I can’t understand living just to hate and harm others who are not doing anything that harms you. To carry that bitterness and to work so hard to deny to others what you demand for yourself seems like poisoning one’s self. With so much to enjoy in diversity and inclusion why work so hard to create a homogeny of everyone being the same. Hugs
As the M4L annual summit kicks off this weekend, here’s how one of the group’s original chapters is sowing chaos and pushing anti-LGBTQ policies in Indian River County.
Mink Tyner says some people call her a “helicopter parent” because of how protective she is over her kids. Despite this, she wasn’t concerned about bringing her daughter, then 14, to the Indian River County, Florida, school board meeting in August 2023, where they were discussing changes to the state’s curriculum relating to race and slavery.
That’s why she was shocked when she saw community members at the podium reading excerpts of sexual content from books.
“I hate lights out now because my D has a mind of its own,” one woman read. Then a man came up and read, “When Doris had just turned 11, her current stepfather started having sex with her.” And a third person read, “He took a long long time peeling off my jeans and T-shirt, pink bra and panties, and a longer time stroking and kissing me.”
The meeting had turned into more of a stunt led by protestors affiliated with the local chapter of Moms for Liberty (M4L), a Southern Poverty Law Center-designated far-right extremist group.
“I’m not gonna have my kid in here listening to these adults doing this shit,” Tyner remembers thinking.
She took her daughter out of the room and pleaded with security to intervene, but they refused. So she spoke up to disrupt the meeting herself, only for security from the Sheriff’s office—who told Uncloseted Media their deputies responded “appropriately and in accordance with established procedures”—to escort her out.
As she was leaving, conservative pastor John Amanchukwu, who had attended the meeting with M4L, confronted her while recording a video that he would later post to X calling her “demonic” and lashing out about her being pro-LGBTQ: “You’re okay with DEI. … You’re okay with Pride Month. You’re okay with the rainbow flag. You’re okay with all that junk,” he yelled. Tyner responded by calling him a “fucking weirdo” and walked out.
That video opened a floodgate of harassment that tormented Tyner and her family for years: She received insults, accusations of pedophilia, and persistent threats of violence from a Facebook account displaying the name CURTIS COUSINS who called her a “fent-using fat fucking dyke” and told her she deserved to have “a potato peeler peel her clit right off to the bone.”
“I never know if this week or 10 years from now somebody’s gonna show up [to my business] based on some kind of misinformation that Moms for Liberty started about me [or] want to harm me and my family,” Tyner, who owns a tattoo shop, told Uncloseted Media.
Indian River County is home to one of the first of M4L’s 320 chapters nationwide. The group’s annual summit is this weekend and will feature a variety of politicians with anti-LGBTQ track records, including Oklahoma’s former state superintendent Ryan Walters, who made headlines for making anti-trans comments after the death of 16-year-old trans teen Nex Benedict. Last year, conservative heavyweights spoke at the event, including President Trump, Tulsi Gabbard and Sebastian Gorka.
Over the last four years, M4L have built a reputation for chaos and controversy. Members have made the news for quoting Hitler, stripping at a school board meeting and offering bounties to report teachers who teach about “critical race theory.”
At one point in Indian River County, close allies of M4L made up a majority of the school board where they pressured the district to ban scores of books, many of which contain LGBTQ themes, and reverse a racial equity policy—all while harassing, doxing and defaming their adversaries.
Maurice Cunningham, a retired professor of political science from the University of Massachusetts, says what’s playing out in Indian River County is a microcosm for so many other chapters across the country.
“[The media are] falling like suckers for this story that they’re a grassroots moms organization. They are not, they are connected to … the far right establishment,” he says. “And that’s become … more and more apparent. So this whole grassroots thing is hogwash.”
Beginnings
Moms for Liberty was founded in Florida in 2021 by three current and former school board members: Tiffany Justice, Tina Descovich and Bridget Ziegler, the latter of whom has since left the group after being involved in a sex scandal wherein her husband allegedly prowled local bars to solicit women for threesomes.
Shortly after M4L launched, Justice tapped Jennifer Pippin, who had made a name for herself for leading activism against COVID-19 restrictions, to lead the chapter for her home county, Indian River.
While the anti-mask circles that would later be folded into M4L always had a conservative lean, multiple county residents told Uncloseted Media that the group’s discriminatory views were not initially apparent.
Tyner, a lesbian who identifies as politically independent, actually felt welcomed by the group when she worked with them on their anti-mask mandate advocacy. However, that changed as M4L’s focus turned towards opposing LGBTQ inclusion measures in schools.
