvil at the summons of war,
Let women now leave all that may be left of home
For a great and earnest day of counsel.
Let them meet first, as women, to bewail and commemorate the dead.
Let them solemnly take counsel with each other as to the means
Whereby the great human family can live in peace….”
June 9, 1954
Special Counsel for the U.S. Army Joseph N. Welch confronted Senator Joseph P. McCarthy (R-Wisconsin) during hearings into alleged communist infiltration of the Army Signal Corps.McCarthy had attacked a member of Welch’s law firm, Frederick G. Fischer, among many others, as a communist. This was alleged due to Fischer’s prior membership in the National Lawyers Guild.
The Guild was the nation’s first racially integrated bar association.

Army counsel Joseph N. Welch (l) confronts Senator Joseph McCarthy (r)
Welch was outraged by the attempt to destroy the reputation and career of someone of whose integrity he had no doubt: “Until this moment, senator, I think I never gauged your cruelty or recklessness . . . . Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?”
The entire hearings and this encounter were seen live on television, the first congressional committee hearings ever to be broadcast. McCarthy’s ability to make such accusations was soon greatly diminished.

Watch the confrontation 
National Lawyers Guild, since 1937 and today 
June 9, 1984
150,000 marched in London, England, for nuclear disarmament, protesting the presence of U.S. cruise missiles on British soil.
June 9, 1993
Police banned a vigil by Women in Black (Zene u Crnom) in Belgrade, Serbia.
 
Who are the Women in Black?
 
Women in Black demonstrations combine art & politics

https://www.peacebuttons.info/E-News/peacehistoryjune.htm#june9

The President’s Power to Call Out the National Guard Is Not a Blank Check

https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/presidents-power-call-out-national-guard-not-blank-check

Domestic deployment under Section 502(f) has its limits, and for good reason.

November 18, 2024

The National Guard plays a crucial role in the United States, both in its capacity as a reserve component of the armed forces and as a versatile asset that state governors can call on in times of civil unrest, natural disaster, or even the coronavirus pandemic. Section 502(f) of Title 32 of the U.S. Code is a long-standing authority that facilitates a range of important domestic National Guard missions. In the summer of 2020, however, the Trump administration made unprecedented use of this law to bring unfederalized, out-of-state Guard troops into Washington, D.C., to respond to protests following the murder of George Floyd. In doing so, the administration put forward an unbounded interpretation of § 502(f) that risks subverting the broader statutory scheme Congress has created to govern domestic deployment of the military. In addition, if a future president were to rely on this interpretation of the law to ask governors to send unfederalized Guard personnel into a nonconsenting state—as opposed to a non-state jurisdiction like D.C.—that deployment would violate the Constitution.

Section 502 is the primary statute that authorizes the National Guard to operate in “Title 32 status,” one of the three different duty statuses in which members of the Guard may serve at any given moment. In “State Active Duty status,” Guard personnel carry out a state-defined mission, under state command and control, and with state funding and benefits. By contrast, in “Title 10 status,” the Guard has been “called into federal service,” or “federalized,” by the president. When federalized, Guard forces carry out federal missions under federal command and control, and with federal funding and benefits. Title 32 status occupies a middle ground between State Active Duty and Title 10 status, featuring both federal and state involvement. In this hybrid status, the Guard remains under state command and control but can perform federal missions, is paid with federal funds, and receives federal benefits. Crucially, because Guard personnel in Title 32 status are under state control, they have not been federalized and are not subject to the Posse Comitatus Act. That means they are not barred from participating in civilian law enforcement activities.

Although Title 32 status was originally conceived to allow the federal government to foot the bill for the extensive training requirements that Congress requires each state and territory’s National Guard to fulfill, the purposes for which it may be used have expanded over time. Today, § 502(f) allows the Guard to carry out a wide range of nontraining, operational missions in Title 32 status. But the authority that the law provides has its limits.

