On Saturday night at the ICCโs Darling Harbour theatre, that idea became a reality for a 21-year-old university student who was thrust into the spotlight at a live performance of the movieโs score โ and saved a concert from derailment.
Sterling Nasa was in the audience at La La Land in Concert, a touring production where the movie โ which features Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone โ is projected on to a screen while a live orchestra plays the musical score in synchronisation with the film.
The performance proceeded normally until the interval, which stretched out to 40 minutes. Then the filmโs Oscar-winning composer and conductor, Justin Hurwitz, walked out alone to address the audience.
The orchestraโs keyboardist had suddenly fallen ill. Was there by any chance a pianist in the house? And one with exceptional sight-reading skills?
Speaking to Guardian Australia on Monday, Hurwitz revealed that behind the scenes, quiet panic had set in during that extended interval.
โOur first thought was, is there a string player who also knows keyboard? The answer was no.โ
As the orchestraโs musicians frantically phoned local contacts, offers started rolling in of backup players who were 15 to 20 minutes away. But Hurwitz knew time had run out.
โI figured nobodyโs as close as they say they are โฆ so I just thought, well, we have 2,500 people in here โฆ
โYes, it was a gamble.
โThatโs why I asked a few times. I wanted to make sure that somebody wasnโt just overly confident. I asked a couple of follow-up questions like, โAre you sure? Can you really sight-read? Can you play key signatures youโve never played before?โโ
Nasa, who plays piano and organ and is the bagpipes tutor at his old school, Scots College, hesitated when the call went out.
โI was a little bit tentative,โ the University of Sydney politics and international studies student told ABC Radio on Monday morning. โI do owe a lot of the experience to my friend, Scarlett, who sort of โฆ put my hand up for me. But I did end up finding the confidence and it was a very good decision to go down and volunteer myself.โ
A longtime admirer of Hurwitzโs work, Nasa suddenly found himself sitting at an electric keyboard, staring at a complex score he had never rehearsed.
The ultimate test came during the performance of the John Legend piece Start a Fire, which features an intricate synthesiser solo designed to match the erratic hand movements of Goslingโs character on screen. It was the exact moment Hurwitz was most nervous about.
โThe synth solo is really technical, and I thought, even a really high-level professional sight-reader would probably not be able to do it,โ he said. โAs it was coming up, I was thinking, โOh no, howโs he going to be able to handle the solo?โโ
Nasa told the ABC he was thinking the same thing.
โI saw it on the score and I thought, oh, I donโt know if Iโm going to be able to sight-read that in one go,โ he said.
Like Goslingโs jazz-pianist character Sebastian, the student had to decide whether to stay in the shadows or take a monumental leap of faith. With no time to overthink, he chose to trust his instincts.
โI took a little bit of a creative liberty and just decided to improvise, which I think ended up being a good choice.โ
The gamble paid off, carrying the orchestra through the number โ and earning Nasa a resounding ovation from the audience.
โHe saw it coming up โฆ and he just improvised,โ Hurwitz said.
โThat is a whole other skill on top of sight-reading. To be able to play a really cool solo in the right key, in the right scale, on the fly with no rehearsal โ it was remarkable.โ
The backstage debrief after the final bow was full of mutual disbelief.
โI just told him how blown away I was, and obviously how thankful I was,โ Hurwitz said. โAll of our heads were spinning a little bit because it was such a surreal moment.โ
By Monday morning, the 21-year-old was experiencing a different kind of whirlwind, being ferried between breakfast television and radio studios to recount his sudden taste of showbiz fame.
Reflecting on the incredible turn of events, Nasa said it was an unforgettable privilege to play a soundtrack he had loved for years.
โIt was quite a blessing to get to play a work that Iโm in such admiration of,โ he said.
While the production team is now scrambling to rehearse new keyboardists for the upcoming Melbourne and Brisbane legs of the tour, Nasa will be heading back to his regular university lectures.
But has the student missed his calling in life?
Hurwitz said that while the young Sydneysider certainly has the talent for a career in music, the choice is ultimately his to make.
โI donโt know what heโs most passionate about,โ Hurwitz said. โMaybe he likes international relations a little more than music. But thatโs what La La Land is about. Youโve got to do what you love the most.โ
ย La La Land in Concert will play at the ICC Sydney on Monday, at the Brisbane Convention & Exhibition Centre on Wednesday and at the Hamer Hall in Melbourne from Friday 6 to 8 June.