“Once they organized and got the appearance of a grassroots start … and many people in the community that were siding with them, it’s like they took the steering wheel and they just steered another direction,” she says.
When Tyner began speaking up against this rhetoric, she says she was blocked from the group’s Facebook pages. But as she continued to oppose them publicly, Justice offered to meet with her to address her concerns.
Over breakfast at a local cafe, Tyner says Justice gave her a “scripted” response in the hopes of winning back her support. She even invited Tyner to an M4L chapter meeting. However, Tyner declined as the meeting was allegedly to be hosted by a community member who had made an online post suggesting necrophilia and pedophilia are part of the LGBTQ umbrella.
“I was like, ‘Alright, this is not a good or a safe movement,” says Tyner.
Justice did not respond to a request for comment. In an email, Pippin told Uncloseted Media that M4L have “members and members children that are LGB in [their] chapter and across the country.”
Another local parent, who requested anonymity due to concerns about his job security, says while he’d initially been on board with M4L’s parental rights advocacy, he ran into conflict with the group when they started opposing the school district’s racial equity policies and tried to ban books with antiracist themes, including Ibram X. Kendi’s “Antiracist Baby”and “Stamped: Racism, Antiracism, and You.” Like Tyner, he says he was approached by Justice and Pippin to win him over again but was ultimately unconvinced.
After he split from M4L, he began publicly criticizing the group’s book bans. In retaliation, some M4L members accused him of supporting pedophiles.
When he reached out to Pippin to ask for the people making such accusations against him to be held accountable, he says she waved him off—all while blocking him on social media and accusing him of “bullying.” He also says that she doxed him after another dispute—a major factor in his decision to remain anonymous.
“Her response to me basically was ‘free speech,’ ‘we don’t control what our members say.’ And I’m like, ‘But Jennifer, you know me, and you know I’m not a pedophile, and this is unacceptable,’” he told Uncloseted Media.
Building Political Power
The Indian River County School District’s J.A. Thompson Administrative Center. Photo by Kiran891.
Efforts to ban LGBTQ and racial justice-related books in schools are part of M4L’s national ammo that helped them quickly explode in popularity.
Cunningham says M4L were boosted by high-profile connections on the right. Ziegler and Descovich both served as presidents of the Florida Coalition of School Board Members, a group billed as a conservative alternative to the Florida School Board Association. Ziegler’s husband, Christian, was vice chairman of Florida’s Republican Party at the time and worked as a media surrogate for the Trump campaign in 2016.
Since their launch, M4L have had their conferences and events sponsored by the Heritage Foundation and the Leadership Institute; were directly advised by Leadership Institute founder Morton Blackwell; and were a part of Project 2025’s advisory board. And this summer, Justice was hired as executive vice president of Heritage Action.
In 2022, the Indian River County chapter leveraged this influence to carve out power in local government: They got two close allies, Jacqueline Rosario and Dr. Gene Posca, elected to the school board, and they developed closerelationships with the Ron DeSantis-backed county sheriff Eric Flowers. Pippin was even appointed by Florida’s Department of Education to a statewide workgroup to develop compliance training for Florida’s classroom censorship policies, including the infamous “Don’t Say Gay” law.
As M4L became notorious for pushing exclusionary measures in schools, some officials—including school board member Peggy Jones—criticized the group. In retaliation, Jones reportedly received so many death threats that the district had to increase security detail at all school events where she was present.
In the midst of increasing chaos surrounding M4L, the group mounted a campaign of hundreds of requests to ban books containing “sexual content.”
While some librarians continued to hold the majority of books where bans were unsuccessful, M4L convinced Flowers to investigate one school library, alleging that keeping the books on the shelf could constitute a sex crime. While the investigation found that no crime had been committed, Flowers concluded that “we do not feel that this content is appropriate for young children,” putting even further pressure on local librarians.
Pippin at the school board meeting in August 2023. Photo via YouTube.
This kind of direct action proved very effective. Even the reading protest where Tyner was escorted out won them 34 additional book bans from a unanimous board vote.
“You can’t deny that the kind of tactics that they have have been useful,” Cunningham says. “Some of the places they’ve taken over, [including] Sarasota County, where Bridget Ziegler was on the board, became much more conservative over the past few years.”