The 2020 National Guard Deployment in Washington, D.C.

In early June 2020, thousands of National Guard troops from 11 states were deployed to Washington, D.C., as part of the Trump administration’s response to largely peaceful protests following the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, Minnesota. At the time, there was a great deal of confusion and controversy over the legal authority under which these soldiers had been brought to D.C.

In a letter to D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser, who had publicly objected to the deployment, then-U.S. Attorney General William Barr offered the following explanation: “At the direction of the President, the Secretary of Defense … requested assistance from out-of-state National Guard personnel, pursuant to 32 U.S.C. § 502(f), which authorizes States to send forces to assist the ‘[s]upport of operations or missions undertaken by the member’s unit at the request of the President or Secretary of Defense.’” According to Barr, these troops had been given broad responsibilities, including authority to participate in certain law enforcement activities:

“Consistent with the President’s direction, the Secretary of Defense assigned to out-of-state National Guard personnel the mission of protecting federal functions, persons, and property within the District of Columbia. That mission includes the protection of federal properties from destruction or defacement (including through crowd control, temporary detention, cursory search, measures to ensure the safety of persons on the property, and establishment of security perimeters, consistent with the peaceful exercise of First Amendment rights); protection of federal officials, employees, and law enforcement personnel from harm or threat of bodily injury; and protection of federal functions, such as federal employees’ access to their workplaces, the free and safe movement of federal personnel throughout the city, and the continued operation of the U.S. mails.”

The deployment and Barr’s subsequent justification raise two crucial questions about the scope of § 502(f). The first is whether § 502(f) authorizes the use of National Guard personnel to perform any mission the president could conceivably request. The Guard’s June 2020 operation in D.C. was unprecedented; § 502(f) had never before been used for a federally requested deployment in response to civil unrest. Historically, when presidents have desired to deploy the military for this purpose, they have invoked the Insurrection Act and deployed either active-duty federal troops or federalized National Guard. The District of Columbia’s unusual status within the United States’s federal system presents a second question: whether the deployment of unfederalized, out-of-state Guard troops into a nonconsenting jurisdiction would be lawful if that jurisdiction were a state. The answer to both of these questions is no.

Section 502(f): a Broad Authority, but Not an Unlimited One

Section 502 of Title 32 of the United States Code addresses “required drills and field exercises”—that is, the particulars of how often and in what manner National Guard units are required to train each year. Its first provision, § 502(a), establishes the normal training requirements for the Guard, commonly summarized as “one weekend a month and two weeks a year.” Section 502(f) sits at the end of the statute and has two prongs. The first, § 502(f)(1), allows Guard personnel to be ordered to perform “training or other duty” above and beyond the standard training regimen described by subsection (a). The second, § 502(f)(2)(A), provides that this “training or other duty” may include “[s]upport of operations or missions undertaken by the member’s unit at the request of the President or Secretary of Defense.”

The word “request” in § 502(f)(2)(A) is significant. The president or the secretary of defense may ask a governor to deploy National Guard troops, but the governor is under no obligation to acquiesce. This reading is supported by 32 U.S.C. § 328, which makes clear that a governor is the party empowered to order National Guard troops to duty under either prong of § 502(f). A governor’s right to refuse was evident in the summer of 2020—the Trump administration asked a total of 15 governors to deploy their Guard personnel into Washington, but four declined to do so. This point is discussed further below.

As for the question of what kinds of missions § 502(f) is intended to authorize, the statute itself offers little guidance. The words “other duty” in § 502(f)(1) plainly permit the National Guard to carry out non-training-related missions. The critical question is how broadly “other duty” should be interpreted. Barr and the Trump administration appear to have assumed that “other duty” means any duty—that under § 502(f)(2)(A), National Guard troops provided by a willing governor may be used to perform any mission the president could request. As Barr explained, the out-of-state Guard forces in D.C. had been assigned a wide range of duties, including law enforcement activities such as “crowd control, temporary detention, [and] cursory search.”

