Andrew Perry said his body was a temple. His drinking and vaping suggest otherwise.
This newsletter is free and goes out to over 26,000 subscribers, but it’s only able to sustain itself due to the support I receive from a small percentage of regular readers. Would you please consider becoming one of those supporters? You can subscribe via Patreon or the Subscribe button below! You can also make one-time donations through Venmo, CashApp, or PayPal.
The Iowa Supreme Court has rejected a nursing student’s plea that he deserved a “religious exemption” to getting vaccinated against COVID. His school didn’t buy his excuse, leading to a lawsuit, but the courts have upheld the school’s argument that religion had nothing to do with this and the guy has been lying about it the whole time.
In November of 2021, Andrew Perry, a nursing student at (private Christian school) Dordt University in Sioux Center, refused to get vaccinated before starting his clinical rotations. He needed the exemption, he said, because it violated his religious beliefs, but the school said no.
It all boiled down to the idea that religious beliefs must be “sincerely held” for the exemption to be granted and Perry didn’t have any credibility, something the Iowa Supreme Court noted in their decision.
For example, the school said, Perry didn’t even care about the issue. His anti-vax parents put him up to this: His mother Galyn said she wouldn’t pay for school if he got vaccinated. Perry himself said in an email to the chair of the nursing department, “I personally do not have a problem with the vaccine” and even “volunteered and received training to help give the vaccine to others.” When pressed in court to explain why he didn’t want to get vaccinated, religion didn’t even come up. It was all about his mother’s threat to stop paying for his education. Perry even admitted to the school that he was thinking about getting the vaccine behind his mother’s back.
Even though both sides tried to work out a compromise, there was no way around the vaccination. The school explained this wasn’t their decision, but rather a requirement of all the sites where students were receiving their training.
Eventually, Perry settled on the idea that religion would be his way out. The school said he just needed to prove he had religious reasons for not getting the shot—like a “published position” against vaccines from his denomination or proof that he had received religious exemptions during his K-12 education. He had neither.
Instead, Perry said “his body is a temple of God and that he must be a steward of his own body. Thus… if he were to knowingly put something in his body that would only hold risk for his body, he would be violating that religious belief.”
That wasn’t enough. The school needed documentation. He didn’t provide it. So they said no.
Eventually, after realizing 20 other nursing schools weren’t going to accept credits from this private Christian school and would also require him to get vaccinated, he settled for admission into Palm Beach Atlantic University—another private Christian school—and left Dordt.
But where the decision really gets interesting is the description of what Perry said under oath when he was cross-examined about the sincerity of his religious claims.
The court noted that “Andrew clearly did not have issues with introducing other things into his body that were unhealthy or a risk to his health.” Specifically, the court noted that “Andrew conceded that he had been drunk with friends in the past” and also that “he vapes nicotine.” The court also noted Andrew’s testimony “that Gayln objects to his vaping, but has never threatened to cut him off financially if he did not stop vaping.” “Gayln also never threatened to cut off Andrew financially for drinking alcohol to excess.”
Beautiful. His “temple” can’t handle vaccinations but it’s apparently fine with nicotine and alcohol. His mother knew about those things but never even suggested cutting him off for all that. (Perry’s lawyer later argued that this was unfair because the school didn’t know about his vaping or drinking, so how dare they use that against him? but the court didn’t buy that argument either.)
Making matters worse, Perry claimed not getting vaccinated was his decision… even though he also testified that his mother threatened to cut him off financially over it. Yet, when asked what he would do if she changed her mind, he said he would be fine with getting vaccinated.
This guy is an opposing lawyer’s dream.
Ultimately, the court didn’t buy his argument that Jesus was the reason he couldn’t get vaccinated. It was about money, and there’s no My-Mom-Pays-My-Tuition exemption to getting vaccinated. (The lower court even said “Andrew’s argument would have carried more sincerity if he had contended he was trying to follow the religious commandment of ‘honor thy father and mother’; however, that is not a claim that he ever asserted in this case.”)