Silencing Opposition
In addition to school board meetings, the group has a track record of trolling progressive events. Tyner and the anonymous parent remember an incident where a group of M4L members showed up to a local National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) meeting that had been organized to discuss plans for opposition against new state regulations that required classes to portray slavery in a more positive light.Tyner says white M4L members attempted to shout down NAACP speakers, with one member allegedly using the n-word. Thomas Kenny, a M4L member who was at the event, said this “did not happen” and that one of their members using the n-word is “an absolute lie.”
Cunningham says these disruptions are part of M4L’s playbook. He pointed to the example of Jennifer Jenkins, the liberal school board member who unseated Tina Descovich in neighboring Brevard County, who says protestors spurred by M4L have turned up outside her home calling her a pedophile and burning “FU” in her lawn.
“They [use the] same kind of tactics … over and over again,” says Cunningham.
Pippin
Chapter leader Jennifer Pippin has mastered those tactics, becoming widely known as one of the most influential book banners in the country. She’s also made headlines for filing a complaint against the Kilted Mermaid, a Vero Beach wine bar, alleging that they had hosted an all-ages drag event with sexual content, which the bar owner denies. M4L rallied against the bar online, spamming the posts of one of the bar’s drag performers, telling the queen to “stay away from children.” This stunt caught the attention of Florida’s Attorney General James Uthmeier, who launched an investigation and issued subpoenas for video recordings of the bar on the day of the event as well as identifying documents for employees and performers.
Pippin has also claimed to be a nurse, despite no public records showing that she has a license, and appeared on the antisemitic and homophobic far-right news website TruNews, where she claimed, without evidence, that anti-M4L activists have been killing pets and livestock owned by the group’s members.
Fear
Tyner and the other anonymous parent both say that they’ve had to take a step back from the school board and local activism because of the toxic environment M4L have created.
“It’s been turned into such a circus,” Tyner says.
In the meantime, things have gotten worse for the LGBTQ community in Indian River County, and in Florida overall, between the “Don’t Say Gay” law and anti-LGBTQ legislation that requires teachers to deadname trans students unless they have signed parental permission slips. The anonymous parent says he’s watched many of the LGBTQ people in his life, including one of his own children, who is a teacher, leave the state due to the hostile environment.
“It’s not safe for a lot of people,” he says.
Greener Pastures?
Despite all of this, a sea change may be on the horizon. A 2024 Brookings report found that the success rates of M4L-endorsed candidates were on the decline, and in Indian River County’s elections last year, both of M4L’s school board candidates lost. With the continued controversies of the Trump administration and the growing popularity of groups that oppose M4L’s ideology, Cunningham feels the tide may be turning for M4L’s influence in Indian River County and across America.
“In school board races, the Moms for Liberty label is toxic, so try to not get attached to that,” he says. “They’ve had quite an impact … I don’t wanna downplay that. But in terms of popular appeal and growth, I think it’s much more limited than it is portrayed.”
Editor’s Note: In an email, Jennifer Pippin responded to the allegations made about her in this story. You can read them here.
If objective, nonpartisan, rigorous, LGBTQ-focused journalism is important to you, please consider making a tax-deductible donation through our fiscal sponsor, Resource Impact, by clicking this button:
I am an older gay guy in a long-term wonderful relationship. My spouse and I are in our 36th year together. I love politics and news. I enjoy civil discussions and have no taboo subjects. My pronouns are he / him / his and my email is Scottiestoybox@gmail.com
View all posts by Scotties Playtime
5 thoughts on “How Moms for Liberty Took Over One Florida County”
I don’t get how they decide they get to call themselves Christian when they brazenly behave in the opposite fashion. I get the situation, I still just have a hard time believing that they believe in the Christian God and Jesus, because they would be so morally opposed to what they themselves do if they really believed. Not to mention frightened of their day of judgment!
Scottie, it is so good to see you posting and sounding more like yourself again! It’s a big relief to me, not only from worrying about you, but for being able to take some time off posting. If you are feeling as good as you sound, here’s to it being forever!
Hi Ali. Thank you. I do owe you and everyone a video explaining what happened. How I got caught up and back to where I need to be is in large part to Ron’s sister Diane. She is a big sister to Ron so has that big sister energy. She also has taken over a lot of what I was doing, giving me time to rest and be at the computer. She got Ron to throw out a room full of scrap pieces of wood he refused to part with because he might need them someday. She is going through the house doing the organization and other stuff I was trying to do. I still have a lot of healing to do, but I am better with the rest I need and was not getting.
