Andrew Perry said his body was a temple. His drinking and vaping suggest otherwise.
This newsletter is free and goes out to over 26,000 subscribers, but it’s only able to sustain itself due to the support I receive from a small percentage of regular readers. Would you please consider becoming one of those supporters? You can subscribe via Patreon or the Subscribe button below! You can also make one-time donations through Venmo, CashApp, or PayPal.
The Iowa Supreme Court has rejected a nursing student’s plea that he deserved a “religious exemption” to getting vaccinated against COVID. His school didn’t buy his excuse, leading to a lawsuit, but the courts have upheld the school’s argument that religion had nothing to do with this and the guy has been lying about it the whole time.
In November of 2021, Andrew Perry, a nursing student at (private Christian school) Dordt University in Sioux Center, refused to get vaccinated before starting his clinical rotations. He needed the exemption, he said, because it violated his religious beliefs, but the school said no.
It all boiled down to the idea that religious beliefs must be “sincerely held” for the exemption to be granted and Perry didn’t have any credibility, something the Iowa Supreme Court noted in their decision.
For example, the school said, Perry didn’t even care about the issue. His anti-vax parents put him up to this: His mother Galyn said she wouldn’t pay for school if he got vaccinated. Perry himself said in an email to the chair of the nursing department, “I personally do not have a problem with the vaccine” and even “volunteered and received training to help give the vaccine to others.” When pressed in court to explain why he didn’t want to get vaccinated, religion didn’t even come up. It was all about his mother’s threat to stop paying for his education. Perry even admitted to the school that he was thinking about getting the vaccine behind his mother’s back.
Even though both sides tried to work out a compromise, there was no way around the vaccination. The school explained this wasn’t their decision, but rather a requirement of all the sites where students were receiving their training.
Eventually, Perry settled on the idea that religion would be his way out. The school said he just needed to prove he had religious reasons for not getting the shot—like a “published position” against vaccines from his denomination or proof that he had received religious exemptions during his K-12 education. He had neither.
Instead, Perry said “his body is a temple of God and that he must be a steward of his own body. Thus… if he were to knowingly put something in his body that would only hold risk for his body, he would be violating that religious belief.”
That wasn’t enough. The school needed documentation. He didn’t provide it. So they said no.
Eventually, after realizing 20 other nursing schools weren’t going to accept credits from this private Christian school and would also require him to get vaccinated, he settled for admission into Palm Beach Atlantic University—another private Christian school—and left Dordt.
But where the decision really gets interesting is the description of what Perry said under oath when he was cross-examined about the sincerity of his religious claims.
The court noted that “Andrew clearly did not have issues with introducing other things into his body that were unhealthy or a risk to his health.” Specifically, the court noted that “Andrew conceded that he had been drunk with friends in the past” and also that “he vapes nicotine.” The court also noted Andrew’s testimony “that Gayln objects to his vaping, but has never threatened to cut him off financially if he did not stop vaping.” “Gayln also never threatened to cut off Andrew financially for drinking alcohol to excess.”
Beautiful. His “temple” can’t handle vaccinations but it’s apparently fine with nicotine and alcohol. His mother knew about those things but never even suggested cutting him off for all that. (Perry’s lawyer later argued that this was unfair because the school didn’t know about his vaping or drinking, so how dare they use that against him? but the court didn’t buy that argument either.)
Making matters worse, Perry claimed not getting vaccinated was his decision… even though he also testified that his mother threatened to cut him off financially over it. Yet, when asked what he would do if she changed her mind, he said he would be fine with getting vaccinated.
This guy is an opposing lawyer’s dream.
Ultimately, the court didn’t buy his argument that Jesus was the reason he couldn’t get vaccinated. It was about money, and there’s no My-Mom-Pays-My-Tuition exemption to getting vaccinated. (The lower court even said “Andrew’s argument would have carried more sincerity if he had contended he was trying to follow the religious commandment of ‘honor thy father and mother’; however, that is not a claim that he ever asserted in this case.”)