The founder of a popular New York City LGBTQ+ book clubs talks queer literature, book clubs, and what she’s reading this summer for Pride Month.
“Itโs so important for everyone to be reading queer books by queer authors,” Joey Lobel said.ย Envato/Cage Rivera/Rewire News Group
In late 2022, Joey Lobel was frustrated.
An avid reader, Lobel, a 31-year-old butcher in Brooklyn, was struggling to find queer books that didnโt have sad endings.
โI went on a little spiral and I thought, Iโm sure other people are feeling the same way,โ she said.
So Lobel decided to make a queer book club page on the social networking website Meetup, hoping to build community around LGBTQ+ reads. She wasnโt sure if people would show up. But โworst case scenario,โ she recalled thinking, โIโm sitting at a bar with a book, which is completely fine.โ
But people did show up. And in the nearly four years since the Queer Book Club started, Lobelโs book club has become a staple in New York Cityโs LGBTQ+ communityโwith monthly meetups at the Brooklyn bar Young Ethelโs and an average of between 15 and 30 participants. The book clubโs one-off events, like book swaps, are popular and see upward of 60 attendees.
As summer gets underway, Lobel spoke to Rewire News Group about the importance of LGBTQ+ literature, generating a top-notch list of reads for Pride Month, and building community through books.
The following conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
What makes a book queer?
A book is queer if itโs written for queer people by queer people. There are so many books out there that have zero queer characters, or one passing queer character. And to me, thatโs not necessarily considered a queer book. But any book written for us, with us in mind, I want to read.
Do you have an all-time favorite queer book or queer character?
Thatโs so hard. My all-time favorite queer book is In The Dream House by Carmen Maria Machado. โฆ I read a lot of books. And a lot of times, I sort of forget immediately. Like, youโre out of that world and youโre back in your world, and you forget what happened. But In the Dream House has always stuck with me.
Is queer literature for everyone?
I definitely believe queer literature is for everyone. You can learn from anyone. You can be entertained by anyone. And itโs important that weโre able to look at viewpoints other than our own. The amount of straight books that Iโve read in my life that Iโve enjoyed is vast. I just feel like itโs so important for everyone to be reading queer books by queer authors.
And to remind publishers that queer authors are authors people want to read.
Thereโs such a big audience out there. There are so many queer shows right now being canceled. There are such audiences for them, and theyโre still being cancelled. We have to support queer media. And straight people have to support queer media. Itโs enjoyable for everyone.
How do you approach building a queer summer reading list?
The reason I love the book club for figuring out what youโre going to read is that Iโm always reading books that I would never choose on my own. If it was up to me, weโd be reading cute little rom-coms where everyone falls in love at the end. I love those, and thereโs definitely space in my reading list for thoseโa big, big chunk of space.
I also like being able to read books that other people recommend to me. I look at a lot of Instagram recommendations.
Thereโs just so many books out there, itโs hard to choose. I also read so much more in the summer. So I try and hoard all of the books that I want to read until it gets warm. And then Iโm outside just reading all day.
Speaking of, what are three books on your summer reading list?
I read this book previously, and I definitely want to reread it. It was incredible. Itโs called Fracineโs Spectacular Crash and Burn by Renee Swindle. Itโs so good. Itโs about a young woman who loses her mom. And thereโs a really interesting relationship dynamic in there with her mom who has passed, and with this young boy that she meets that sheโs protecting, and someone that she starts dating. Thereโs so many layers to it that I want to reread it, because I know Iโm going to get more of it the second time.
Right now, Iโm reading Nevada by Imogen Binnie. Thatโs Juneโs book club pick. Iโm halfway through, and itโs a really great book. Itโs so different from the way that I see the world. From this characterโs perspective, itโs a little darker and a little chaoticโmore chaotic than Iโm used toโwhich I think makes for an interesting dynamic to read about.
I also want to read Mac Craneโs new book, A Sharp Endless Need. Their last book, I Keep My Exoskeletons To Myself, was hauntingly beautifulโand not something I would gravitate toward because itโs not the rom-com, two girls falling in love. But we read it for book club and I was entranced. And thatโs why Iโm so glad that I get to read books that arenโt just my normal go-tos.
But one that is my normal go-to, which I havenโt read yet, is Puck by Samantha Allen. Itโs been pitched to me as a Midsummer Nightโs Dream spinoff with reality TV. And Iโm already invested.
What advice do you have for people who are unsure about whether book clubs are for them?