As to these people I also don’t understand them either. Ali I think I have as good a reason to hate if I gave into it as anyone. Yet I rejected it in my 20s because Ron showed me a better way to live and the anger and hate I felt was not hurting those who hurt me, it was destroying me. Having that in my system was a poison that was killing me, changing me into something I never wanted to be. So I worked hard to remove it and instead embrace the joys of diversity among people. If what others do is not harming me or others then it simply is not any of my business or concern.
How do they live with such anger, hate, bigotry, and desire to harm others? How do they enjoy life when they are trying to take from others what they demand for themselves? As for do they really believe? I think they created their god in their own image instead of god creating them in its image. I am lucky to know real Christians who try to follow the Christ of the bible and his words of kindness. But far too many use the bible as a club to hit others with rather than a guide for personal growth. I hope you and your family have a grand holiday. Hugs
Hi Annie. Thank you. I am trying very hard to return. I have a huge help from Ron’s sister who is here taking a lot of the strain off me, allowing me both the rest I need and the time to be at the computer.
I am glad they are losing their hold on the public and to be clear I simply do not understand their hate to those who are different from them yet are not harming them in any way. It confuses me because I understand what hate can do to a person if they give into it, it destroys them not the person they hate. Why are these things so important to them? Is it power? Is it fame? Why harm so many rather than just taking the joy in having so much diversity. I live in Florida, and in the cities you can get any food you want. Even here in my smaller town I can have a diverse menu if we wish. Why is that diversity bad.
Thank you Annie for sticking with the blog. I am so lucky that Ali and Randy agreed to be authors posting while I couldn’t. Have a grand holiday. Hugs
Scottie's Playtime 
I don’t get how they decide they get to call themselves Christian when they brazenly behave in the opposite fashion. I get the situation, I still just have a hard time believing that they believe in the Christian God and Jesus, because they would be so morally opposed to what they themselves do if they really believed. Not to mention frightened of their day of judgment!
Scottie, it is so good to see you posting and sounding more like yourself again! It’s a big relief to me, not only from worrying about you, but for being able to take some time off posting. If you are feeling as good as you sound, here’s to it being forever!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Ali. Thank you. I do owe you and everyone a video explaining what happened. How I got caught up and back to where I need to be is in large part to Ron’s sister Diane. She is a big sister to Ron so has that big sister energy. She also has taken over a lot of what I was doing, giving me time to rest and be at the computer. She got Ron to throw out a room full of scrap pieces of wood he refused to part with because he might need them someday. She is going through the house doing the organization and other stuff I was trying to do. I still have a lot of healing to do, but I am better with the rest I need and was not getting.
As to these people I also don’t understand them either. Ali I think I have as good a reason to hate if I gave into it as anyone. Yet I rejected it in my 20s because Ron showed me a better way to live and the anger and hate I felt was not hurting those who hurt me, it was destroying me. Having that in my system was a poison that was killing me, changing me into something I never wanted to be. So I worked hard to remove it and instead embrace the joys of diversity among people. If what others do is not harming me or others then it simply is not any of my business or concern.
How do they live with such anger, hate, bigotry, and desire to harm others? How do they enjoy life when they are trying to take from others what they demand for themselves? As for do they really believe? I think they created their god in their own image instead of god creating them in its image. I am lucky to know real Christians who try to follow the Christ of the bible and his words of kindness. But far too many use the bible as a club to hit others with rather than a guide for personal growth. I hope you and your family have a grand holiday. Hugs
LikeLiked by 3 people
Hi, Scottie. Good to see you and hear you’re back.
I’m quite sure that all the Moms for Liberty candidates who ran for school bds, etc, were defeated in November—nationwide!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hi Annie. Thank you. I am trying very hard to return. I have a huge help from Ron’s sister who is here taking a lot of the strain off me, allowing me both the rest I need and the time to be at the computer.
I am glad they are losing their hold on the public and to be clear I simply do not understand their hate to those who are different from them yet are not harming them in any way. It confuses me because I understand what hate can do to a person if they give into it, it destroys them not the person they hate. Why are these things so important to them? Is it power? Is it fame? Why harm so many rather than just taking the joy in having so much diversity. I live in Florida, and in the cities you can get any food you want. Even here in my smaller town I can have a diverse menu if we wish. Why is that diversity bad.
Thank you Annie for sticking with the blog. I am so lucky that Ali and Randy agreed to be authors posting while I couldn’t. Have a grand holiday. Hugs
LikeLiked by 2 people
You too, Scottie. Onward and upward!
LikeLiked by 1 person