Such a broad reading, however, is inconsistent with the statute’s legislative history, its place in the statutory scheme, and judicially established rules of statutory interpretation. In effect, it allows an end run around the procedures and guard rails that Congress has created to govern domestic deployment of the military. Section 502 was originally enacted as part of the codification of Title 32 in 1956, but subsection (f) and the “other duty” language within it were not added until 1964. On paper, the addition of subsection (f) opened the door for National Guard personnel to perform operational missions under Title 32. However, the legislative history of its adoption suggests that it was intended principally to provide funding and authorization for training-related duties beyond the specific exercises cited in the law. The provision was not used for operational missions until 1989, when Congress added specific statutory authority for one kind of § 502(f) “other duty” in particular: drug interdiction missions under 32 U.S.C. § 112.

Another type of operational mission was added in 2004, when, amid the broadening war on terror, Congress added an entirely new chapter to Title 32—Chapter 9—that authorized National Guard personnel operating under state control to be federally funded under § 502(f) while engaging in certain “homeland defense activities.” But state governors struggled to obtain Department of Defense approval for these missions because of the requirement that missions under Chapter 9 respond to a “threat … against the United States” as a whole. In 2005, Hurricane Katrina devastated the Gulf Coast and exposed disastrous shortcomings in the federal government’s ability to respond to natural disasters. The next year, Congress responded to both of these problems by further expanding the potential nontraining uses of § 502(f), this time by amending the provision itself rather than adding any new sections to Title 32.

The newly added subsection (f)(2)(A), which authorizes National Guard support of federal operations or missions “at the request of the President or Secretary of Defense,” was undoubtedly meant to simplify and ease the process by which National Guard forces could perform domestic operational missions under Title 32. However, although the legislative history for the 2006 amendment does not clearly identify the exact bounds of what Congress intended to authorize, it does suggest that Congress was concerned primarily with facilitating homeland defense activities already authorized elsewhere in Title 32 as well as the National Guard’s traditional role in responding to natural disasters like Katrina.

Indeed, the Report of the House Armed Services Committee on the 2006 amendment hardly mentions the new authority it would create for governors to use their Guard forces to support missions requested by the president or secretary of defense, and instead focuses on discussing how other parts of the same amendment would allow “reserve component personnel performing active guard and reserve duty, as well as military technicians (dual status), to … train active duty members of the armed forces” and the limitations on this new authority. In short, it is highly unlikely that Congress intended to revolutionize the landscape of domestic deployment in the United States by giving the president an easy alternative to the Insurrection Act.

A narrower interpretation of Section 502(f) is also consistent with established principles of statutory interpretation. The Supreme Court explained in Whitman v. American Trucking that “Congress … does not alter the fundamental details of a regulatory scheme in vague terms or ancillary provisions—it does not, one might say, hide elephants in mouseholes.” Similarly, when the Court held in FDA v. Brown & Williamson that the Food and Drug Administration’s authority does not include power to regulate tobacco products as drugs, it said that “Congress could not have intended to delegate a decision of such economic and political significance to an agency in so cryptic a fashion.” In short, the Court generally assumes that Congress will speak to major issues directly.

There is no doubt that Congress meant for the 2006 amendments to § 502(f) to widen the scope of the activities it authorizes. Even so, it seems extraordinarily unlikely that Congress would have buried within a section of the U.S. Code that is primarily concerned with National Guard training requirements an open-ended authorization for American military forces to participate in domestic law enforcement activities at the behest of the president, notwithstanding the Posse Comitatus Act and without reliance on the Insurrection Act. Indeed, that would be the very definition of “hiding an elephant in a mousehole.”