You almost feel bad for Andrew because he had to make up all these lies to satisfy his batshit crazy mother, but he’s an adult, and he went along with it. So too damn bad. He can live with the consequences of knowing he couldn’t even overcome the extremely low bar of using your religion to get out of following a rule everyone else has to obey.
His desire would have made it easier for COVID to spread—which should have been a deal breaker for someone who wants to go into the medical field—but thankfully the school refused to honor that idiotic request and they were vindicated in court.
You can watch the full oral arguments here:
It feels rare for a court to reject someone’s request for a religious exemption because you can’t probe their mind. But in this case, there was plenty of evidence that religion played no actual part of Perry’s refusal to take public health measures. He lied about his faith and everyone caught him. You can’t say your body is a temple only when mommy won’t pay for tuition.
Part of me feels bad for the situation Andrew Perry was placed in, but he’s not a child. He couldn’t deal with his overbearing, crazy, conspiracy-believing mother, so she became everyone else’s problem.
The Iowa Supreme Court got this right. They didn’t rule against his religion; they ruled against his sincerity. That makes a huge difference. While religious freedom is important, it shouldn’t be used as some magical phrase to get out of anything you want. It shouldn’t be a loophole, even though that’s often what it seems to be these days.
To be clear, a religious exemption shouldn’t be automatic. Someone’s faith shouldn’t make it easier for others to get infected with a virus. But at the very least, you should have to prove you’re serious about your faith if you’re going to use that excuse to harm others, and this family couldn’t even do that.
In a 5-4 vote, the Supreme Court cleared the way for President Donald Trump to continue building the White House ballroom, rejecting a challenge from a preservation group that was seeking to indefinitely halt the controversial project. https://cnn.it/3UsAOqU
Trump immediately blames Joe Biden for the 13 deaths at Abbey Gate in Afghanistan. Trump forever forgets he caused the withdrawal problem by negotiating with the Taliban without the Afghan government involved. The withdrawal took longer than the timetable he created.#Trump #Afghanistan #AbbeyGate
MAGA had a meltdown when 13 servicemembers were killed at Abbey Gate trying to evacuate after Trump surrendered to the Taliban. Now the Republicans think it's funny that 13 servicemembers have been killed in the GOP's latest Never Ending War in the Middle East. http://www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-…
Hey MAGA, remember when Donald Trump freed 5000 Taliban without even speaking to the Afghani government – then the Taliban took over the Afghani government? Then he struck a deal to get out of there and blamed Joe Biden for the Chaos he left behind, I do!
(Bloomberg) – US allies are privately warning that the Strait of Hormuz is still likely mined, casting doubt on President Donald Trump’s claim that the US Navy has completely removed and detonated explosives laid by Iran.@bloomberg.comhttp://www.bloomberg.com/news/article…
Mehdi Hasan to MAGA pastor Doug Wilson on Donald Trump:
"Your leader, your hero, the guy you're a fan of is the most unchristian man who's ever come anywhere near public office– thrice married, adulterer who slept with a porn star, ran casinos, lies in every breath, curses,… pic.twitter.com/AuI0FaWfZ5
Heidi Overton is a far-right, anti-abortion extremist who has no business leading the FDA.The American people deserve someone who will put science and facts FIRST, not another Trump sycophant who will make it their mission to attack medication abortion.I will vote NO.
Data centers in the 7 states with the highest concentration of them use more water than L.A., Phoenix, and D.C. combined.Now Trump's EPA is making it even harder for communities to push back against them. He's forcing the Big Tech takeover on America, democracy be damned.
The Kennedy Center will remove a major outdoor sculpture from the center’s grounds on Wednesday. The work was targeted for elimination after President Trump’s takeover of the center, according to internal documents obtained by The New York Times.
Far-right Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has shared a disturbing concentration camp video depicting Palestinians being placed into a machine on a conveyor belt, entering overweight and emerging thin, distressed and crying. #StopTheGame
Israel's National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has deleted his video depicting kidnapped Palestinians being sent into an industrialized slaughterhouse. pic.twitter.com/4xUCnyqqae
"First they came for hand cranks, and I said nothing. Then they integrated starter/alternators and I said nothing. Then they put remote start on keyfobs and I said nothing." – Sean Duffy https://t.co/obr27gOZbs
Cracking up at the mental picture of Duffy sitting in a car for 30 minutes, frustration increasing, until someone finally tells him to press the brake pedal first. https://t.co/FMXHbCm5TV
Breaking news: The Supreme Court said construction can continue on the White House ballroom.The justices found that the historic preservationists who challenged the project had not suffered the direct personal harm required to bring a lawsuit.