Thereโs a lot of reasons why people might be a little nervous to join a book club. I was worried that I would have to always public speak, which is a little tough when youโre not feeling up to it. I was also worried that it would be tough finishing a book on a timelineโit does remind me a little bit of school, in that way. (Editorโs note: Lobelโs club has a rule that not finishing the monthly book is totally fine, so long as youโre โfine with spoilers.โ)
But book clubs are very welcoming. You can just go in, and talk to people.
Whatโs the worst that can happen? Youโre surrounded by other queer people who love books.
I read the article linked below.ย To show how badly these papers were done one paper used reports made in theย Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) to find what he said were โunusual patterns and safety signals highly suggestive of a causal relationshipโ between vaccination and Sids. VAERS is a vaccine safety monitoring program where anyone can submit a report about any suspected adverse health event that happens after a vaccination.ย Morgan McSweeney, a scientist who posts on social media asย Dr.Noc said of the people running the CDCย โThey have a strong opinion about what is true. And then they go looking for whatever scrap of low-quality evidence they can find to support that opinion,โ McSweeney said. โIf that finding supports the story that they believe, theyโre willing to overlook data points from hundreds of thousands or millions of children and go with the one that fits their story.โย โThis was a low-quality, very small study that was not replicated. So yeah, the CDC page now says that some studies supporting a link have been ignored by health authorities,โ McSweeney said inย the video, which now has more than 5m views betweenย Instagramย and TikTok. โAnd maybe thatโs a little bit true, because the studies theyโre showing here are worth less than a fart in the summer breeze.โย Hugs
When approaching recent historical events, where the scope of destruction and loss can be unfathomable in scale, oral history can bring both connection and immediacy through individual stories of loss, grief, rescue, or triumph that would otherwise disappear in the grand sweep of โGreat Men and their Deeds.โ
[T]he method enables the documentation of certain aspects of historical experience that are often missing from other kinds of historical sources. Oral historians not only interview and engage in conversation with living sources, they also find themselves challenged in a unique wayโthe historian is transformed into a protagonist in the dialogue. Oral history is perhaps the only field where the sources talk back to the historian, confronting, disputing, disrupting, and sometimes resisting the historianโs understanding of the past (Frisch 1990; Shopes 2012). Oral history works with the interviewee as a partner in dialogue and the verbal form historical truth can take is always co-constructed (Cook and Goodall 2013; Goodall and Cadzow 2009; Portelli 1991).
Some of the most effective (and affecting) projects using this approach concern communities that may be far outside of the audienceโs experience, whether due to time, geography, or identity. Works like Shoah by Claude Lanzmann, Hard Times by Studs Terkel, and Boots of Leather, Slippers of Gold by Elizabeth Lapovsky Kennedy document their subjects through the voices of those who lived through specific moments and events that can be overwhelming or remain unknown without a more interpersonal method.
โMany of the best works about this disease have been produced by people at various stages of HIV infection.โ
The history of the HIV/AIDS epidemic has recently become the subject of numerous oral history projects, where the stories of survivors, caregivers, activists, and health care professionals have been collected and made available online, traditionally published, and edited into documentaries.
One such collection, Visual Arts and the AIDS Epidemic, was begun in 2015 by the Smithsonian Archives of American Art after receiving a grant from The Keith Haring Foundation. Haring founded the foundation in 1989, a year before his death from HIV-related illness, to maintain his artistic and philanthropic legacy. The project interviewed forty artists about their lives, their work, and how the AIDS crisis intersected and permeated both.
The interviews in the Visual Arts and the AIDS Epidemic collection cover wide ranges of personal and creative history, ranging from insider gossip and โname-droppingโ to theoretical discussions of method and art history. They benefit from interviewers who bring their own experience as artists, art scholars, and historians to the conversation, with questions and insights that make this collection a rich multifaceted history of AIDS, the arts, and activism.
as if the artist were immersed in dealing with the epidemicโas so many are. Many of the best works about this disease have been produced by people at various stages of HIV infection. Perhaps they have lost a lover, nursed a dear friend, or attended a dozen funerals at a young age, and feel themselves to be, in every sense, set apart by the experience. They are implicated. Their art signifies a collective traumaโmass death in the midst of life.
Reveal Digital, an initiative โto amplify important, long-overlooked voices of the twentieth century,โ has made these histories, and more, available in their developing open access collection HIV, AIDS and the Arts.