State Sovereignty and Deployment of Unfederalized National Guard Personnel Into a Nonconsenting State

If the District of Columbia were a state, then the deployment of out-of-state National Guard troops into the District over its chief executive’s objections in June 2020 would have violated the Constitution. U.S. states are sovereign entities, although their sovereignty is limited and made subordinate to the federal government under the Constitution. Like foreign sovereigns, their sovereignty is territorially defined. As the Supreme Court explained on multiple occasions in the early republic, “the jurisdiction of a state is coextensive with its territory, coextensive with its legislative power.”

It is a function of the states’ co-equal and territorially limited sovereignty that one state’s courts cannot reach into another and adjudicate the affairs of people living there, unless those individuals have sufficient “minimum contacts” with the forum state. For the same reason, it cannot be the case that a state, solely under its own authority, may deploy its National Guard forces into another state without that state’s permission. Simply put, U.S. states may not invade one another.

The deployment of one state’s National Guard into another state in State Active Duty status without the receiving state’s consent would therefore be unlawful. Were this not the rule—if one state could freely reach into another and exercise governmental power there—then any kind of conflict between the states would have the potential to lead to a physical confrontation between their law enforcement agencies and National Guard forces, with potentially disastrous consequences.

The crucial remaining question is whether placing Guard forces in Title 32 status obviates this sovereignty barrier, making deployment into a nonconsenting state permissible. It does not.

The principal difference between State Active Duty status and Title 32 status is that the latter allows National Guard forces to operate at federal expense and to perform certain federal missions, all while remaining under state command and control. State command and control has legal as well as practical consequences. To start, it means that Guard personnel in Title 32 status have not been federalized. The federal courts have made clear that whether Guard personnel have been federalized depends solely on whether they are under state or federal command and control.

Further consequences of state control are apparent within Title 32 itself. As noted above, § 502(f)(2)(A) makes clear that governors are free to reject a president’s request for National Guard assistance. Likewise, 32 U.S.C. § 328 provides that for any § 502(f) deployment, the governor—not the president—issues the orders to mobilize and deploy. Barr’s letter to Bowser likewise acknowledges that § 502(f) “authorizes States to send forces” to support missions requested by the president.

All of these factors point to the same conclusion: Although a deployment under § 502(f)(2)(A) is federally requested, defined, and funded, state authority is being exercised as a legal matter.

This conclusion is consistent with what the Supreme Court has said about what it means for members of the National Guard to be “federalized.” In Perpich v. Department of Defense, the Court explained that when Guard troops are federalized, they temporarily become part of the active-duty federal military. When not federalized, however, they remain state officers. The Perpich Court made clear that, when on active duty, a member of the Guard must be either a part of the federal military or a state officer—they can never be both at the same time. Since Guard personnel in Title 32 status have not been federalized, they are not part of the federal military and must instead be state officers operating under state authority.

For the purposes of the co-equal and territorially limited sovereignty of the states, then, there is no difference between State Active Duty status and Title 32 status. In both cases, National Guard personnel are state officers exercising state authority. That means they cannot operate in another state without its consent, no matter who requested their presence or who is paying them.

Conclusion

Congress should amend § 502(f) to narrow and clarify its scope. In the meantime, though, the law is not a blank check allowing the president to use military forces anywhere in the country and for any purpose so long as they can find one willing governor. Congress no doubt intended the creation of § 502(f)(2)(A) to make domestic deployment of the National Guard easier rather than harder, but it is highly unlikely that lawmakers meant to blow a gaping hole in the complex web of laws that govern the military’s domestic activities. Rather, § 502(f)(2)(A) was likely intended to facilitate missions that were already authorized by other statutes as well as traditional Guard functions like disaster relief.

Moreover, regardless of Congress’s intent, deployments of the National Guard in Title 32 status must in all cases respect the co-equal and territorially limited sovereignty of the states. As a constitutional matter, the deployment of unfederalized Guard personnel into a nonconsenting state is never permissible. If the president wishes to unilaterally deploy military forces into a nonconsenting state, then they must do so through the statutory mechanism that Congress has provided for this purpose since 1792: the Insurrection Act.