Dr. Erica Schwartz has been nominated to lead the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
(Graeme Sloan/Bloomberg/Getty Images)
The Senate’s health committee on Thursday pushed back a vote to advance two top health care nominations to the Senate floor but indicated that one, the pick to lead the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, would win the necessary votes after some assurances by the Trump administration — including a change to the CDC’s website on autism and vaccines.
In a statement Thursday, Sen. Bill Cassidy, chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, said the agency “needs someone who understands that the way to prevent vaccine-preventable diseases is to reassure the public that vaccines are safe and effective.”
After speaking with CDC nominee Dr. Erica Schwartz again and reviewing the transcript of her hearing, Cassidy said, he’s confident “she knows what she is doing and will stand against those who don’t.”
“As a sign of good faith, [the US Department of Health and Human Services] modified the CDC’s autism and vaccines webpage,” Cassidy said. “There is more to do to repair the damage that has been done to the U.S. public health response, but this is a start.”
Cassidy had previously voted to confirm HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. after the nominee assured him, as Cassidy said, that “CDC will not remove statements on their website pointing out that vaccines do not cause autism.”
The CDC did not remove that language but in November added a sentence: “Vaccines do not cause autism is not an evidence-based claim.”
As of Thursday, the website reads, “Scientists have not identified the root causes of autism. HHS continues to support rigorous scientific research and will update this page as reliable new evidence becomes available.”
On Thursday, Cassidy also suggested that he had lingering concerns about Sean Kaufman, the nominee to lead the Administration for Strategic Preparedness and Response.
Sen. Bill Cassidy, chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, said the CDC “needs someone who understands that the way to prevent vaccine-preventable diseases is to reassure the public that vaccines are safe and effective.”
(Al Drago/Reuters/File)
Cassidy grilled both Schwartz and Kaufman at a committee hearing last week, questioning whether Schwartz would have autonomy in her role after CDC upheaval last year and raising Kaufman’s past remarks about vaccines.
“Any time there is somebody contributing to confusion on immunizations that gives me concern,” Cassidy told reporters on Thursday, referencing Kaufman.
Cassidy lost his reelection bid this year after President Donald Trump endorsed a rival contender and the Louisiana senator sparred with the administration over vaccine rhetoric.
The committee had been expected to vote on Thursday, but the vote was delayed due to attendance issues. At least one Republican, Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, was not at the Capitol on Thursday. The committee is expected to reconvene for votes on the health care nominees and the nomination of Keith Sonderling to be secretary of the Department of Labor next week.
Whether Kaufman has the votes to advance remains unclear.
“There are ongoing conversations with the administration on the path forward for Mr. Kaufman’s nomination,” a HELP Committee spokesperson said.
Kennedy, a longtime vaccine skeptic, ousted the 17-member Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) earlier this week in a stunning move that shocked medical experts. He defended his action in an interview with Fox News’ Martha MacCallum, claiming that “97% of the people on the committee had conflicts of interest.”
He repeated falsehoods about vaccines that were immediately fact checked by doctors on social media platform X. He falsely claimed there were between 69 and 92 mandatory vaccines in the U.S. today and that most of the vaccines, excluding the COVID-19 vaccine, had not gone through safety tests.
“So nobody has any idea what the risk profiles are on these products, and we don’t know whether they have anything to do with the epidemic of chronic disease,” Kennedy said, presenting no evidence for his claims.
This is a must watch video. It totally destroys the anti-vaccine groups and the Idea that vaccines cause autism. This is a medial Scientist researcher with the greatest knowledge in the field of study and he has an autistic daughter. He knocks down and shows proof of the lies of the anti-vaccine people. He explains how it all became a political issue and power, and how it is killing people. Hugs