Artists in The Early Years of the Epidemic
โI still canโt believeโI still donโt believe that AIDS even existed and wiped out our community in the โ80s, just wiped off our community from the history. Itโs unbelievable to me. Everybody who held myโwho carried my history is dead.โ โNan Goldin
One year later, William F. Buckley published a New York Times op-ed calling for HIV-positive people to be tattooed on the upper arm and buttocks to protect others (assuming that would protect both future sexual partners and intravenous drug users who might share needles). News reports about the disease largely focused on fear of contagion, the promiscuity and danger of gay men, and the threat of HIV to โnormalโ Americans.
In the interviews gathered in the Visual Arts and the AIDS Epidemic collection, artists describe how they first became aware of AIDS: from a loved one diagnosed after an illness; from hearing of a friendโs passing after not seeing them for a while; from a doctor telling them to stay with a partner because โthereโs something going aroundโ; or by learning of their own diagnosis. Friends were lost to the disease, and surviving family members denied the illness or sometimes actively excluded partners from funerals.
Sur Rodney (Sur), a New York City-based writer, gallery co-director, and archivist, relates that the late artistย David Wojnarowiczย would go to his local bodega in New York City where the clerks returned his change in a paper bag, out of fear. He describes his own anxieties when stepping in after a friendโs death to help save and archive their artworks and collections so they wouldnโt be destroyed (before there were nonprofit organizations to do so).
These personal experiences unfolded within the larger context of governmental indifference, active discrimination against people with the disease (or belonging to groups that were deemed โat riskโ), and a growing consciousness of the political landscape of the epidemic. Robert Vasquez-Pacheco, a member of ACT UP and Gran Fury, recounts,
as I was becoming more and more politically aware, I became more and more pissed off, you know, because I was seeing. I was beginning to understand how women were being treated. I had an understanding, a firsthand understanding, of how people of color are treated, you know, because I knew that. But then I started to understand the institutional stuff and all of that, and consequently, as a gay man. So I started to put all of this stuff together and I was just super pissed off.
Some version of this process, repeated for many of the subjects, led people to activism, whether through art, volunteer work, protest, or sometimes all three. Nancy Brooks Brody (1962-2023), a visual artist and member of the fierce pussy collective, describes the progression in her interview.โBecause when people were dying,โ she explains,
we just kept going. [โฆ] You went to a funeral, and then you were out on the streets. Or you were at a meeting, and then you went to a hospital to take care of someone and feed them. Feed someoneโs cats, walk their dog, help someone move. You know? These things justโwe didnโt have anyโI didnโt have any room or perspective on it. It was just what was happening.
The meetings she, and others, refer to were those of ACT UP New York (The AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power), which began in 1987 at a community meeting where Larry Kramer asked, โHow long does it take before you get angry and fight back?โ Kramer, a playwright and essayist who had been covering AIDS since the beginning through journalism, had co-founded the non-profit Gay Menโs Health Crisis in 1982. His play The Normal Heart, an impassioned call to action, spurred members of the audience to meet and subsequently take part in one of the most significant and effective activist movements of the twentieth century.
Creating Art in an Epidemic
The artistic works of those interviewed are diverse, both in media and approach: photographing people living with AIDS, using dรฉtournement to turn existing works into calls to action via graphic design, or using their body to confront audiences with the existence of the disease through performance. In some cases, their illness became an essential component of their art: John Dugdale, a former commercial photographer, began using nineteenth-century methods to capture and produce his work after HIV-related retinitis and a stroke left his sight significantly impaired. Ron Athey, one of the NEA Four, used his own HIV-positive body to create work exploring sex, trauma, and desire. The place of the artist within (or outside) a community could become a contentious issue, especially at a time when representation of people with AIDS was so fraught.
Rosalind Fox Solomon, whose 1988 show Portraits in the Time of AIDS featured photographs of the subject alone or with loved ones, some with visible lesions or in the hospital, relates that her project was critically panned and called โexploitativeโ at the time.
Some of the most vibrant, and now iconic, images of AIDS were created as (and for) protest: Silence = Death, the work of the Silence = Death Collective (and not ACT UP, as Avram Finkelstein relates in his interview) became the primary pictorial representation of ACT UP and a rallying slogan for the fight against the disease. Keith Haring did his own take on it for a poster, adding โIgnorance = Fearโ to a โSee No Evil, Hear No Evil, Speak No Evilโ scene.