In all cases and regardless of the statutory device used, domestic deployment of the military should be treated as an option of last resort. There is a tradition in American law and political thought, with roots that can be traced to medieval England, that opposes any kind of military interference in civilian affairs outside of emergencies. This tradition recognizes the fundamental danger of turning an army inward to face its own country’s citizens. As the Eighth Circuit explained in Bissonette v. Haig:

“The use of military forces to seize civilians can expose civilian government to the threat of military rule and the suspension of constitutional liberties. On a lesser scale, military enforcement of the civil law leaves the protection of vital Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights in the hands of persons who are not trained to uphold these rights. It may also chill the exercise of fundamental rights, such as the rights to speak freely and to vote, and create the atmosphere of fear and hostility which exists in territories occupied by enemy forces.”

Domestic deployment presents risks for the military itself, too. While sometimes necessary, all domestic military operations distract and draw resources away from the military’s core national security responsibilities. Domestic law enforcement operations, in particular, are also broadly unpopular among military personnel, who did not enlist in the armed services to police their fellow citizens—a fact that is all the more significant as the military continues to struggle through a recruitment and retention crisis.

The National Guard is not immune to these risks. While the Guard certainly continues to fulfill its traditional role of providing local support in times of crisis, over the past three decades it has also been integrated into the broader United States armed forces. Today’s National Guard is a professional army and an essential piece of the Department of Defense’s “Total Force.” To be sure, Guard personnel are more likely to be trained in law enforcement than their active-duty counterparts, but many Guard units are frontline combat units trained and equipped to fight overseas, with comparatively little experience or training in responding to civil unrest.

Accordingly, when considering whether to use any part of the military domestically, leaders should not merely ask whether a deployment would be constitutional and authorized by statute. They should also ask whether it would be an appropriate use of limited military resources and whether it is consistent with the foundational American belief that domestic civilian affairs should be managed by domestic civilian authorities whenever possible.

Peace & Justice History for 6/8

June 8, 1956
Air Force Tech Sergeant Richard B. Fitzgibbon, of North Weymouth, Massachusetts is listed by the U.S. Department of Defense as being the first U.S. military casualty of the Vietnam War.
His name is listed on The Wall (the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington, DC) with that of his son, Marine Corps Lance Colonel Richard B. Fitzgibbon III, who died September 7, 1965.

June 8, 1966

270 walked out of graduation ceremonies at New York University (NYU) to protest the presentation of an honorary degree to Robert McNamara, then the Secretary of Defense and responsible for U.S. forces waging war in Vietnam.
June 8, 1969
Two-thirds of the graduating class of Brown University (Providence, Rhode Island) turned their backs on Secretary of State Henry Kissinger as he gave the commencement address, silently expressing their opposition to U.S. foreign policy and the war in Vietnam.
June 8, 2002
1500 Israeli and other peace activists demonstrated peacefully in front of the Prime Minister’s Jerusalem residence in opposition to 35 years of Israeli occupation of Palestinian territory.
“The occupation is hurting us all,” said advertising placed by the organizers, “draining billions of shekels from us, forcing cutbacks in social and educational programs.”


Coalition of Women for a Just Peace leading a demonstration against the continued Israeli occupation of Palestine.
They also claimed the occupation inculcates the belief that “violence is the only way to solve problems” and “allows militarism to run rampant in our lives.” Buses with banners saying “End the Occupation” and “The Occupation is Hurting Us All” started out from four locations throughout Israel, arriving in Jerusalem together.
A choir of Israeli and Palestinian children had been scheduled to close the action but their conductor feared government retribution; the demonstration ended in silence instead of with children’s voices.

https://www.peacebuttons.info/E-News/peacehistoryjune.htm#june8

Intersectionality

“Her insistence that the rights of women, people in poverty, people of color, and immigrants all be upheld within the political Left, as well as without it, left a legacy of intersectionality that was ahead of its time.”