You almost feel bad for Andrew because he had to make up all these lies to satisfy his batshit crazy mother, but he’s an adult, and he went along with it. So too damn bad. He can live with the consequences of knowing he couldn’t even overcome the extremely low bar of using your religion to get out of following a rule everyone else has to obey.
His desire would have made it easier for COVID to spread—which should have been a deal breaker for someone who wants to go into the medical field—but thankfully the school refused to honor that idiotic request and they were vindicated in court.
You can watch the full oral arguments here:
It feels rare for a court to reject someone’s request for a religious exemption because you can’t probe their mind. But in this case, there was plenty of evidence that religion played no actual part of Perry’s refusal to take public health measures. He lied about his faith and everyone caught him. You can’t say your body is a temple only when mommy won’t pay for tuition.
Part of me feels bad for the situation Andrew Perry was placed in, but he’s not a child. He couldn’t deal with his overbearing, crazy, conspiracy-believing mother, so she became everyone else’s problem.
The Iowa Supreme Court got this right. They didn’t rule against his religion; they ruled against his sincerity. That makes a huge difference. While religious freedom is important, it shouldn’t be used as some magical phrase to get out of anything you want. It shouldn’t be a loophole, even though that’s often what it seems to be these days.
To be clear, a religious exemption shouldn’t be automatic. Someone’s faith shouldn’t make it easier for others to get infected with a virus. But at the very least, you should have to prove you’re serious about your faith if you’re going to use that excuse to harm others, and this family couldn’t even do that.
Kudos to @luciengreaves.bsky.social and everyone else who spent so much time on this case. Thanks for your service. This is huge. reason.com/2026/04/02/s…
Inbox: LGBTQ org @EqualityFlorida is condemning an attack text linking to a 2020 report about CD 24 candidate @ShevrinJones being turned away from a blood drive due to his sexuality.
Equality, which endorsed Jones, says it didn't pay for the text, which the text says it did. pic.twitter.com/6fd6bpPhYm
NEW: The DOJ asked SCOTUS to quickly allow the Trump administration to implement his anti-voting executive order after a federal judge issued a nationwide block on the measure.The push underscores the administration's urgency to impose sweeping mail voting restrictions for the midterms.
Since you’re too afraid to debate me, how about you “hold me accountable” on a football field instead. Tackle, no pads like we used to play when we were kids. I’d be happy to show you much I love football. https://t.co/6oQ6sunxZn
TOWN HALL CALLER: Hi Paxton, nice to meet you. I'm just wondering — why did you cheat on you wife?
KEN PAXTON: Um. I'm not going to talk about personal issues that relate to my family, just like I don't think you would want to discuss your marriage on a call with thousands of… pic.twitter.com/9en7qlSdVM
Exclusive: The Trump administration plans to spend at least $900 million on White House grounds construction, a significantly larger price tag than previously reported.Taxpayers would cover most of the cost, according to records reviewed by The Post.
Trump lies out his ass:Q: Why was it too dangerous for you to fly on Air Force One but not for the press?TRUMP: Well, I don't know, I think actually the plane I that I flew on was at greater riskQ: Why do you say that?TRUMP: Because that would be the plane they would be more likely to go for
Every parent wants to keep their children safe, and vaccines are among the most powerful tools for doing that, making deadly diseases preventable. @WHO is concerned that recent changes to US immunization policy are not aligned with decades of evidence that show when children… pic.twitter.com/vCfgJFrFGK
Trump Administration Kills a Flagship Annual Report on the ArcticThe top of the world is warming faster than any other region. For 20 years, the Arctic Report Card chronicled the extraordinary transformation.
Authoritarianism isn’t down the street or around the corner — it's here right now.