Collectives like Gran Fury and fierce pussy, which organized inside the ACT UP activist group, created posters for wheat-pasting that served as art, education, and calls to action around AIDS, homophobia, health care, and visibility. Whether newsprint works of text, guerrilla-installed bus station โads,โ or rolls of stickers of bloody hands announcing โOne AIDS Death Every 10 Minutes,โ the art of AIDS activism used any means available to communicate the urgency of the crisis.
The Visual Arts and the AIDS Epidemic collection demonstrates the power of oral history to preserve not just historical events, but what it felt like to live in the moment and survive it when so many people did not. Together with Reveal Digitalโs HIV, AIDS, and the Arts archive, the collection ensures that these voices, experiences, and creative histories continue to be available to inform and educate future generations.
June is LGBTQIA+ Pride Month in the United States, so weโve collected some of our most popular stories on a range of topicsโfrom pronouns to politicsโthat highlight the history of the LGBTQIA+ community. As always, links to free JSTOR scholarship are included with each of these.
WASHINGTON โ Today, Senator Ruben Gallego (D-AZ) introduced the Redistribution Of Billions by Instituting New High-income Obligations on Overlooked Debt (ROBINHOOD) Act to close the โborrowโ aspect of the โbuy, borrow, dieโ tax loophole that is used by the ultra-wealthy to finance extravagant spending without paying income or capital gains taxes.
โWorking and middle-class Americans are paying their fair share โ they do it with every paycheck. But the billionaires in this country? Theyโre using legal loopholes and tricky accounting to finance private jets and yachts while most Americans struggle to afford healthcare and groceries,โ said Senator Gallego. โMy legislation closes a critical loophole and brings us closer to billionaires finally paying their fair share.โ
The โbuy, borrow, dieโ tax loophole has three stages:
Buy:ย A wealthy individual buys, or is given as part of their compensation package, assets, such as stocks. This allows them to store and grow their wealth without paying taxes since the gains from these assets are consideredย unrealized.ย
Borrow:ย The individual then borrowsย tax-free cash loans, often backed by those assets, to finance their extravagant lifestyles. All the while, their assets continue to gain value.
Die: Finally, when they die,ย their assets are gifted to their heirs on aย stepped-up basis, meaning their heirs can sell the assets without paying taxes on the capital gains accumulated during the individualโs life.
The ROBINHOOD Act closes this loophole by treating taking out a loan as a realization event, meaning the individual would have to pay taxes on capital gains equal to the loan amount. The provisions of the bill apply to taxpayers who have an income over $100 million and/or assets worth more than $1 billion.
You can find a one-page summary of the legislation HERE.
You can find a section-by-section explainer of the legislation HERE.
You can find the full text of the legislation HERE.
Companion legislation was introduced in the House by Rep. Dan Goldman (NY-10).
โWhile working, wage-earning New Yorkers pay income taxes on every single paycheck, billionaires live tax-free by borrowing against their stock portfolios, real estate holdings, and art collections without paying a dime in taxes on that money,โย Congressman Dan Goldman said. โBy restoring basic fairness to our tax code and making the ultra-wealthy pay their fair share and contribute what they owe, this bill will generate revenue to invest in universal pre-K, child care, and working families instead of subsidizing billionairesโ yachts and private islands. Itโs long past time for the wealthiest people in the country to pay their fair share.โ
A group of Black Skimmers in flight resembles an aerial ballet, circling, banking, and gracefully alighting as one. Although taxonomists place this unique, long-winged waterbird in a separate genus, itโs closely related to gulls and terns.
The Black Skimmerโs most striking feature is its gaudy red-and-black bill: Both jaws are long and narrow like a knife blade, with the lower jutting out well beyond the upper. Its unique appearance lends the Black Skimmer a number of evocative folk names, including Scissor-bill, Cutwater (Cortagua or Corta-agua in South America), and Seadog (after its calls, often compared to dog barks).
This odd bill is what affords these birds their distinctive foraging style, and the name โskimmer.โ A feeding skimmer flies low over the water with its beak open and lower mandible partially submerged. Where a broader bill would send a continuous spray of seawater straight down the throat of another species, the uniquely narrow mandible of the skimmer cuts through the water like a fin. When the extended lower mandible touches prey, such as a small fish, the billโs upper mandible snaps down, securing the birdโs meal.
Another remarkable feature of the Black Skimmer is its eyes, which have large pupils that can narrow to vertical slits, like a catโs pupils. This adaptation compensates for glare off the waterโs surface and may enhance the birdโs vision as it hunts in dim light or at night.
Threats
According to the North American Breeding Bird Survey, Black Skimmers have declined in the United States by almost 90 percent since 1966. This is largely due to habitat loss and human disturbance at nesting colonies. These birds are also affected by oil spills and chemical pollution in coastal waters, and may face additional threats during the breeding season with climate change as sea levels continue to rise. (snip-MORE)
Life has been happening here with me this couple of weeks, and I have a few things I’ve picked up here and there to post when I’m busy. Most of this is positive, because why not?
Hey-today is World Environment Day! Let’s be proud to care for our home; we all get overheated.
June 5, [since 1972]
World Environment Day was established by the U.N. General Assembly to commemorate the opening of the Stockholm Conference on the Human Environment in Sweden. The United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) was established as a result of the conference.
UNEPโs mission: To provide leadership and encourage partnership in caring for the environment by inspiring, informing, and enabling nations and peoples to improve their quality of life without compromising that of future generations.
This is pure racism and entitlement.ย The boy put the bottles of water back.ย But even if he had not does stealing bottles of water rate or equate to a death penalty performed by a civilian?ย This is clearly an extra juditiacal killing.ย No judge or jury just a store owner and his son angry thinking a kid stole from them deciding to end his life.ย This automatic killing of Black people with no evidence has to stop.ย ย Black Lives Matter. Hugs
Gas station owner charged in shooting death of 14-year-oldRick Chow, 58, has been charged with murder after allegedly killing Cyrus Carmack-Belton in Columbia, South Carolina, on Sunday, police said.
The family of Cyrus Carmack-Belton expressed their indignation towards a South Carolina juryโs decision on Tuesday to acquit Chikei Rick Chow in the 2023 fatal shooting of the Black 14-year-old.ย
โYesterday a jury watched our 14-year-old boy run away from two grown men on video. They knew one of them shot him in the back and they still said no one is to blame,โ the family said in a statement first released to ABC News. โWe are heartbroken. We do not accept it. Cyrus stole nothing. He was a child, and he was running for his life. Our son mattered.โ
Chow, a 61-year-old store owner, shot the 14-year-old in the back outside of his Columbia, South Carolina, store in May 2023. He and his son were seen chasing Carmack-Belton outside of the store in video leading to the incident. Chow was charged with murder and denied bond multiple times before his acquittal.ย
An image of Cyrus Carmack-Belton is displayed in court during closing arguments in the murder trial against his shooter, Chikei Rick Chow, a convenience store owner accused in the 2023 fatal shooting of the 14-year-old, on June 1, 2026, in Columbia, S.C.
Erik Verduzco/AP Photo
Prosecutors alleged that Chow acted out of a false belief that Carmack-Belton had shoplifted four bottles of water from his store. The defense claimed that Chow acted to protect his son, after allegedly seeing Carmack-Belton point a gun at him.
“On behalf of the Chows, we’re very pleased at the jury’s deliberations and their verdict,” attorney Jack Swerling said in a statement to ABC News. “We think it was the appropriate verdict in this case, although it was a difficult decision to come to, because you have two different stories, two extreme differences.”
Video obtained by ABC News shows that Carmack-Belton returned the bottles of water in question and did not steal anything from the store. A 9mm pistol was found next to Carmack-Belton, with prosecutors saying it was in his possession during the chase, and it had fallen to the ground at some point.
In this June 1, 2023, file photo, mourners stop by a memorial to Cyrus Carmack-Belton, in Columbia, S.C.
Jeffrey Collins/AP, FILE
As the verdict was read in the courtroom, members of the Carmack-Belton family and the audience were seen breaking into sobs.ย
In their statement Tuesday, Carmack-Beltonโs family drew a connection between their case and a larger history of violence against the Black community. โBlack families have stood right here too many times โ burying our children and then being told the law sees nothing. We feel every bit of that today,โ the family said.
Troy Belton, center, father of Cyrus Carmack-Belton, reacts after a not guilty verdict against Chikei Rick Chow, a convenience store owner accused in the 2023 fatal shooting of his 14-year-old son, during a murder trial, on June 1, 2026, in Columbia, S.C.
Erik Verduzco/AP Photo
โTo everyone hurting with us: honor Cyrus in peace. We will not stop. Weโre taking this fight to civil court, and we will not rest until our sonโs life is given the dignity this verdict denied him,โ the family added.
According to family attorney Todd Rutherford, the family filed a civil lawsuit against Rick Chow in Richland County, which was put on hold until the conclusion of the criminal case.ย