The For Our Republic Act lays out a clear roadmap of the actions Congress can take to fight back against Trump’s authoritarian takeover and save our republic!https://t.co/3QKQvPhRwa
🚨SEND PETE HOEKSTRA PACKING🚨The House of Commons petition calling for U.S. Ambassador Pete Hoekstra to be declared persona non grata has already reached 56,215 signatures.🔗 Petition e-7531: http://www.ourcommons.ca/petitions/en…🔗 sendpetepacking.ca❤️🍁🇨🇦TEAM CANADA FOREVER🇨🇦🍁❤️❤️🍁🇨🇦VIVE LE CANADA🇨🇦🍁❤️
Donald Trump and Mike Collins want to pay your tax dollars to violent thugs who ransacked the Capitol to undermine our elections and attacked police officers on January 6th. Georgians will vote accordingly. https://t.co/rnkRI1vU5s
I helped pass this law in 2020. It's purpose is to prevent drug traffickers, Russian & Chinese kleptocrats, and other international criminals from setting up anonymously owned companies to hide their money in the US. Trump's Treasury Dept. is doing this to help criminals. 1/ https://t.co/k7zRPDlwoH
"Beneficial ownership information" is just a record of who actually owns a company. That's all that was being reported here, so that we didn't have LLCs in Delaware laundering millions of dollars through the US and into offshore banks on behalf of totally anonymous people. 2/
Treasury deleting the beneficial ownership info it already gathered is utterly crazy. This database was not public — it was just for law enforcement to use in investigating crimes. It's like Trump ordering the deletion of the FBI's fingerprint database. 3/
Why is the Trump administration doing this? I don't know. But it's certainly good news for rich Russians who want to buy his condos, or Gulf royals buying his fake crypto. The true identities of people he's done business with, if registered with Treasury, will now be deleted. 4/
Congress passed a law — with strong Republican support BTW — saying Treasury had to collect and keep beneficial ownership info. The Trump administration cannot say "we're just not going to do it." 5/
*** Personal Note. By Monday things here should be back to normal. Ron will be in Texas driving his sister home. I will have had the weekend to rest. Ron is on his last full day of doing no exertion not even house work. They went into a major artery in his wrist. He had a wrist board to keep the wrist from flexing for 24 hours, shower lightly but leave the large bandaid on. Change the bandaid after showering for 72 hours. Call 911 if it starts to bleed. On Saturday morning he is off restrictions and flies to Texas. Then he and his sister will drive to Florida. She will stay with us for a few days as her house here is emptied and then she will settle her stuff and go to New Hampshire. She is flying up there. Hugs ****
Trump administration health officials are giving serious consideration to a plan that would make injuries from COVID-19 vaccines a formal diagnosis that can be coded in medical records. Increasing documentation of what’s still a loosely defined condition could help lay the groundwork for future lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers.
The ICD-10 system already covers general vaccine injuries and reactions to some specific vaccines, but it doesn’t have a designation for the COVID shot, whose safety has become a major point of contention within the administration.
The new code could allow providers “to identify, track, and study patients who experience adverse effects specifically related to COVID vaccines,” Mary Stanfill, a CDC health information specialist, said during a public meeting on code proposals last week.
Read the full article. You will recall that the cult has claimed that COVID vaccines cause the human body to become literally magnetic, and that they cause “turbo cancer,” autism, miscarriages, myocarditis, pericarditis, hearing loss, and taste loss. Oh, and the vaccines also supposedly contain graphene nanobots meant to connect people to the internet for the purpose of mind control.
Kennedy, a longtime vaccine skeptic, ousted the 17-member Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) earlier this week in a stunning move that shocked medical experts. He defended his action in an interview with Fox News’ Martha MacCallum, claiming that “97% of the people on the committee had conflicts of interest.”
He repeated falsehoods about vaccines that were immediately fact checked by doctors on social media platform X. He falsely claimed there were between 69 and 92 mandatory vaccines in the U.S. today and that most of the vaccines, excluding the COVID-19 vaccine, had not gone through safety tests.
“So nobody has any idea what the risk profiles are on these products, and we don’t know whether they have anything to do with the epidemic of chronic disease,” Kennedy said, presenting no evidence for his claims.
This is a really great video on covid vaccines and why people needed to take them. Tyson explains the social contract, explains why with the first vaccines you might still get a new covid strain, that the vaccine was well studied, and the risk for not taking it. Wonderful video to show every anti-vaxxer. The host is a person on the right, well known right wing media person who pushes the right’s talking point. So him being fully and quickly having his stupidity over the issue displayed to him, his ass handed to him on his own program, with someone who could hold their own and not let the host over talk them or belittle them. It is grand. Hugs